Comments on: EXCLUSIVE: THE AUTUMN OFFERING’S MATT MCCHESNEY AND METALSUCKS’ AXL ROSENBERG MAKE NICE! PLUS THE DEBUT OF “THE CURTAIN HITS THE CAST,”THE NEW SINGLE FROM THE AUTUMN OFFERING! http://www.metalsucks.net/2009/04/30/exclusive-the-autumn-offerings-matt-mcchesney-and-metalsucks-axl-rosenberg-make-nice-plus-the-debut-of-the-curtain-hits-the-castthe-new-single-from-the-autumn-offering/ IS FOR LOVERS Fri, 10 Feb 2012 21:01:34 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.2.1 By: TAOFAN. http://www.metalsucks.net/2009/04/30/exclusive-the-autumn-offerings-matt-mcchesney-and-metalsucks-axl-rosenberg-make-nice-plus-the-debut-of-the-curtain-hits-the-castthe-new-single-from-the-autumn-offering/#comment-293717 TAOFAN. Wed, 02 Sep 2009 00:11:58 +0000 http://www.metalsucks.net/?p=14439#comment-293717 Edit Sorry. There old Lead singers name was Dennis. I was thinking of there New Drummer Brian for some reason. Sorry. Edit Sorry. There old Lead singers name was Dennis. I was thinking of there New Drummer Brian for some reason. Sorry.

]]> By: TAOFAN. http://www.metalsucks.net/2009/04/30/exclusive-the-autumn-offerings-matt-mcchesney-and-metalsucks-axl-rosenberg-make-nice-plus-the-debut-of-the-curtain-hits-the-castthe-new-single-from-the-autumn-offering/#comment-293714 TAOFAN. Wed, 02 Sep 2009 00:09:48 +0000 http://www.metalsucks.net/?p=14439#comment-293714 Alright. Really now this is my ENTIRE opinion on there new Album "Requiem". Alright. Really all in all. It Sucks. There are maybe 2-3 good songs on the Album. Its sad to say. I am not one of those people who think "OMG MATT SUCKS". I like the guy. How ever I did not like his Vocals on this Album. Actually let me reprahse my statement before. Inturmental : 4/5 Lyrics 4/5 Vocals 1/5 I'm sorry. The Vocals do NOT match the music. Seriously. This bands greatest works were with Embrace The Gutter and Revelations. Fear Will Cast No Shadow was good but I think the reason it got a lot of Bad reviews was because of just two songs. From Atrophy to Obsession and Silence and Goodbyes. Both of which are good songs but were defiantly a QUANTUM(Not Figuratively speaking) Leap and Change from the work of the first two albums. Matt is a good sing. The Autumn Offering is an Amazing band. Do I prefer Brian(There Old Lead Singer) Over Matt In some ways yes. Some ways no. Again they are both Different. Matty has pipes. He has a good clean vocal and an amazing scream. Brian was ALL growls. Which I quite liked. But, The Instrumentals matched in there first 3 albums with the vocals (By matched sounded like they went well together ect ect.) Reqiuem. None of the songs really sound like the Vocals and the Intermentals. (Yes I have spelling proplems and yes I'm to lazy to correct them. Atleasr I am trying to base my opinion with proof and or reason as to why I belive insteado f just saying "Matt sucks" (which im not saying). The autumn offering has come along way there past 12 or so years they have been aqroudn (Yes they have been around that long). I hope they stick around for awhile more with out any more line up changes (Tommy Church and Matt Johnson and Matt McChesny and the New Drummer Brian are amazzing. Set up) But I wish they would seriously read this as constructive criticism and take into consideration about waht there myspace use to say. Something like "Fighting Against the mainstream ect ect) There first 3 Albums TRULY beyond any doubt had a DISTINCTIVE SOUND. Reqiuem is slowing turning there sound mainstream. I have nothing against bands selling out, Yeah you guys want the main shows. The Festival Tours. Concerts all year round. Media Attention like Slipknot and all them get.But you guys are SLOWLY turning into a Scene Kid band and trust me. All your hardcore fans started listening to you to get away from that shit. Now your sounding just like them. Horns up. Keep up the good work. Lets hope the next Album has some changes to it. Alright. Really now this is my ENTIRE opinion on there new Album “Requiem”. Alright. Really all in all. It Sucks. There are maybe 2-3 good songs on the Album. Its sad to say. I am not one of those people who think “OMG MATT SUCKS”. I like the guy. How ever I did not like his Vocals on this Album.

Actually let me reprahse my statement before.
Inturmental : 4/5
Lyrics 4/5
Vocals 1/5

I’m sorry. The Vocals do NOT match the music. Seriously.
This bands greatest works were with Embrace The Gutter and Revelations.
Fear Will Cast No Shadow was good but I think the reason it got a lot of Bad reviews was because of just two songs. From Atrophy to Obsession and Silence and Goodbyes. Both of which are good songs but were defiantly a QUANTUM(Not Figuratively speaking) Leap and Change from the work of the first two albums.

Matt is a good sing.
The Autumn Offering is an Amazing band.

Do I prefer Brian(There Old Lead Singer) Over Matt In some ways yes. Some ways no.

Again they are both Different. Matty has pipes. He has a good clean vocal and an amazing scream.
Brian was ALL growls. Which I quite liked. But, The Instrumentals matched in there first 3 albums with the vocals (By matched sounded like they went well together ect ect.) Reqiuem. None of the songs really sound like the Vocals and the Intermentals. (Yes I have spelling proplems and yes I’m to lazy to correct them. Atleasr I am trying to base my opinion with proof and or reason as to why I belive insteado f just saying “Matt sucks” (which im not saying).

The autumn offering has come along way there past 12 or so years they have been aqroudn (Yes they have been around that long). I hope they stick around for awhile more with out any more line up changes (Tommy Church and Matt Johnson and Matt McChesny and the New Drummer Brian are amazzing. Set up)
But I wish they would seriously read this as constructive criticism and take into consideration about waht there myspace use to say.

Something like “Fighting Against the mainstream ect ect) There first 3 Albums TRULY beyond any doubt had a DISTINCTIVE SOUND.
Reqiuem is slowing turning there sound mainstream.

I have nothing against bands selling out, Yeah you guys want the main shows. The Festival Tours. Concerts all year round. Media Attention like Slipknot and all them get.But you guys are SLOWLY turning into a Scene Kid band and trust me. All your hardcore fans started listening to you to get away from that shit. Now your sounding just like them.

Horns up. Keep up the good work. Lets hope the next Album has some changes to it.

]]> By: flameboy http://www.metalsucks.net/2009/04/30/exclusive-the-autumn-offerings-matt-mcchesney-and-metalsucks-axl-rosenberg-make-nice-plus-the-debut-of-the-curtain-hits-the-castthe-new-single-from-the-autumn-offering/#comment-234750 flameboy Thu, 04 Jun 2009 12:51:51 +0000 http://www.metalsucks.net/?p=14439#comment-234750 I'm really not a fan of the new track, but then after Fear Will Cast No Shadow I didn't expect much. Autumn Offering were awesome with Dennis Miller, but imo, with the addition if McChesney the band has killed the sound they had perfected and the "new sound" they've found just isn't working, atleast not for me. There's too much out there already like this. Listening to Revelations of the Unsung and Embrace the Gutter makes you realise how great this band could have been. I hope the album does well and everything but this will be the first AO album i'm not buying. I’m really not a fan of the new track, but then after Fear Will Cast No Shadow I didn’t expect much. Autumn Offering were awesome with Dennis Miller, but imo, with the addition if McChesney the band has killed the sound they had perfected and the “new sound” they’ve found just isn’t working, atleast not for me. There’s too much out there already like this. Listening to Revelations of the Unsung and Embrace the Gutter makes you realise how great this band could have been.

I hope the album does well and everything but this will be the first AO album i’m not buying.

]]> By: Chris http://www.metalsucks.net/2009/04/30/exclusive-the-autumn-offerings-matt-mcchesney-and-metalsucks-axl-rosenberg-make-nice-plus-the-debut-of-the-curtain-hits-the-castthe-new-single-from-the-autumn-offering/#comment-227287 Chris Thu, 14 May 2009 03:27:49 +0000 http://www.metalsucks.net/?p=14439#comment-227287 Kick ass! I had these guys on a show last year and they were all very cool and very nice. I like their last 2 albums and am looking forward to this new one. Rock on TAO! Kick ass!

I had these guys on a show last year and they were all very cool and very nice.

I like their last 2 albums and am looking forward to this new one.

Rock on TAO!

]]> By: satans balls http://www.metalsucks.net/2009/04/30/exclusive-the-autumn-offerings-matt-mcchesney-and-metalsucks-axl-rosenberg-make-nice-plus-the-debut-of-the-curtain-hits-the-castthe-new-single-from-the-autumn-offering/#comment-224255 satans balls Mon, 04 May 2009 00:24:58 +0000 http://www.metalsucks.net/?p=14439#comment-224255 say what you want this new song is a solid track that hangs next to anything off the latest killswitch,atr,etc etc why is that not many take notice to this band.i for one love the melody of Matt"s vocals over there previous singer Dennis who could barely do anything other than the typical hardcore scream. say what you want this new song is a solid track that hangs next to anything off the latest killswitch,atr,etc etc why is that not many take notice to this band.i for one love the melody of Matt”s vocals over there previous singer Dennis who could barely do anything other than the typical hardcore scream.

]]> By: Lookie here http://www.metalsucks.net/2009/04/30/exclusive-the-autumn-offerings-matt-mcchesney-and-metalsucks-axl-rosenberg-make-nice-plus-the-debut-of-the-curtain-hits-the-castthe-new-single-from-the-autumn-offering/#comment-223751 Lookie here Fri, 01 May 2009 19:33:18 +0000 http://www.metalsucks.net/?p=14439#comment-223751 Pickin' up chicks, eh? Pickin’ up chicks, eh?

]]> By: alexwank http://www.metalsucks.net/2009/04/30/exclusive-the-autumn-offerings-matt-mcchesney-and-metalsucks-axl-rosenberg-make-nice-plus-the-debut-of-the-curtain-hits-the-castthe-new-single-from-the-autumn-offering/#comment-223709 alexwank Fri, 01 May 2009 17:55:28 +0000 http://www.metalsucks.net/?p=14439#comment-223709 definitely impressed with the song. i thought the last record was pretty cool (but a bit patchy), but if this song is any indication requiem will definitely stand out as a release for me this year. very much looking forward to it. i think the gruff vocals on this one sound way better than on the last one. also a really good interview, especially for a correspondence interview. after reading interviews with so many metal halfwits, one gets indurated to how one-dimensional and thick the majority seem. i hadn't realised until i read this one. matt seems like an articulate, level headed bloke.. tell him to come tour london before the end of the year or australia next year! definitely impressed with the song. i thought the last record was pretty cool (but a bit patchy), but if this song is any indication requiem will definitely stand out as a release for me this year. very much looking forward to it.
i think the gruff vocals on this one sound way better than on the last one.

also a really good interview, especially for a correspondence interview. after reading interviews with so many metal halfwits, one gets indurated to how one-dimensional and thick the majority seem. i hadn’t realised until i read this one. matt seems like an articulate, level headed bloke..

tell him to come tour london before the end of the year or australia next year!

]]> By: Drink Up Bitches http://www.metalsucks.net/2009/04/30/exclusive-the-autumn-offerings-matt-mcchesney-and-metalsucks-axl-rosenberg-make-nice-plus-the-debut-of-the-curtain-hits-the-castthe-new-single-from-the-autumn-offering/#comment-223632 Drink Up Bitches Fri, 01 May 2009 12:37:54 +0000 http://www.metalsucks.net/?p=14439#comment-223632 I like it, much better than their previous effort - the last album was very generic and uninspired to me (hell they toured w/ Dope for a couple months!) hopefully they can find their place w/ this new bad boy I like it, much better than their previous effort – the last album was very generic and uninspired to me (hell they toured w/ Dope for a couple months!) hopefully they can find their place w/ this new bad boy

]]> By: pokesmot http://www.metalsucks.net/2009/04/30/exclusive-the-autumn-offerings-matt-mcchesney-and-metalsucks-axl-rosenberg-make-nice-plus-the-debut-of-the-curtain-hits-the-castthe-new-single-from-the-autumn-offering/#comment-223568 pokesmot Fri, 01 May 2009 03:38:29 +0000 http://www.metalsucks.net/?p=14439#comment-223568 good band matt is a cool dude and a good vocalist I met him in MA when he played in Hell Within good band matt is a cool dude and a good vocalist I met him in MA when he played in Hell Within

]]> By: Cisco http://www.metalsucks.net/2009/04/30/exclusive-the-autumn-offerings-matt-mcchesney-and-metalsucks-axl-rosenberg-make-nice-plus-the-debut-of-the-curtain-hits-the-castthe-new-single-from-the-autumn-offering/#comment-223528 Cisco Fri, 01 May 2009 00:20:55 +0000 http://www.metalsucks.net/?p=14439#comment-223528 Meh... this song sounds like it should have come out in '04 or '05. I've heard it before by another band. Cool guy though, this Matt McChesney. Meh… this song sounds like it should have come out in ’04 or ’05. I’ve heard it before by another band. Cool guy though, this Matt McChesney.

]]> By: b http://www.metalsucks.net/2009/04/30/exclusive-the-autumn-offerings-matt-mcchesney-and-metalsucks-axl-rosenberg-make-nice-plus-the-debut-of-the-curtain-hits-the-castthe-new-single-from-the-autumn-offering/#comment-223473 b Thu, 30 Apr 2009 22:01:10 +0000 http://www.metalsucks.net/?p=14439#comment-223473 yeah. matt, the guy singing is the same one growling. i've loved this band since the beginning. they're a great bunch of guys to chill with yeah. matt, the guy singing is the same one growling. i’ve loved this band since the beginning. they’re a great bunch of guys to chill with

]]> By: CJ http://www.metalsucks.net/2009/04/30/exclusive-the-autumn-offerings-matt-mcchesney-and-metalsucks-axl-rosenberg-make-nice-plus-the-debut-of-the-curtain-hits-the-castthe-new-single-from-the-autumn-offering/#comment-223401 CJ Thu, 30 Apr 2009 20:25:14 +0000 http://www.metalsucks.net/?p=14439#comment-223401 Definitely a cool song. And I loved his voice on the last record and with Hell Within. I'll be picking this one up. Definitely a cool song. And I loved his voice on the last record and with Hell Within. I’ll be picking this one up.

]]> By: CJ http://www.metalsucks.net/2009/04/30/exclusive-the-autumn-offerings-matt-mcchesney-and-metalsucks-axl-rosenberg-make-nice-plus-the-debut-of-the-curtain-hits-the-castthe-new-single-from-the-autumn-offering/#comment-223399 CJ Thu, 30 Apr 2009 20:22:34 +0000 http://www.metalsucks.net/?p=14439#comment-223399 I'm not positive, so don't quote me, but I'm pretty sure Matt does the growls and all the singing, too. I’m not positive, so don’t quote me, but I’m pretty sure Matt does the growls and all the singing, too.

]]> By: mr lun http://www.metalsucks.net/2009/04/30/exclusive-the-autumn-offerings-matt-mcchesney-and-metalsucks-axl-rosenberg-make-nice-plus-the-debut-of-the-curtain-hits-the-castthe-new-single-from-the-autumn-offering/#comment-223393 mr lun Thu, 30 Apr 2009 20:15:24 +0000 http://www.metalsucks.net/?p=14439#comment-223393 the burning red? ooooooooooooooooooooof the burning red? ooooooooooooooooooooof

]]> By: Metal Fuckin' Dave http://www.metalsucks.net/2009/04/30/exclusive-the-autumn-offerings-matt-mcchesney-and-metalsucks-axl-rosenberg-make-nice-plus-the-debut-of-the-curtain-hits-the-castthe-new-single-from-the-autumn-offering/#comment-223385 Metal Fuckin' Dave Thu, 30 Apr 2009 20:09:30 +0000 http://www.metalsucks.net/?p=14439#comment-223385 It sounds like a million other songs...but it least it sounds like a million other good songs. The solos rip. If the rest of the album follows a similar pattern I may pick it up. It sounds like a million other songs…but it least it sounds like a million other good songs. The solos rip. If the rest of the album follows a similar pattern I may pick it up.

]]> By: Daisy May Tinklepants http://www.metalsucks.net/2009/04/30/exclusive-the-autumn-offerings-matt-mcchesney-and-metalsucks-axl-rosenberg-make-nice-plus-the-debut-of-the-curtain-hits-the-castthe-new-single-from-the-autumn-offering/#comment-223361 Daisy May Tinklepants Thu, 30 Apr 2009 19:29:38 +0000 http://www.metalsucks.net/?p=14439#comment-223361 the site will give good reviews to any band that grants them an interview. whores! the site will give good reviews to any band that grants them an interview. whores!

]]> By: JasonfromIKILLYA http://www.metalsucks.net/2009/04/30/exclusive-the-autumn-offerings-matt-mcchesney-and-metalsucks-axl-rosenberg-make-nice-plus-the-debut-of-the-curtain-hits-the-castthe-new-single-from-the-autumn-offering/#comment-223350 JasonfromIKILLYA Thu, 30 Apr 2009 19:20:04 +0000 http://www.metalsucks.net/?p=14439#comment-223350 I thought the songwriting on the last album was excellent. It is a bit whinny in the choruses at times, but overall songs like A Great Distance will probably stay in rotation for me. Looking forward to the new album. Great interview as well. Seems like a really good dude. I thought the songwriting on the last album was excellent. It is a bit whinny in the choruses at times, but overall songs like A Great Distance will probably stay in rotation for me. Looking forward to the new album. Great interview as well. Seems like a really good dude.

]]> By: Beastmaster http://www.metalsucks.net/2009/04/30/exclusive-the-autumn-offerings-matt-mcchesney-and-metalsucks-axl-rosenberg-make-nice-plus-the-debut-of-the-curtain-hits-the-castthe-new-single-from-the-autumn-offering/#comment-223345 Beastmaster Thu, 30 Apr 2009 19:15:21 +0000 http://www.metalsucks.net/?p=14439#comment-223345 Seems like a nice guy. Seems like a nice guy.

]]> By: metalguy http://www.metalsucks.net/2009/04/30/exclusive-the-autumn-offerings-matt-mcchesney-and-metalsucks-axl-rosenberg-make-nice-plus-the-debut-of-the-curtain-hits-the-castthe-new-single-from-the-autumn-offering/#comment-223339 metalguy Thu, 30 Apr 2009 19:10:08 +0000 http://www.metalsucks.net/?p=14439#comment-223339 wow very very good. doesnt sound like embrace the gutter, so im not gonna compare. it kindof resembles devildriver in my opinion. totally pshycked about the new album wow very very good. doesnt sound like embrace the gutter, so im not gonna compare. it kindof resembles devildriver in my opinion. totally pshycked about the new album

]]> By: Double D http://www.metalsucks.net/2009/04/30/exclusive-the-autumn-offerings-matt-mcchesney-and-metalsucks-axl-rosenberg-make-nice-plus-the-debut-of-the-curtain-hits-the-castthe-new-single-from-the-autumn-offering/#comment-223323 Double D Thu, 30 Apr 2009 18:47:07 +0000 http://www.metalsucks.net/?p=14439#comment-223323 I like it, mostly. However, the guy who sings (not growls) sounds like that dude from Linkin Park. Otherwise, I think it's a good track. I like it, mostly. However, the guy who sings (not growls) sounds like that dude from Linkin Park. Otherwise, I think it’s a good track.

]]>