GRUNGE WEEKEND REDUX: SOIL COVERS SOUNDGARDENS “RUSTY CAGE”

Monday, December 17th, 2007 at 12:10pm by

Our Weekend of Grunge found us taking a look back at the genre’s progenitors, examining the relationship between grunge and metal, and even questioning what in the heck grunge actually is and surmising about its demise. What better way to cap off that last thought than by listening to a mostly lame cover of Soundgarden’s “Rusty Cage” by nu-metal torch-bearers Soil? Gone are the raw, aggressive production and soaring Cornell vocals, and in their place are dull, downtuned thuds and weak nu-metal yarls.

There should be a rule; thou shalt not attempt to be Chris Cornell. Thou shalt not cover Soundgarden (unless thou happen to be Operator). Now why’d these guys have to go and ruin a good thing? Check it out on Soil’s MySpace page.

-VN

  • TJ

    I can think of two Soundgarden covers that are actually really awesome:

    DEP doing Jesus Christ Pose
    Johnny Cash doing Rusty Cage.

    Maybe it’s just because Soil sucks.

  • Sammy

    ugh. I liked the cover until the singer ruined it. I don’t hate Soil, normally, but man this song is all about the high register vocals. And the vocals on this cover are further hindered by some bad digital “enhancement”.

  • Wayne

    What TJ said.

  • green&grey

    I actually like(d) Soil, especially when compared to their peers. But this was a bad choice that highlights their limitations.

  • http://www.bastardradio.com Bastard No. 1

    Holy crap. Why do bands release shit this bad? Is there no one in their circle that has the balls to step up, take one for the team and tell these guys to bury this somewhere?

  • Adam

    bury? they should drop this attched to the next nuke we drop just to make sure a shred of it never remains, this is crap with a capital P and i kinda like soil, least i did