TEARGARDEN BY KALEIDYSCOPE: IT’S LIKE A KOALA BEAR CRAPPED A RAINBOW IN MY BRAIN

Friday, September 18th, 2009 at 12:00pm by

corgan44

I became a fan of The Smashing Pumpkins the minute I heard “Drown” (or was it, “Cherub Rock?”), and as such I have followed the work of Billy Corgan throughout the lifespan of that band, not to mention his endeavors both with Zwan and on his own. Though I scoffed at the irrational backlash that accompanied the 2005 reunion sans James Iha and D’arcy Wretzky, I still have to concede that 2007′s Zeitgeist was the weakest Pumpkins release ever, and perhaps the worst album of Corgan’s career to date. The commercial failure of that record and the recent departure of longtime drummer Jimmy Chamberlin raised questions regarding the band’s future, though Corgan seems to have pulled a Page Hamilton (or perhaps an Axl Rose), carrying on with hired guns and invited guests. For you see, he now intends to release 44 new Smashing Pumpkins songs online for free. In the words of my beloved Internets: DO NOT WANT.

As Corgan explains:

Recording began yesterday, September 15th, 2009 on the new record which will be entitled ‘Teargarden by Kaleidyscope’. The album will feature 44 songs, 4 of which are now being recorded. My desire is to release a song at a time beginning around Halloween of this year, with each new release coming shortly after until all 44 are out. Each song will be made available absolutely for free, to anyone anywhere. There will be no strings attached. Free will mean free, which means you won’t have to sign up for anything, give an email address, or jump through a hoop. You will be able to go and take the song or songs as you wish, as many times as you wish.

In light of the lackluster Zeitgeist, the very thought of Teargarden by Kaleidyscope fills me with dread. As my dear friend Svenllama opined on his Twitter account, it’s “the answer to a question nobody was asking.” I guess Corgan figures that he’s a rockstar with brand recognition on par with Radiohead and Nine Inch Nails, two artists who’ve spearheaded and at least initially defined the slowly evolving online release model. (Credit, however, should be given to Corgan for perpetrating one of the earliest free album releases back in 2000: Machina II: The Friends & Enemies Of Modern Music.) Like those bands, Corgan also intends to offer a physical product for the collector’s and Ebay entrepreneurs, promising “highly limited edition EP’s (of 4 songs each times 11)” that “will be more like mini-box sets rather than your normal cd single,” as well as a culminating “deluxe box set” once all of the songs have been released. Like it or not, this is becoming the business plan for legacy acts jaded by years of major label bureaucracy and restrictive contracts. Kudos to Corgan for following suit, but you’ll forgive me if I pass on the “mini box sets” and opt instead to download the digi-freebies and delete at will.

-GS

[Gary Suarez is still just a rat in a cage. He usually manages the consistently off-topic No Yoko No. Say, why don't you follow him on Twitter?]

  • http://infinitybasement.wordpress.com Jon

    Just because you’ve written 44 songs doesn’t mean any of them are any good. Just saying.

  • crank

    Billy Corgan? Moar like Shit, amirite?

    • Urban Outdoorsman

      Ahhhhh Fucking unbelievable how many douchebags comment on here with retarded Points of view. Obnoxious. If you dont at least respect Billy Corgan youre a fucking idiot. Theyre one of thoses bands that when you here you immediately know who it is even if youve never heard the song before. You dont have to ask, you just know by Corgan’s voice. If not for the gigantic, fucking hiatus they went on they would be much bigger than they are. And as for you idiots who comment on their radio songs….get a fucking clue. The fact that they have radio played songs without a doubt works to the idea of how great they are. People bitch when bands sound different and bitch when they fall inline and go mainstream. What the fuck do you want? Id rather make some mainstream shit and make a good living then make a bunch of pissed off underground tracks that all sound the same and never make a name for myself. Fucking constant pissing and moaning.

      • http://www.thejamminjabber.com thejamminjabber

        I disagree. Silly Billy doesn’t deserve my respect. He’s done nothing to earn it. Just because he’s in a band a lot of people like doesn’t mean I have to kiss his ass. I like plenty of his music, but dude is a colossal douche and thinks way too highly of himself.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Chris-Cefaratti/542463984 Chris Cefaratti

    I already have two Pumpkin box sets I don’t need a 3rd filled with lackluster tracks.
    Oxbow needs a vinyl box set now that would be great.

  • http://www.last.fm/user/markandrew78 alexwank

    Lisa Simpson is the answer to a question no one asked…..

  • cougar party

    I used to love these guys when I was younger. Siamese Dream is still an epically great album. That being said, the pumpkins have sucked BAD for quite awhile now. The double album and the aeroplane flies high box set were the last good products they put out. After that, it just got boring….really boring.

  • http://bsisserson@gmail.com nairbs

    old devin townsend wannabe ass nigga.. haha

  • http://www.metalsucks.net/ Sammy O’Hagar

    Ah, trying to redeem yourself with your fans after releasing your last album in 4 slightly different variations to make sure the Smashing Pumpkins faithful could shell out as much cash as possible.

    I think this has less to do with Billy Corgan being cool and more to do with the fact that Sr. Corgan realizes that no one is gonna buy new shitty Smashing Pumpkins records anyway, so why not GIVE it away.

    • DemonicLemming

      This. I don’t see Corgan trying to do a “fan appreciation” thing like Trent Reznor did, I think it’s more of the fact that it’d be a waste of time to try and actually sell albums with new songs on it.

  • http://uponwingsofblack.blogspot.com/ \m/Eluveitie\m/

    Homer Simpson, smiling politely

    • ThisIsNecessary

      “A walk-in humidor!”

    • Damotello

      If it’s brown drink it down, if it’s black send it back!

  • Driven9

    I could really care less. I think theres something to be said about a band whos best songs were the ones played on the radio. OVERRATED

  • zhitnik

    Don’t care much about the article, but I just wanted to say nice Sealab 2021 reference in the title…love that show.

  • fightingmike

    I think Billy is a great songwriter and i think some of his best songs are his mellower, folky ones, like from the Spun soundtrack. I dont think any new rockin songs will be the same without Jimmy, but i will totally download the stuff for free!!!

  • http://www.solidsterecords.com NoCowNoFood

    I agree with fightingmike whatever is free its free.. I actually admire Corgan for keeping the SP flag high after all these years however I guess I would change the name of the band because of the new members

  • braincake

    nothing good since gish and siamese dream.

  • http://www.thejamminjabber.com thejamminjabber

    Little Billy obviously doesn’t understand the concept of quality over quantity.

    http://thejamminjabber.com/2009/09/17/billy-corgan-obviously-doesnt-understand-the-concept-of-quality-over-quantity/

  • Bill

    I am a Pumpkins fan from the first time I saw the video for I Am One on 120 minutes.

    I loved all their early albums.Gish is still one of my favorite albums of all time and Siamese Dream was pretty much the defining record for the early post-grunge era. Hole’s Live Through This might as well been another great Pumpkins record as Billy wrote almost the whole damn thing himself. Courtney Love actually was a good creative partner on that record too, which added to it’s success I think. Mellon Collie is probably one of the best concept albums ever made. Adore is another great, underrated album. Then they started to lose the thing that made them so great from the beginning: melody and musicianship.

    Where you can argue that it has always been Billy’s band, D’arcy, James and Jimmy were a great creative filter for Billy. They kept him on track and the band making awesome music together. D’arcy and James bolted and Jimmy killed their keyboard layer (in so many words). It was pretty much a recipe for creative disaster. While I really liked Machina, it didn’t really feel like a Pumpkins record. It had some good, heavy tracks, but the melody and the complex, layered guitars were absent. I can understand that Billy was probably looking to evolve the sound, but he lost what made them so great.

    I enjoyed the Zwan side project and got to see them live. In typical Corgan fashion, the show was fantastic and his playing was phenomenal. It was like a creative release for him, he got the garage band sound, the rawness, the back to basics out of his system. The whole band contributed to the creative process.

    So with Zeitgeist, I totally expected a return to form, but was a bit disappointed. While I like the album, on the whole, it’s definitely the band’s weakest release to date. There were some signs of the old Pumpkins in there, the screeching vocals, some of the guitar work, but it lacked the spirit of the old band. So it’s tough to be optimistic about the new stuff. I think the young kid on drums will be good for Billy. A little youthful spirit. The new guitar and bass players are totally interchangeable with a million other players out there though, which is something D’arcy and James were not. Their musicianship aside, they kept Billy grounded and in check. When he’s free to run wild and make all the decisions, the music suffers. Billy’s solo album was god awful. He’s an extremely talented musician and he CAN be a great songwriter, but he needs competent musicians around him to keep him on track creatively. Billy seems to have turned into a greedy, sullen old egotistical maniac. Calling your fans onstage to berate them? Telling fans who want an encore “If you wanted to hear more music, you should have bought the fucking album”? I mean what the fuck can he possibly expect? He never once thought maybe people just didn’t like the album. Maybe his audience left him. Now he’s got to get them back.

    While I really want the new material to be great, I’m not terribly optimistic. I hope Billy proves me wrong. I mean seriously, kick ass new Alice in Chains material and (what I hope to be) great new Pumpkins stuff, how awesome could the next few months potentially be?

    • Bill

      oh yeah, words……..words……….

    • http://infinitybasement.wordpress.com Jon

      You’re Billy Corgan aren’t you?

      • dot

        if that were corgan, he’d regret ever fucking courtney love.

        • Bill

          Courntey is a fine and misunders………..

          HEY, WAIT A MINUTE!!!!!!!!!

  • Sven

    Huge Smashing Pumpkins fan for many years, despite the litany of dissapointments (Adore, half of Machina, breaking up, the shittiness that was Zwan, 2/3rds of Zeitgiest). I was obsessed with them for many years.

    I saw them live in 2007 and they put on a great show – long and deep sets, and the best lighting rigs I’ve ever seen.

    I’ve been waiting for Corgan to get his fury back – the guy can play his ass off, and has a wicked scream, but oversimplified riffs and autotune seem to be his modus operandi at this moment. And his attitude of the cross-bearing rock and roll mascot is beyond tired.

    In the meantime, for me, Coheed and Cambria swooped in and filled the void of earnest, somewhat annoyingly-voiced concept rock. They’re infinitely better musicians, they’ve long had the prog and well-established concept elements that Corgan only half-assedly reached for in more recent years, and perhaps most importantly, they don’t seem to have open contempt for their fans. Listening back to SP seems utterly infantile now. It’s like watching old cartoons you loved as a kid, only to find that they haven’t held up too well with age, and a feeling of disillusionment follows.

    Unless the new shit is astoundingly good, furious and heavy, I don’t forsee any kind of Smashing Pumpkins resurgence whatsoever.

  • CYN1C

    Why is this here?

    More importantly, why does this guy keep writing at MS?

  • kingheadcrab

    yay, sealab bitches

  • Simon Threadgate

    Cool song Drown, Singles soundtrack.

    that is all.

  • wackomann

    This is total out-of-date comment fail, but…

    Stimutacs or Gleemonex?