BTBAM ARE LIKE THE PHISH OF METAL

Wednesday, December 2nd, 2009 at 3:00pm by

between-the-buried-and-me-bandphishrs0303

Maybe I smoked one too many spliffs laced with Old Bay (Adella Place Summer ’97 what what), but very early during my second listen-through of Between the Buried and Me’s new album The Great Misdirect, I couldn’t help but make the comparison to that old jam band who used to dork out onstage in the form of soloing whilst bouncing on trampolines……or, if you will, tramapolines.

Some might make other comparisons, but please allow me to explain.

Both bands have insanely choreographed suite-like songs that ebb and flow, wax (on) and wane (off).

Both bands are musical equivalents of a heaping plate of spaghetti bolognese — a shit-ton of noodles with almost enough meat (but you always want more).

Both bands are silly.

Both bands make thinly veiled attempts to mimic country grooves, and neither succeed very well (although the novelty seems appreciated by fans).

Both bands display both a formidable sense of musical prowess and unfortunate lack of SOUL. For further explanation on the latter, feel free to consult my man BP.

Both bands LOVE ham n cheesing it up (not unlike John C. Reilly in Boogie Nights).

Both bands seem like they’d be equally crazy and annoying to trip out to.

Both bands suffer from adult ADD.

Both bands get a leel too big for their britches sometimes.

Both bands are capable of inducing musical orgasm if the listener has an open mind.

Am I wrong?!? Remember, you’re definitely wrong, so how off could I be?

-KW

  • andre

    I had this exact thought this morning while listening to Colors for the first time while walking to the train. Thanks for reading my mind, The Internet.

    • DustintheWind

      Tramampoline!!!! Trabompaline!!!!!

  • dicknballs

    I woud have to agree with this…sadly I think they missed the mark with The Great Misdirect and tried just a bit too hard.

  • FuckinEh

    I have tried many times to get into BTBAM, i even saw em live and i just cant get stoked about their music. its by no means terrible and they are definitly talented musicians and stuff, but their music does nothing for me.

    • Facebook User

      Yeah. I just don’t get this band. Even after repeated listens it still just sounds like overly complicated noise.

      • cosk!

        i also do not understand why people revere this band so highly

        • Alex_P

          I get why people don’t like them, but for me it’s music I can feel. It’s like I get lulled by the onslaught of death-metal/metalcore, and then thrown off guard by undiluted prog prowess. Songs like Son of Nothing illustrate my example. I think they only work within the context of albums.

  • infern0

    When I saw phish this past summer I felt the same way. a phish show is fucking giant party!

  • ryan

    A+ post Kip!

  • Awful Offal Carnage

    I can’t comment on BTBAM, but Phish is pretty gay.

    I felt this was relevant.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A8bFEAWgZAs

    • josh

      phish is pretty awesome!

  • Donk

    What in the fuck, how do you compare Phish to Btbam? In no way similar. I think btbam has broken out of the metal mold that so many bands follow, this band deserves praise if anything else. If you are a fan of Opeth on any level you should be able to enjoy the fuck out of them.

    • dylan

      well said, this post is bullshit

    • stu1

      I think the comparison makes perfect sense on many levels and the fact you say they’ve broken out of the metal mold, adds more credence to that.

    • therealmetalmatt

      I’m a huge Opeth fan, and I can’t enjoy the fuck out of BTBAM. Their music does nothing for me

      • Alkahest

        Opeth are boring, imo. They’re Snorlax’s favorite band,

    • gibberish

      I’d say Opeth and BTBAM are opposite ends of the same genre spectrum. They both play proggy-death-whateveryouwanttocallit, and both are insanely talented groups of guys, but BTBAM focus on being technical, and Opeth focus on feeling. Opeth gets the edge there for me personally, although I liked The Great Misdirect. Couldn’t get into Colors, though.

      • Donk

        Btbam is directly influenced by Opeth. Look it up.

        • gibberish

          I’ll prolly just take your word for it

      • http://www.facebook.com/people/Brandon-Fountain/1391790047 Brandon Fountain

        If BTBAM could grasp the soul that Opeth has, it would almost make them a powerhouse. Still, BTBAM should cut back on the spastic ADD parts.

      • msv81

        I agree about Opeth and emotion/BTBAM and lack thereof. I hate to sound like a broken record every time BTBAM are mentioned, but I simply can’t get into them; their music sounds completely emotionless while being technical for technicality’s sake.

        • Spwee

          We will wait for the Opeth and BTBAM collaborative album. It will probably end up like TIm Mcgraw and Lady Gaga playing together though…or new Coke

  • bucketochicken

    “Picture of Nectar” is a fucking incredible album.

    That is all.

  • Natalie

    I bet you that tastes good.

  • mahkiavelli

    I’d have to disagree. BTBAM actually does something interesting with their music, whereas Phish bores the living shit out of me.

  • Jimmy

    “Both bands make thinly veiled attempts to mimic country grooves, and neither succeed very well (although the novelty seems appreciated by fans).

    Both bands display both a formidable sense of musical prowess and unfortunate lack of SOUL. For further explanation on the latter, feel free to consult my man BP.”

    Have to disagree. Also, BTBAM arent boring like Phish.

  • A-ron

    my thoughts exactly, while listening to Disease, Injury, Madness the first thing i thought of was Phish. I myself am a very big Phish head, pretty much the only band i would rape who dont play brutal metal. Much obliged sir, much obliged

  • Strapping Young Lad

    hahahah can’t wait to show this to my roommate. He’s a HUUUGE Phish head and hates metal. maybe this will open his mind a little, or at least give him a chuckle.

  • msv81

    Why the fuck are we talking about Phish on this site?

  • I killed a Dunky

    Kip Wingerschmidt u dont know crap abut music how can u say something like this… FAIL BING TIME

  • KC

    Being from NC I’ve always loved BTBAM, but these last two albums are wearing thin on me quickly. Alaska in my opinion, was fucking perfect and I still listen to that album at least once a week. Its not that Colors and Great Misdirect are bad albums at all. They are both good albums, but if I wanted pretentious post rock/metal sounding crap I’d listen to Russian Circles or Explosions in the Sky. With BTBAM I expect some badass technical metal, and that’s not what they are anymore. Oh well, at least I still have the first 3 albums.

  • http://infinitybasement.wordpress.com Jon L.

    Colors > The Great Misdirect

  • Cameron

    Just because they don’t have a black guy, doesn’t mean they don’t have SOUL! Well, kinda… yeah, pretty much.

  • Ramp

    BTBAM are gods. All who can’t get into them you haven’t listened to them enough. I would say that colors is the better album, but the Great Misdirect is a great song.. Obfuscation is an amazing song.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jake-Ryan/596440962 Jake Ryan

    i just finished listening to the great misdirect for the first time. i am severely underwhelmed. colors is my favorite album of all time and i had such high hopes for this album. needless to say i’m pretty fuckin bummed…

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jeffrey-Bialos/770719073 Jeffrey Bialos

    Manowar is like the beatles of metal. Chicks chase them around (eastern) europe. Their songs are accessible but have depth. One member has absolutely no talent.

    nah i’m just being an a$$hole.