«
»
Br00tal-lists

ANOTHER LIST TO ARGUE ABOUT

 Tuesday, May 19th, 2009 at 10:30am by

noisecreep-logo1Noisecreep have unveiled their list of the Top 10 Death Metal Debut Albums (although the list is in no particular order), courtesy Friend of MetalSucks, Carlos Ramirez.

And for once, I don’t actually have any complaints. The list is pretty good.

That being said, I’m sure you folks will find something to bitch about, so… have at it!!!

-AR

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,
  • http://reaper-x.deviantart.com/ Reaper-X

    No need to argue. They actually didn’t fail at it. These are good bands with good albums. :)

  • Sacajawea

    I only have three of those albums so I can’t do much arguing. The three I have do belong in there though, so that’s good.

  • TWOAF

    The list seems about right.

  • Julian

    Not a bad list, just missing Like an Ever Flowing Stream.

  • Zombie(really)

    List seems fine with me.

  • lkgf09

    what about Altars of Madness? No love for Morbid Angel. Besides that awesome list.

  • CarlosRamirez

    ‘Altars of Madness’ is not Morbid Angel’s debut album. That would actually be ‘Abominations of Desolation.’

  • bob

    Um no…

    Abominations of Desolation is a series of demos that came out in 1991. Altars is their debut full length album, newb.

    This list is cool but Immolation is terrible. Switch them out with Altars.

    • Brock

      You called someone a “newb”. That makes you awesome in internet land.

      • 20 eyes

        haha and he started with “um no..”
        that just sounds snobby.

        i missed the debut part as well. after all its just one little ass word.

  • CarlosRamirez

    Hey Bob,

    First off, I’m definitely not a “newb” dude. I have played in 2 bands with Dave Witte….doesn’t that count for anything?! haha

    Secondly. ‘Abominations of Desolation’ is definitely their first album. They just didn’t like it so it went unreleased for a few years before Earache Records put it out. Mike Browning of Nocturnus was the singer at the time.

  • 36thoughtless

    Seems fine, except no love for Morbid Angel

  • http://www.crescentshield.com Dan

    No Possessed. Fail.

    • iolanach

      Yup, that’s probably the most obvious miss. Other then that, is pretty good. I guess.

      • Joe

        Uhhhh it’s hard to call an album a debut when the first is their only death metal album, as Beyond the Gates is more or less German thrash (but I dig it anyway.)

  • myke

    whats with all the morbid angel hating on that list and no cannibal corpse or even any early carcass come on dude why are you hating!!!!

    • Zombie(really)

      Umm, Cannibal corpse WAS on the list…..

      • metalguy

        and carcass was more grind related when they started

        • Mike

          Not to mention Carcass arn’t American

          • Brock

            Wait, I agree with Carcass being in the grind category, but what does them not being American have anything to do with?

          • myke

            i guess im a retard and read it too fast…lol

  • ashley

    This sucks. I can’t bitch about anything on that list. As far as death metal goes it’s looking pretty good!

  • Mancubus

    Where the FUCK are Alters of Madness, Like an Everflowing Stream, Focus, or Peace of Time? Not one of them got mentioned. WTF?

    • CarlosRamirez

      Altars is NOT Morbid Angel’s debut album. Read the comments above.

  • http://lordsofmetal.nl/index.php?lang=en Cavorka

    Waaaait a minute……where the fuck is PENETRALIA???

  • Mike

    Pesonally I qould have added Cryptopsy, but that’s just me.

  • SonOF

    Good list. I would have added Dismember’s Like an Everflowing Stream (which many people mentioned) and Opeth’s Orchid (although I know that album isn’t death metal in the strictest sense).

  • Malacoda

    Good list.

  • justin

    yup. solid list. i would probably throw “conforming…” by cephalic carnage on my personal list, but otherwise there are no complaints or criticisms.

  • Tim

    A suprisingly well-thought out and complete list. It’s awesome they included Incantation, Onward to Golgotha never gets the credit it deserves for being one of the heaviest, evilest metal albums ever.

  • THE CARL

    Ironically I am a huge death metal fan but apparently not a fan enough considering i have none of those albums. This is one of those rare articles that really opened my eyes. I mean who knew Dark Throne was a more death metal oriented band before they pretty much wrote the book on black metal?

    Great article!

    • Tim

      I got Soulside Journey in ’92 in a tape trade with my friend Eric. I got that and he got Megadeth’s So Far, So Good, So What? It was probably another seven or eight years before I listened to another Darkthrone album. At the time it didn’t compare to Carnage, Entombed, Grave, Dismember, Unleashed, Hypocrisy. Who knew it would be so well regarded nearly twenty years later?

  • Brock

    Pretty good list.

  • Whittemore

    Missing Seven Churches by Possessed

  • http://reaper-x.deviantart.com/ Reaper-X

    This is possibly THE calmest collection of comments on Metalsucks…