THE HARD R: DALLAS COYLE’S NON TOP 20

Tuesday, December 22nd, 2009 at 11:22am by

The Hard R with Dallas Coyle
I’ve lost interest in metal. Playing it that is. I LOVE listening though. I listened to Chimaira’s Resurrection in it’s entirety and didn’t even realize it was in its entirety. Bad ass record! Born Of Osiris has been in my play list lately as well. But Dallas Coyle’s (yes, third person) output/creation of metal music has been nil on the metal front. I’ve written some rock, some trip hop, some electronica — But no metal.

I haven’t done a blog in a while because I don’t have the passion to write about metal either. There are an alleged amount of reasons I suspect are contributing to my lack of metal inspiration, none of which I can say is a direct culprit. None of which is the sole reason I’m not ‘metaled’ up right now.

Reason #1

This site is becoming more popular and I feel obligated to write something that relates to the metal scene. Since there is more of a demand for metal blogomania at Metalsucks I feel I shouldn’t talk about Susan Boyle or Tiger Woods. BUT, when the election was happening I didn’t mind talking shit about McCain or Hillary Clinton? Weird right? But the site didn’t have the traffic it does now. I don’t get it myself. Shouldn’t I want MORE people to read what I write? Like I said, I have no idea! I’m an enigma wrapped in a shitty cooked grilled onion. The enigma stinks and so does the onion :) My brother’s latest blog about Killswitch was better than anything I’ve ever written for my blog so maybe I’m waiting for him to step in. Wait. I’m not in God Forbid anymore so I should stop expecting Doc to cover for me. Dammit. I never should have quit!

Reason #2

I don’t have anything to shamelessly promote! That’s it. That’s the direct culprit! I’ve been so unproductive, so uninspired, that I, the big mouth, can’t find ANYTHING I feel worthy to promote for myself. Dammit. Rock bottom!

www.polyesterdreams.com
www.coylemedia.ning.com

Reason #3

Baroness is the old Mastodon but people don’t have old Mastodon anymore so they have to listen to the new Baroness. But when new Baroness turns into new Mastodon who are they going to turn to for a #2 record of the year?

Reason #4

I didn’t think this year in metal was as good as everyone else thought it was. Seriously. This year in metal was bullshit den a motherfucker… Listen, I LIKE Mastodon a ton. I love the dudes. Shit, Brent hooked me up with half a xanax once… BUT… when the world hangs from ANYONE’S nuts I tend to back away. And from Mastodon I have backed away.  I LOVE Leviathan. LOVE it. But Crack The Skye ain’t what all you ball-hangers are saying it is. It’s a good record. I like it. Hey, I listen to it. But JESUS CHRIST, get off the MOTHERFUCKING NUTS! Blood Mountain was better! Josh Homme was on that RECORD! He’s super famous!

I don’t have a top 20, niggas. I have honorable mentions. And a #1.

Honorable Mentions

Eryn Non Dae – Hydra Lernaia (For being french as fuck)
Lamb Of God – Wrath (For being my favorite band since 1998)
Poison The Well – The Tropic Rot (For being ahead of their time)
God Forbid – Earthsblood (For being ghetto and metal and true at the same time)
Meshuggah – Obzen (this is a 2 year-old record… fuck you)
Five Finger Death Punch – Ivan Moody’s Voice (like silk, son)
Oceano – Depths (For being mad depthful, the kings of noise, and for giving me a free shirt via Doc Coyle of God Forbid)
Alice In Chains – Black Gives Way To Blue (for keeping success with a black singer)
All Shall Perish (For making Kirk Hammetts decade list: Congrats!)
Burnt By The Sun – Heart Of Darkness (The record kicks old people pussy)
Despised Icon – Day Of Mourning (For sparking that drum triggering debate months back)
Dirge Within – Force Fed Lies (For writing good metal and Shaun Glass sticking it through)
Divinity – The Singularity (For catching the ear of Axl and Vince and making me listen)
Behemoth – Evangelion (For being Behemoth… again)
Megadeth – Endgame (For not making #1, Dave)
Volbeat - Catalog ( Cause they are metal-ass guidos: or Life Of Agony)
Joe Duplantier (For being better than every one else)
Rammstein – Liebe ist für alle da (For having a porn for a video: seriously)
Periphery (For being the only hope in 2010)
System Of A Down (For being ignored this decade: I LOVE YOU, CATS! LOAN ME $500!)

And the #1 record of 2009 is……. and it’s so renowned I have to do it album-first!

CRACK THE SKYE – MASTODON!

I’m hanging from those nuts, dogs! I know there’s enough room with those fannie pack-wearing, bearded-hippie Dethklok-watching, Elvis Costello glasses-having and 1600 SAT-scoring college graduates to hang from the Mastodon balls! It’s Mastodon: a huge motherfuckin’ creature with HUGE motherfuckin’ earth shattering balls!

Over and out.

-DC

[Check out a recent radio interview Dallas did. It's free to download! -Ed.]

  • http://schenkeltown.blogspot.com SchenkelTown

    hey that’s great…..when you rejoin God Forbid, and YOU WILL, I bet this posting will seem funny to you.

    I posted my top ten!

    schenkeltown.blogspot.com

    • RockOutWithMy…YouKnow

      eminem? yuck…

      • http://schenkeltown.blogspot.com SchenkelTown

        that’s why it’s MY top 10. Thanks for at least checking it out though!

    • Baldish

      +1 for Eminem making the list. Relapse was an awesome record. I don’t know why CTS is getting so much praise, I mean I know its a good CD but not worthy of all the top spots. Also, Carver City wasn’t nearly as good as An Answer Can Be Found. Carver City just didnt sound that good to me. Over all, nice list

    • joshkid

      wow thats wierd. I fuckin love Relapse. I listen to metal all day, but Eminem is the only rapper I listen to.
      And he is way fuckin awesome!!!

      • SonOF

        “Relapse” would have been 75% better if Em didn’t have this bizarre need to CONSTANTLY rap in a stupid quasi- Arab/Mexican/cartoon character voice. Seriously, why does he do this? It makes sometimes really good verses sound silly, often making the listener assume Em has nothing useful to say (when he often DOES). He has some AWESOME verses on Relapse; I only realized that after I gave the album (and the dumbshit accents) a few chances…unfortunately, many people didn’t. Maybe when you are as good as Em, shit starts to get boring/repetitive, and the voices are a way to make it interesting, but they are super obnoxious.

        note: I know Em has been doing different voices (like himself as a child, women’s voices, his mom, etc) since Slim Shady LP, but that was different. Those voices served a purpose (to tell a story, accent something); they were original and made Eminem who he was. The voices and accents on Relapse (and some of Encore) serve litte purpose other than to sound silly..but they don’t work. they are just annoying and make quality lyrics appear stupid.

        • Superhans

          +1 i’ve heard a few of his new ones and the moment he does those voices i just switch off and think of his tracks that he has something to say

        • John

          Yeah, the voice is hard to get past at first. It took me quite a few listens to really get past it, but according to him he started using the accent because it made it easier for him to rhyme certain words that really shouldn’t be rhyming. He was already really good at that though…so the accents and shit are kind of off-putting. I don’t care…once I got past that I really got into the record…his flow is as good as it’s ever been.

          • SonOF

            I just read an interview with Em in that Ecko magazine (Complex?), and he claims the drugs were still getting out of his system with Relapse (or something along those lines), and he knows some of it is just silly for the sake of silly. Supposedly Relapse 2 is going to be a beast, much more serious and generally some high quality stuff. Get excited.

    • Dallas

      It already seems funny to me. I don’t get your logic?

    • Dallas

      Your blog is funny man!

      • http://schenkeltown.blogspot.com SchenkelTown

        i like your blog, even if it pains you to write it!

        • DALLAS

          You write screenplays? We should talk. I’m interested in the one you’re writing now. The one you described on your blog.

          • http://schenkeltown.blogspot.com SchenkelTown

            yeah man. it’s coming along. i’ve kind of hit a wall, or writer’s block with it, but it’s coming along!

    • http://www.myspace.com/adeadissue Z?

      My radio show Metal Medicine will have its own TOP of 2009 tonight at 11pmEST on http://www.metalmedicine.net Just click on the Listen LIVE button!!!

      There won’t be Megadeth, Mastadon, Suicide Silence, or Baroness. So sad…..

  • skip crackers

    that ending was priceless…..”i’m hanging off those nuts, dogs!” hahaha

  • http://dcmetalreview.wordpress.com/ Dan-O

    Fucking great post man! Hanging off those nuts indeed!

  • key

    funny, when i went to see dethklok and mastodon it was definitely all hipsters there for mastodon. the sentence structure is confusing but i’m pretty sure you implied the opposite.

    • Glorious Johnson

      whenever a band has crossover appeal i feel thats when the hipsters/douche bags move in. there was definently a dude in a northface that wasnt please with the amount of herb i was burning next to him at that show. can’t blame the band tho

  • bearbomb

    “I didn’t think this year in metal was as good as everyone else thought it was.”

    THANK YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    • Biff Tannen

      thats simply because you have no taste. There was TONS of good metal released this year,probably the best year of the decade. YOU just don’t look hard enough. You wait for it to be on an end cap at best buy or hot topic. There is a mountain of awesome music out there if you are willing to look for it.

      • Ryan

        For once I will agree with what you say. You can’t just expect awesome music to come and fall into your lap, you’ve got to look for it.

        • Fufkin

          I have to agree in part – it was definitely a strong year for metal, but it was the kind of metal you have to search out because it wasn’t going to find you.

      • bearbomb

        Please Biff. You know that I like RATM and Pantera, only because half your posts on this site consist of you bitching and trolling about those bands, otherwise you have no idea what I like. Wow, Biff spends a ton of time on the internet scouring for cool new bands that have yet to be signed or discovered. WHO DOESN’T?! I don’t feel the need to name drop the bands that I’ve discovered because my comments (most of the time) relate to the posts. If you wanna know what bands I’ve discovered through my hours upon hours of daily, extensive research, how ’bout you just fucking ask? Quite frankly I’ve given a lot of bands recommended by MS posters a chance and a lot of them, not all, but a lot of them, just don’t do it for me. Listen, it was a good year for metal, NOT GREAT. I can only jiz myself over Crack The Skye so much before I’m just fooling myself. CTS is a good album that fits nicely into the Mastodon catalogue, such is the year 2009 in the history of metal.

  • Hammer_Smashed_Hurtt

    Nothing I can come up with can possibly make Dallas look more like Toolbag than what he comes up with himself.

    A job well done sir on another installment of The Flacid R:

    • !?!

      20

    • stu1

      Agreed.

    • Biff Tannen

      Hammer 2012 !!! Well said…this guy is painful to read. Shitty music as well.

      • Nick from hell

        My thoughts exactly. Why so many people are “hanging from his nuts” is a complete mystery, to me. His entries never fail to give me douche chills.

        • Ali

          Don’t read them then. Although, I’ve got to admit I only read his stuff because I love God Forbid – he ain’t the best blogger

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Colin-OConnor/1491245262 Colin O’Connor

      HaHaHa.

  • http://MetalchupaS! Raulito666

    What the fuck Dallas…rejoin the group already..

  • http://jordanmunson.wordpress.com Jordan Munson

    Your description for Mastodon at #1 is the exact reason I hate Boston. Fucking hipsters. Crack the Skye is mediocre. Thought that from the get-go, glad to see someone else on board (I know there’s plenty of people who are).

    • http://raiseyerfists.wordpress.com Liam

      Boston hates you too.

      Why does Dallas still post here?

    • inhumanrampager

      The House of Blues is such a shitty venue. Sure sound quality is great, but security pisses me off.

      As for those hipsters, I also blame Dethklok. As much as I love them, there’s a ton of people who like them that don’t actually listen to metal.

      • Patrick

        Why does everyone hate hipsters so much? I would really like a logical explanation. Obviously they like the music, what gives a non-hipster the right to say hey your a hipster you can’t be at a metal show. I’m not a hipster nor do I dress like a metalhead, Am I allowed to go to a metal show? Hipsters listen and love metal, deal with it. Stop being ignorant hating douches and except people for who they are and that maybe people just like music.

        • http://jordanmunson.wordpress.com Jordan Munson

          How many actual hipsters do you know? I know a TON, and I fucking hate them. I don’t care that they go to metal shows. They’re just EVERYWHERE in Boston. They saturate all the places I like to go see live music with all the crappy things that hipsters happen to like and find so cool at the moment. While they’re all extreme examples, latfh.com pretty much sums up all the reasons I hate hipsters, independent of their musical tastes.

          • http://jordanmunson.wordpress.com Jordan Munson

            Also, it’s worth noting, that hating hipsters and not liking the new Mastodon that much are not related – they’re just two things that are closely associated lately (including in this post).

          • stu1

            What is it that “they” do and why does it bother you so much? And can you define what a hipster is, exactly?

          • Sean Williams

            i think people just need to cool their jets on these scenes in general– on both sides. if you like your music you shouldnt have to affiliate with any group to like it. i like metal across the board, but i’m just who i am, i don’t need to fit into some peg to like it. on the other side, leave people the fuck alone who decide to, if thats their thing hey, why the hell should you care? i think your blowing it way up for whatever reason and its bugging the shit out of you unnaturally.
            and no offense to jordan (even though this shouldnt be offensive but to him it probably will be) you look pretty much like a stereotypical in your pic. beard, hat… i think you are what you hate.

          • Sean Williams

            i apologize for the unreadableness of this post… should really proofread…

          • stu1

            SeanWilliams- Totally what I thought. His pic looks like what I generally hear people complaining about regarding “hipsters” at metal shows.

          • Jordan Munson

            @Sean – No offense taken, I realize I look like a hipster. It’s a mere coincidence, I’m not one who is overly concerned with having my appearance fit in with whatever “scene” I associate with. I could dress to fit many at this point.

            @stu1 – If you read the comments below, it pretty much sums it up (my definition of a hipster, and why it is they bother me so much). They like the allure of liking metal and being a metalhead, but not so much being one. With hipsters, it’s all about image and portrayal, not action (another example is how most hipsters are in love with cameras, but few are “real” photographers, and use their nice DSLRs on automatic settings, or buy vintage cameras because it’s cool, not for the quality of picture it takes on film, which they ideally should). Many hipsters buy vinyl because it’s “cool” and “vintage” instead of buying it for the audio quality.

            Though it may not seem it, I’m not normally a very judgmental person. I just don’t like it when any group of people latches onto something I love and ruins it, like hipsters are doing with metal in Boston. I feel the same about “hardcore kids” (it’s really the “deathcore kids” who show up to something and are disappointed when there are no breakdowns, and they hardcore dance at tiny bars to songs that aren’t -core, ruining the experience for everyone else).

            So, y’all can bash me, flame me, etc. about my hate for hipsters, but I really don’t give two shits, because I’m not going to get my panties in a bunch over comments on a blog. That would be fucking retarded. I just wonder how many of you live in a place where the hipsters and deathcore kids have saturated every metal show to the point where it’s become unbearable.

          • stu1

            Jordan- Being that I’ve been to metal shows in Boston very recently, I can assure you I live in a place with far more of BOTH of what you’re describing.

          • stu1

            Biff- I’m in Los Angeles.

          • anthony

            So your best arguement for hating hipsters (fuck knows what a hipster is anyway, must be some bs yankee thing) is their existence and presence in public? Fucking Glorious!

          • Jordan Munson

            @stu1 — I’m sorry, that must be awful. Are you in need of a metal man hug?

        • SonOF

          Hipsters don’t “listen and love metal,” that’s the point. These are the type of people that talk shit about metal and metalheads and look down their noses (and thick black glasses) at the metal scene in general. But somehow they forget their normal rules when it comes to a tiny handful of bands (Mastodon being the ringleader) which are somehow exempt and OK (even cool) to like. It’s not the look of these Hipsters which angers metalheads (well maybe it does, but that isn’t the main issue), it’s their attitude. Hipsters like Mastodon, but they would make fun of a longhair in a Slayer shirt if they saw him on the street.

          I’m also a metal lover who doesn’t necessarily look the part (pretty average looking dude; school teacher), but my attitude is completely pro-metal, I support the scene (go to shows, buy merch), I embrace my fellow metal heads (regardless of how smelly) as long as their are passionate and (hopefully) at least semi-knowledgeable. No one wants these jerkoff hipsters to bring their smug, self-important attitudes to our shows…I guess that’s the easiest way of looking at at.

          • Patrick

            show me proof that hipsters don’t love metal. really do I don’t think you can

          • Sean Williams

            see, those people your describing just sound like douche bags, can we just lump them into that category? i like mastodon and baroness because their fucking unbelievable, not because their trendy. i have a beard. so i guess in some circles that would make me a “hipster,” but i don’t dress like a retard. i like what everyone seems to think is more metal then the aforementioned bands, ie SYL, megadeth, sabbath, opeth, amon amarth, judas priest, etc. so for these people who do piss over really any good band and dress like wannabe homos, lets just call them douche bags, mmmkay?

        • Biff Tannen

          “Hipsters listen and love metal, deal with it.” No they don’t. They like it ‘ironically’. Hipsters are vapid, souless people that cannot create. they can only invade,then suck all value out of whatever it is they find cool (in an ironic sense,of course) at the moment, then move on to a new trend. They are fake and plastic people.

          • stu1

            So what exactly is a “hipster?” SOmeone who goes to metal shows but doesn’t like other types of metal? There’s obviously some fashion code here, right?
            Hipsters like Mastodon because it’s ironic? Or do they wear Slayer shirts because it’s ironic?
            Is it possible that my friend in a shoe gazer band, with his tight pants, sports jacket and low v neck t shirt ACTUALLY really likes Testament and Celtic Frost and Sepultura and Megadeth? Are you qualified to speak on behalf of everyone on what ALL hipsters do?
            The term “hipster” is so fucking gay, it’s ridiculous. It’s the same with the term “emo” that gets tossed around. So fucking stupid.

          • Biff Tannen

            where do you live, Stu ?? Come to Chicago and you will learn exactly what a hipster is. And yes, we do need a new word for these vapid wastes of oxygen

          • stu1

            Los Angeles, Biff.

        • Noel

          hipsters suck ass because they dont really like anything they listen to or do, they partake in these things because theyre hip. get it? hip. their trendhoppers.

      • http://raiseyerfists.wordpress.com Liam

        And the $6 Pabsts. That’s some bullshit.

        • The M_F Beard

          I don’t know what a hipster is, do we have them in the UK ? Today I was listening to Incubus’ S.C.I.E.N.C.E without a hint of irony. Just thought I’d share that.

          • Hammer_Smashed_Hurtt

            I actually dig incubus

            +1 Good Sir

          • SonOF

            M_F Beard: Hipsters seem to be more of an American phenomenon, but I’m sure a similar type of individual exists in the UK.

            A Hipster:

            “Listens to bands that you have never heard of. Has hairstyle that can only be described as “complicated.” (Most likely achieved by a minimum of one week not washing it.) Probably tattooed. Maybe gay. Definitely cooler than you. Reads Black Book, Nylon, and the Styles section of the New York Times. Drinks Pabst Blue Ribbon. Often. Complains. Always denies being a hipster. Hates the word. Probably living off parents money – and spends a great deal of it to look like they don’t have any. Has friends and/or self cut hair. Dyes it frequently (black, white-blonde, etc. and until scalp bleeds). Has a closet full of clothing but usually wears same three things OVER AND OVER (most likely very tight black pants, scarf, and ironic tee-shirt). Chips off nail polish artfully after $50 manicure. Sleeps with everyone and talks about it at great volume in crowded coffee shops. Addicted to coffee, cigarettes (Parliaments, Kamel Reds, Lucky Strikes, etc.), and possibly cocaine. Claims to be in a band. Rehearsals consist of choosing outfits for next show and drinking PBR. Always on the list. Majors or majored in art, writing, or queer studies. Name-drops. May go by “Penny Lane,” “Eleanor Rigby,” etc. when drunk. On PBR. Which is usually.”

            *************************************************************************
            or, seemingly from the view of the hipster himself (“boy are we great!”):

            “Hipsters are a subculture of men and women typically in their 20′s and 30′s that value independent thinking, counter-culture, progressive politics, an appreciation of art and indie-rock, creativity, intelligence, and witty banter. The greatest concentrations of hipsters can be found living in the Williamsburg, Wicker Park, and Mission District neighborhoods of major cosmopolitan centers such as New York, Chicago, and San Francisco respectively. Although “hipsterism” is really a state of mind,it is also often intertwined with distinct fashion sensibilities. Hipsters reject the culturally-ignorant attitudes of mainstream consumers, and are often be seen wearing vintage and thrift store inspired fashions, tight-fitting jeans, old-school sneakers, and sometimes thick rimmed glasses. Both hipster men and women sport similar androgynous hair styles that include combinations of messy shag cuts and asymmetric side-swept bangs. Such styles are often associated with the work of creative stylists at urban salons, and are usually too “edgy” for the culturally-sheltered mainstream consumer. The “effortless cool” urban bohemian look of a hipster is exemplified in Urban Outfitters and American Apparel ads which cater towards the hipster demographic. Despite misconceptions based on their aesthetic tastes, hipsters tend to be well educated and often have liberal arts degrees, or degrees in maths and sciences, which also require certain creative analytical thinking abilities. Consequently many hipsters tend to have jobs in the music, art, and fashion industries. It is a myth that most hipsters are unemployed and live off of their parent’s trust funds.
            Hipsters shun mainstream societal conventions that apply to dating preferences and traditional “rules” of physical attraction. It is part of the hipster central dogma not to be influenced by mainsream advertising and media, which tends to only promote ethnocentric ideals of beauty. The concepts of androgyny and feminism have influenced hipster culture, where hipster men are often as thin as the women they date. The muscular and athletic all-American male ideal is not seen as attractive by confident and culturally-empowered hipster women who instead view them as symbols of male oppression, sexism, and misogyny. Likewise, culturally-vapid sorority-type girls with fake blond hair, overly tanned skin, and “Britney Spears tube-tops” are not seen as attractive by cultured hipster males who instead see them as symbols of female insecurity, low self-esteem, and lack of cultural intelligence and independent thinking. Hipsters are also very racially open-minded, and the greatest number of interracial couples in any urban environment are typically found within the hipster subculture….”

        • Mike

          HERE FUCKING HERE. I went to see BTBAM at HOB and was like “what the fuck is this?” We’re not in O’Brien’s anymore, Toto.

  • I killed a Dunky

    Let me tell ya SomeThin Mr. Dallas knows it all Coyle.. U now complainin that u are not in God Forbid so what was all that crying all this months for? I dig ur list but please dude make up ur mind.. if u gonna start a new band then start the freakin band if u going to join GF then join.. dude we have seem lotx of examples of musicians that quit, they get fired of a band and they just move on. I think u should go ahead and meditate on that… cause whats the big deal to call ur bro and tell him dude Im sorry I made a mistake .. I wanna come back.. none .. so let me leave u with this hope it helps:Honor is like an island, rugged and without shores; once we have left it, we can never return.
    Nicolas Boileau

    • bearbomb

      Ugh…

    • stu1

      What in the name of all things holy are you fucking talking about??

    • Sean Williams

      …. i think my brian just died a little. well, it already did reading dallas’ post, so i’m well on my way to full retard.

      • stu1

        Again, well said.

      • Ryd1ZZ

        Never…NEVER, go full retard!

    • Dallas

      THIS KID CAN’T EVEN READ!

  • Patrick

    Dallas just gets worse and worse each time, you are still out of touch Dallas.

    • stu1

      Painfully.

  • Geekbeater

    This dude is weird. What he fucking hates playing metal and wont rejoin God Forbid? I actually enjoy some of these posts (the ones that actually pertain to metal). Join your band and stop crying about it. Get your shit together Dallas. Now go make another good record for us.

  • Future Ruins

    Geez. I like God Forbid and Dallas’ efforts, but man, he sounds like a moron. Who gives a shit that Josh Homme was on Blood Mountain? “Alice in Chains for keeping success with a black singer?” “The record kicks old people pussy?” “Periphery for being the only hope in 2010?!?!?!” Whether or not this is intended sarcasm, it is still just plain retarded. Dude, quit eating crank and get back to being productive and relevant to music.

  • Hobo7088

    Nice post, boss. Gonna have to agree with everything you said. Lolol

  • no-ghost

    Really? why get all twisted about kids liking the same music you like. Who cares, god knows those wonderful bands that you see don’t give two shits about who is listening. Just as long as they are listening. You can still go home and write, smoke, play, sleep,etc whatever it is and the world will keep turning.
    I have no clue who dallas is besides a city.

    • Biff Tannen

      He’s a nobody, move along.

  • evilfatguy

    This was the best post on this site in weeks!
    I also like your honorable mentions list. PTW! Forgot they had a new album and I was really into their last one.

  • g

    You should end this blog. Seriously.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Harrington-Neil-Sauer/677600672 Harrington Neil Sauer

      Yeah, you’re a gaping vagina. And only guys who wear their sisters clothes enjoy your writing.

  • ferocious_fetus

    Correction, Baroness is the rocking-metal (lite) sound that the new Mastodon should sound like instead of the generic wank fest they’ve turned into. Best song of Mastodon’s tour was “Where Strides the Behemoth,” the crushing old style that Baroness sounds nothing like.

    As for 2009, this might have been the best year for metal of the decade. The best since 04′ for sure (Miss Machine, Leviathan, You Fail Me, Panopticon, Terrifyer,…Gone Forever) and your list has bands that didn’t put out anything in 09′ alongside Dirge Within and Five FInger Death Punch? I wouldn’t care for metal anymore either if was listening to that shit.

    • stu1

      I agree with all of this, except for you not liking CTS. To say Baroness sound like old Mastodon is pretty absurd. There’s similarities to some extent, yes, but his observation is pretty off.

      • Patrick

        I agree Baroness doesn’t get nearly as intense as those first few Mastodon albums

        • stu1

          Nowhere near as heavy, far more atmospheric than “old Mastodon.”

          • ferocious_fetus

            i agree…thats why i said ““Where Strides the Behemoth,” the crushing old style that Baroness sounds nothing like.”
            My point/argument is that the Blue Album is the rocknroll/metal-ish mainstream type of album (appreciated by regular folk and not just relapse nerds) Mastodon SHOULD have made instead of the disappointing (in my opinion) Crack The Skye. Meant to counter Dallas saying Baroness is the Old Mastodon when in fact, they are how the NEW Mastodon should be.

          • stu1

            Totally follow you ferocious.

    • Hammer_Smashed_Hurtt

      I dig everything about Mastodon EXCEPT when Brent Hinds Sings. GREAT guitar Player, horrible vocals.

  • Sean Williams

    ….what the fuck? no one sentence in that entire post made any sense. it sounded like a mental patient with multiple personalities arguing with himself the entire post. “i don’t like metal!” “i’m not gonna post anything about metal!” “oh wait, all the albums i picked are metal and my entire post is about metal!” “i hate the hype around mastodon!” “but mastodons my fav album of the year!” what? and i agree with the dude who said is sentence structure is completely off, what the hell are you talking about? lay off the meth man.
    on a side note, even if your post made sense your completely wrong, this year was beyond incredible for metal and both mastodon and baroness kick serious ass. sorry.

  • joshkid

    what the fuck dude? Dallas is getting weirder by the blog.

  • d00shc00gr

    you like FFDP?
    …this relationship is over. Goodbye, Dallas

  • Natsquatch

    “I’ve lost interest in metal. Playing it that is.”

    File that under “obvious foreshadowing”.
    I would bet money that Dallas will eventually play metal again in one way or another, though it may be many years from now.

  • iolanach

    Shitty musician has shitty taste. More news at 11.

    • Biff Tannen

      10

    • Sean Williams

      hahaha

  • Sammy

    Dallas, you are the picture of confused clarity, and I love it. I also love how everyone just hates everything you write and so many of these stains actually get angry with you for your opinions. By the way, I love Earthsblood and don’t care what anyone thinks. It’s an awesome listen on the way up to the mountain to get pumped before tearing it up on my Lib Tech. And good call on the Dirge Within album. Merry Christmas.

    • Geekbeater

      maybe you should blow him too. Im sure he would like that

  • jagbag

    After reading that list, I no longer question what the fuck he was thinking when he wrote “I didn’t think this year in metal was as good as everyone else thought it was. Seriously. This year in metal was bullshit den a motherfucker…”

  • seth

    I agree SO wholeheartedly that this Mastodon fascination is over-the-top ridiculous. They are simply not that good. They are more interesting than a typical metal band, yes, but people don’t realize how starved they are for something different and how quickly they latched onto the nuts of these guys just because it’s SOMEthing different and they have cool artwork. The music itself really can’t be put up on such a pedestal. Have you hipster idiots ever listened to Yes? Genesis? King Crimson? The “prog” that Mastodon puts into their songs is so laughably unimaginative and derivative of everything that has been done before and so much better than them.

    I submit that the only metal band that is doing anything truly unique and worthy of generous praise is Meshuggah.

    “Meshuggah – Obzen (this is a 2 year-old record… fuck you)” – my sentiments exactly. This year SUCKED for metal.

    • SonOF

      “people don’t realize how starved they are for something different and how quickly they latched onto the nuts of these guys just because it’s SOMEthing different and they have cool artwork. The music itself really can’t be put up on such a pedestal. Have you hipster idiots ever listened to Yes? Genesis? King Crimson? The “prog” that Mastodon puts into their songs is so laughably unimaginative and derivative of everything that has been done before and so much better than them.”

      Well put. Even compared to Opeth the prog aspect of Mastodon is pretty simple.

      On a related idea, have any of the hipsters that dig on Mastodon so much heard Opeth? The one such person that I introduced to Opeth said something along the lines of, “they are OK, but those (death metal growling) vocals are horrible /just too much” :/ ugh, give me a break. This is why hipsters shouldn’t be trying to listen to metal – “ohh those growly screams hurt my ears!”

      • Biff Tannen

        Metalheads shouldn’t listen to Opeth post 1999. Its fucking random garbage on a tape.

        • ferocious_fetus

          I drew the line with Deliverance/Damnation.

        • SonOF

          Wow, I wish I could make some “random garbage” like Blackwater Park, Deliverance/Damnation, etc. I bet about 98% of metal bands would agree with me, but whatever………

          • SonOF

            I’m not sure what that means, you “drew the line”…were you so offended by D/D that you vowed to never listen to a note of Opeth’s stuff ever again? weird

          • DidgeryDo

            What he meant by “drew the line” is he drew a line between
            when the band had a breakout album. He is one of those guys
            who allways claims he likes just the older stuff to appear
            more tr00.

          • Biff Tannen

            They band peaked with “Still Life”… blackwater park was okay, but nothing close to the genius of Still Life. Everything since then has been the band tossing turds at the walls to see which pieces stick. I used to LOVE Opeth.my dislike for post 1999/2002 Opeth has nothing to do with them being popular. It has to do with their releases since then being haphazard and thrown together with no thought. They are treading water in a sea of recycled riffs and bad poetry.

          • SonOF

            Biff: I actually thought Blackwater Park was more of a peak than Still Life; usually even people that dislike Opeth regard BWater as high quality…you are the first non-out and out Opeth hater that I have ever heard call BWater “OK.” I understand where you are coming from, even though I wholeheartedly disagree. I can see how if you didn’t like too much experimentation/lack of structure or convention you would hate everything post Still Life.

      • stu1

        So, if you don’t like growling vocals, you’re not a true metal fan? That’s essentially what you just wrote.

        • SonOF

          Stu1: I don’t think that at all, nor did I imply it. I was citing one example of someone who discounted quality music, simply because he didn’t like the growling vocals. I never wrote that you had to like such vocals to be a “true metal fan” (I never mentioned anything about true metal fans at all, actually). I do get frustrated when people completely shut down and refuse to give certain heavy music a chance because of the vocals. The vocals are part of the package, and they exist for a reason. Yes, they may sound different from what the person is used to listening to, but that doesn’t mean one should discount the music as a whole (different should not have to equal “bad”). I do think that anyone who considers him or herself a “true metal fan” should, at the very least, respect the harsh growling vocals. The vocals contribute to the overall sound as well as theme/message for metal bands. For example, take Cannibal Corpse. You have death metal music coupled with lyrics about extreme gore/violence and other dark imagery.. the way that vocals are delivered (growling, death metal grunts) match the sound they are trying to create. If ‘Corpse sung their vocals in a melodic fashion, I’m guessing it simply wouldn’t fit – the desired effect may not be reached. I also understand that you could listen to plenty of metal music that does not include growling vocals but is still undoubtedly metal. Personally, I like both all types of vocals within the metal spectrum.

          I remember when I was like 15 or so, and the only heavy music I had heard was Metallica, I was introduced to Vision of Disorder’s self-titled album. William’s screamed vocals were so intense, and so different from anything I had ever heard, that I automatically rejected it, despite liking the hardcore music that surrounded the vocals. I refused to believe that it could be legitimate “music” with vocals like that. I had friends who told me to give it a chance, and I did…eventually I got it. After a while, I couldn’t possibly imagine VOD’s music WITHOUT Williams’ “screaming with my last dying breath, I hope my vocal chords explode and bleed out onto this stage” vocals. I opened up my eyes to the style, sound and genre, and my views on music haven’t been the same since….I later found death metal, hardcore, grind, black; music with vocals that often pushed the envelope. I realized that often times music THAT extreme needs vocals to match, and that these extreme vocalists were often very talented in their unique way.

          I only recount that story because I wish more people (those unfamiliar with heavy music) would try to do what I did with that VOD album: give the music with the vocals that were so different, so bizarre, and so harsh, a legitimate chance before completely discounting it, ESPECIALLY if you like the music. You just may find amazing art that will change your life.

          Sorry about the motivational pro-metal rant, and since most here are already huge metalheads, it is preaching to the choir. oh well.

          • stu1

            I’m still not really getting the vocal issue here, at all. Some music is ruined by the vocals. Some people like screams, some don’t. Same with growls. It’s ok to not like something. Opeth may be the best musical band on earth, but if someone doesn’t like the vocals and thus doesn’t enjoy the band, so what?

          • SonOF

            stu1: If someone doesn’t like Opeth BECAUSE of the growls, whatever, their loss. My point was that someone shouldn’t quickly discount something simply because of the vocals. I find that over time, sometimes I learn to like apects of music that I originally didn’t. I realize why the vocals are the way they are, and sometimes end of appreciating them for what they are. Sure it’s ok not to like something, I just think not giving certain music a shot because you don’t like one aspect of it is silly.

          • stu1

            Some people revisit things, some don’t. It’s human nature. Has nothing to do with being a “hipster” or not.

      • http://www.facebook.com/people/Colin-OConnor/1491245262 Colin O’Connor

        This has nothing to do with hipsters you dumb fuck. I have no friends that like my music
        NOT ONE and the reason is allways the growls. Why? The growls honestly do sound
        fucking stupid. I listen to them regardless and I allways justify it to people via the
        musicianship but I never blame people for not liking them.

        • SonOF

          Thanks, I’m sure my comment warranted calling me a dumb fuck. Oh wait, it didn’t, you just have a hard time with reading comprehension and/or humor, hyperbole, all of the above.

          I introduced someone to Opeth who is a hipster…that person didn’t like Opeth because of the growls. Yes, there are other people out there – who aren’t hipsters – that also don’t like some heavy music because of the growls or other harsh vocals. Did I clear that up for you? I’ll be sure to lay out everything with absolutely no ambiguity in the future so as not to be attacked by random losers.

          And if you think metal growls “honestly do sound fucking stupid,” you should probably pick a new genre of music to listen to.

      • Tonberry

        Unless you only listen to music for the sake of experimentation, what does it matter whether Mastodon is more progressive or less progressive than other bands? It seems like you’re judging them based on their hyped as opposed to their music.

    • ferocious_fetus

      Napalm Death, Converge, Behemoth, Nile, Isis, Burnt By the Sun, Kylesa, Marduk, Skeletonwitch, Gorod, Magrudergrind, Obscura, The Red Chord, Immortal, Suffocation, Lamb of God, Coalesce, Goatwhore, Slayer (to name a FEW) all put out amazing albums this year.

      Bands from all different sub genres of extreme music shat out some of the best records of their careers almost every month of the year and people are saying 2009 blows? Get out from under your rock will you.

      • Hammer_Smashed_Hurtt

        Good Call, you summed it up right there.

      • stu1

        Black Dahlia Murder, Isis, Iron Age, Doomriders are some additions.

        • ferocious_fetus

          new Doomriders FTW!

      • Dallas

        Give me a fuckin’ break with that bullshit. Not one band this year put out a record that impacted music in the way I want it impacted. I want cultural upheaval motherfuckers. You just don’t get it cause most of you assholes don’t understand what it takes to make it in music and become a band that changes the trend.

        I wouldn’t expect it though because half of your fucking posts on here don’t even GET the fact that the whole article is 100% tongue in cheek. But that’s the WHOLE POINT. YOU DON’T GET IT!

        Marduk, Immortal, Slayer (new album, big fucking MEH), Kylesa: Bands I don’t give two shits about. Shit I like Pink more than I like the new output from those bands. Yeah, PINK!

        And all you +1, +20 guys who wonder why I still write for this site don’t get it either. Look at what you’re doing. Commenting on this blog post, having a conversation sparked by my fucking BLOG you cocksuckers. So lick my balls 8000 times and ask your girl to my ass too.

        Some of you even sit here and say “Oh, he gets weirder every time and I get ‘douche chills’ EVERY TIME I READ HIS BLOG. Well, who’s the fucking dumbass? Me or you? I’d say YOU. You’re subjecting yourself to the same treatment over and over again knowing you don’t enjoy it. That’s just dumb shit. But not surprising because the amount of smart comments on the comments section lately has dwindled massively.

        That’s OK though because you ASSHOLES make the site more popular because that’s what FOLLOWERS do. Eat shit up once it’s popular.

        And to make myself clear, I am not referring to EVERYONE who posts at Metalsucks. Some of you wouldn’t even be coming to this site if not for my blog so wake up.

        Over and out, douchebags.

        • jackattack

          Because God Forbid has really altered trends in heavy music… and Jesus road a dinosaur.

          I’m usually not in on the haterade, Dallas, but I gotta call bullshit when I see bullshit. The reason the comments have sucked is because the content has sucked. Like this post. And saying that music wasn’t impacted in the way you wanted it impacted is an extremely pretentious way of going about saying that you didn’t enjoy a lot of releases this year. Just keep it at that, dude. You’re doing yourself a huge disservice by trying to lash out. If you don’t like it than don’t post.

        • DidgeryDo

          “You just don’t get it cause most of you assholes don’t understand what it takes to make it in music and become a band that changes the trend. ”

          If you know what it takes why have you never done it? You’re pretty much
          about as famous a guy who is waving in the background when a news
          anchor is reporting and equally influential.

        • Hammer_Smashed_Hurtt

          First off SON:

          Music impacts EVERYONE in a different way. What is a masterpiece to you may be garbage to me or vice versa.

          Second:

          You and I and everyone in this blog missed the last true ‘cultural upheaval’ by about 40 years. And it died a painful death.

          I totally get your post is Tongue in cheek, youre just not smart enough to make it relevant in any way shape or form.

          Last time I checked the point of this blog (Metal Sucks) though often misguided; is to promote intelectual converstion about METAL. If thats no longer your love. Fine go listen to Pink or whatever suits your fuckin needs. Oh and BTW stop droppin N-bombs, all it does is cement the fact that your a fucking tool. And yes it offends the shit out of me (and im white)

          Third:

          I am willing to bet that the popularity of this site has NOTHING.NADA.ZILCH……FUCKING ZERO to do with your Blog. Id put my next shitty Army paycheck on it. And im pretty sure calling folks who read your shit (because i /we need something to laugh at)cocksuckers, assholes, followers,etc aint gonna help your cause any bit.

          Fourth:

          EVERYONE here wishes that it was YOU that got hit with a beer bottle on stage NOT your brother.

          Take the fucking hint ‘Tough guy’

        • !?!

          You seem really into dudes licking your balls. Like, REALLY into dudes licking your balls. Which is cool if that’s your thing. I’m not into it, but different strokes for different folks or whatever.

          Don’t flatter yourself: this is not a “conversation” sparked by your blog. This is us calling you out for being an idiot. And if your little article was meant to be “tongue-in-cheek,” it failed; there is nothing witty about it.

          If you don’t like playing metal; aren’t even in a metal band any longer; and have no interest in a year’s worth of metal releases, why are you even here?

        • Genial Gentile

          Kylesa has made more important contributions to heavy music than practically every band you listed in your post…and the ex-guitarist from a third tier NWOAHM band bagging Slayer is beyond laughable regardless of the quality of their last album. Know your role, son.

        • stu1

          I was going to comment on your “rant” Dallas, but pretty much has already covered it. You’re totally out of touch, bitter, and washed up.
          The fact that you even talk about “knowing what it takes to make a trend” is god damn laughable. You have the BALLS to say that? Unreal.

        • SonOF

          Dallas, when was the last time there was a metal album that had the type of MAJOR, earth-shattering impact you are talking about? 1986 with Master of Puppets or Reign in Blood? 1994 with Far Beyond Driven? So metal hasn’t had a good year since 1994? if so, your standards are pretty damn high; I’ll consider a good year when a ton of good metal albums were released (like 2009) and there was a soild buzz within my little metal community, albeit no cultural upheaval.

          • Dallas

            The Black album from Metallica. And you’re right, metal hasn’t been good since 1994. Spot on.

            KsE killed nu-metal but that sort of counts. And Korn changed metal.

        • I killed a Dunky

          BANATE BUEN SUCIIO

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Colin-OConnor/1491245262 Colin O’Connor

    Crack the Skye is my album of the year. Why? Simply because when I first listened to the record it grabbed and never let go till the climax and it did this better then any other record I heard this year. It’s that simple. I have seen the typical arc following this albums release and I am not suprised in the least. It started with mass love the album deserved. Then as months went on some grew tired because they listened to it five times a day. Others felt that it had become too popular and no longer had the same
    name-dropping paunche and abandoned it for something more obscure and new. Dallas the dummy said it himself. He shies away from popular things. See he is actually one of “those” people. Funny thing is that’s the one thing that I don’t like about hipsters( not saying he is one, he lacks the inteligence). They tend to dislike music based on how many people listen as opposed to the music’s actual merit.

    First I want to talk about the throw-away aspect of metal. We are so fickle and something that excited us incredibly a few months ago just no longer has that ZING! and pales in comparison to other newer records which incidentally are not even better but fresher in our pysches. Metal fans are ravenous. They devour an outsanding new record. They listen until it is absolutely killed( myself included). So there is that. It’s hard to be so excited about Crack the Skye when we are hyped about what we listen to now( which will also be forgotten five months later for the NEWER newness).

    The other is the underground aspect of metal. There is a contentiousness in metal to anything mainstream. Once a band becomes popular enough there is allways a contingency of metal fans who leave strictly for that reason alone. These are the same guys that will allways say their favorite record is the one JUST before the breakout album ( BIff Tannen talking about Opeth for instance). These people actually are not really into music itself but the sad feelings of affirmation they get from the ascociation. Black Metal is an entire genre based on this idea this accounts for at least ninety percent of why anyone would listen to such awful unmusical crap.

    A popular record is suseptible to being ascociated with a group of people. I have seen this in the last few months where hipsters are now ascociated with Mastodon. The logic here is, “I’m no hipster, therefore I
    now don’t like Mastodon.” Obscure bands are free from ascociation simply because nobody knows who the fuck they are.

    Let’s skip all this bullshit. Let’s simply ask if this is good music or not and forget how long it’s been since it released, the thickness of the glasses of those who listen or how many people dig it. Is it good or not.
    Crack the Skye is my album of the year. Suck my fucking cock.

    • chris

      well fucking put. i agree with every single point that you made. i’ve listened to mastodon since the day leviathan came out and i still love them. i could care less that hipsters like them, whatever the fuck a hipster is. who knows i might be one. i mean i listen to tons of metal yet i still like indie stuff, animal collective, portugal. the man, mgmt. does this mean i am a hipster? what the fuck is a hipster? do i have to wear all the attire? i mean i wear tight pants, but i dont shop at a thrift store. my point is, people can call me whatever the fuck they want, i’ve gotten everything from being called a punk to being called a hippy, im just me and thats what matters. most people won’t give a fuck what you say, so singling music out on the basis of their fans isn’t really going to get you anywhere. you won’t make the ‘bad’ people go away from your music. just shut the fuck up, deal with it, and listen to the music.

    • Tonberry

      Posted this here before, but it’s always relevant on this site:

      http://media.gamerevolution.com/images/misc/image/music-i-like.jpg

      • http://www.facebook.com/people/Colin-OConnor/1491245262 Colin O’Connor

        Tonberry: LOL
        Chris: Thanks. I would say you are a hipster. HaHa Just kidding. I don’t know exactly what
        they are but they are either allegedly all over Brooklyn so I must have seen one at some point.

        • chris

          hahaha, i actually brought this question up to my friends when we were getting drunk last night and it was like a scene out of a movie where a kid is coming out to his family. i was like “guys, what the fuck is a hipster and am I one?” they all looked at me and were like “yeah we hate to break it to you but we think you’re a hipster and it’s okay” i was like fuck. i became a hipster without trying. i can’t change the music i like, i can’t change the clothes i like, it’s just me. they said it pretty much boiled down to this, if your iPod has All Shall Perish next to Animal Collective, if it has Mastodon next to The Mars Volta, and if it has The Melvins next to MGMT, you are most likely a hipster. i always just saw how I am, the way i dress and act, as a complete combination of the clash between all of the different musical styles I listen to. I’m a musician and I find something rewarding in almost every style of music, except country, with the exclusion of Johnny Cash cause he is the fucking shit. oh well, you straight up metalheads can stay at home under your rocks while I go to Bonnaroo and trip face.

          • Tonberry

            Maybe I’m just saying this because I too have Animal Collective next to All Shall Perish in my iPod, but I think that the state of “hipsterness” has more to do with motivation than what you’re actually listening to. There’s a difference between having broad musical tastes and accumulating a bunch of music in order to seem eclectic.

          • chris

            @ tonberry: i totally see what you are saying. i have this one friend and he is so fucking annoying. everyday he comes up to me with some random electronic music or some other weird stupid shit saying how its his favorite new band, a week later i havent heard him say anything about those bands again. he does this constantly, only he dresses way more metal looking than i do.

          • http://www.facebook.com/people/Colin-OConnor/1491245262 Colin O’Connor

            I’m probably considered Hipster by all kinds of qualities but at the
            end of the day I shop at Macy’s and that group would revile
            me for that fact alone.

          • SonOF

            Chris: The negative way I view the “hipster” is more about attitude than musical taste (or even fashion). The stuff I listen to next to my metal probably moves me into the hipster realm as well, but since I legitimately like the stuff, and don’t listen to it to be “eclectic,” “different” or to purposely buck trends it’s all good (and the same goes for your musical taste). The hipster likes certain music because of the statement the music makes about HIM as listener, not because he liikes it.. And he is unbelievably close-minded, snobbish and negative about the vast majority of “other people’s music.” That’s the difference. If you don’t have those attitudes, you probably aren’t a hipster (and neither am I). Not that it matters what the hell some label people attach to you anyway, but for the sake or argument and to answer your question, there ya go.

          • chris

            i get it now. sooo pretty much hipsters listen to the same exact music that i do, but for all the wrong reasons. word!

    • Biff Tannen

      Hey Colin- The fact that I think “Still Life” is where Opeth peaked has NOTHING to do with the fact that they had a ‘breakout’ album after it. In fact, Blackwater Park was the first Opeth I heard. I liked it so much that I tracked down everything I could of theirs and became quite obsessed with the band. After doing that, I find that “Still Life” is where they peaked, and the only album of theirs that I find to be coherant and have true staying power. Blackwater Park has its moments, but as an artistic work, it pales in comparison to Still Life. Everything after Blackwater has been complete and utter rubbish…haphazard riffs thrown together,followed by absolutely NO transition into their now cliche acoustic parts.

      • Biff Tannen

        Also, Colin- your forehead must be pretty sore and bloody after bashing it on the keyboard for however long it took you to make your long- winded comment.

        • http://www.facebook.com/people/Colin-OConnor/1491245262 Colin O’Connor

          Truth? That was about eight minutes.

      • http://www.facebook.com/people/Colin-OConnor/1491245262 Colin O’Connor

        I think you proved my point exactly. You say that people should not bother to listen to
        Opeth pre-1999 but admit that Blackwater Park was the one that turned you on to
        the band in the first place. Wouldn’t that fact alone mean it should make sense to
        recomend it to other people?

        I’ve listened to Opeth for a long while and think BP is still a great record. I think a lot
        of guys find that to be their peak. Metalsucks staff included. Is Still Life the one with
        Demon of the Fall or was that My Arms Your Hearse?

        • SonOF

          Demon of the Fall is on “My Arms.” And your point that if BWater is the one that turned someone on to Opeth it is definitely worth recommending, I agree. That is the album that turned me on as well, and I still think it is killer. But I also consider Deliverance and Damnation “great,” and Ghost Reveries and Watershed to be “good” or “very good.”

          ” Everything after Blackwater has been complete and utter rubbish…haphazard riffs thrown together,followed by absolutely NO transition into their now cliche acoustic parts.”
          @ Biff – I think that Opeth’s progression/evolution has been natural. They are constantly pushing the boundaries and refusing to adhere to any structural demands. Sometimes it doesn’t work, but when it does, I think it’s amazing. I don’t think the riffs are at all “haphazard,” nor do I think the lack of transition is necessarily a negative in most cases. Do you really want more structure in an Opeth record? Isn’t it the lack of structure and unpredictability part of what drew you to the music in the first place? I just can’t see the band evolving in any other way, and I don’t see how anyone can say (or imply) that their very early records (Orchid, Morningrise) stand up to their newer stuff. You say the newer stuff is haphazard without transition, have you listened to Morningrise or Orchid lately? I mean I love those albums, but talk about pointless noodling. I have enjoyed the evolution of this band, and have really never been let down, I guess that’s all I can say.

          • Biff Tannen

            SonOF -

            ” I think that Opeth’s progression/evolution has been natural.” To my ears, they have not progressed at all since SL/BWP. I think they are treading water. They know their fans are going to eat up whatever they put out. Akerfeldt could take a dump, wrap it in tinfoil and put hooks in it and sell it as earings and fans would buy it. I think that where they REALLY ‘progressed’ is from Orchid to Still LIfe. Each of those 4 records was an evolution of the highest order, rarely seen by any band. I think they began playing it safe on BWP

            “Isn’t it the lack of structure and unpredictability part of what drew you to the music in the first place?” Thats my problem with modern Opeth…it has become VERY predictable. NONE of the riffs stand out anymore (except maybe a FEW on the Deliverance album). Where are the great riffs like those found in “The Moor”, “The Drapery Falls”, “When”, “Black Rose Immortal”. They just aren’t writing great riffs anymore…they all sound very much the same,song after song,album after album.

            Also, Im not a big fan of either Orchid or Morningrise (I do like Orchid better if it matters).

            I am not an Opeth ‘hater’…. Im a long time fan that has been very,VERY underwhelmed by their output this decade, barring a few moments/songs on BWP.

          • http://www.facebook.com/people/Colin-OConnor/1491245262 Colin O’Connor

            SonOf – Definitely agree about Watershed Ghost, Reveries and
            Deliverance/Damnation….those sister albums, in particular, were
            staples for me in 2002.

          • http://www.facebook.com/people/Colin-OConnor/1491245262 Colin O’Connor

            Biff – For that entire last post I would refer you to Doc Coyle’s
            Killswitch blog that Dallas has linked up above. He said it pretty well.

  • JOEY FROM JERSEY, COLLAS UP YA FEEL ME

    Dallas Coyle smells like vinegar.

  • AATHD

    I think hed (pe) is looking for a guitarist.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Colin-OConnor/1491245262 Colin O’Connor

      HaHa Dallas would luck funny in clown paint.

  • http://www.metalsucks.net satans balls

    the drama on this site amazes me.p.s i LOATHE Mastodon.truly one of the most over praised bands.Opeth are thee best modern prog Metal band on the market

    • JOEY FROM JERSEY, COLLAS UP YA FEEL ME

      lol no.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Colin-OConnor/1491245262 Colin O’Connor

      OK is it allright to like both or what?

      • SonOF

        yes, as long as you kow tow to Akerfeldt and realize that Opeth is your daddy.

  • http://schenkeltown.blogspot.com SchenkelTown

    on another note, fuck ryan seacrest

  • dot

    haha. this made my day.

  • http://reaper-x.deviantart.com/ Reaper-X

    Reason 1 First, I think you could still talk about outside topics as long as you could relate it to the subject of the website. It’s just a matter of figuring out how to do that. The last part though, sounds kind of sarcastic. Do you even want to see a future with God Forbid?

    Not like I’m challenging you because I’m neither here or there. I saw you guys live at the pearl room once, even shook your hand at the merch table. You guys were cool, but musically okay.

    It just seems rather unclear with the way you said “Wait. I’m not in God Forbid anymore so I should stop expecting Doc to cover for me. Dammit. I never should have quit!” It could very well be you being silly, but I don’t know that.

    Reason 2: You aren’t following the muse quickly enough. It happens

    Reason 3: NEUROSIS MOTHERFUCKER…

    Reason 4: This year wasn’t spectacular… but at least Slayer, Behemoth, Alice in Chains and Devin Townsend didn’t suck. The saddest thing was seeing Animosity break up and make room for more bullshit deathcore acts filling the scene.

  • chtimixeur

    Dallas, I’ve read on the PRP you were in the band Soul At War. I listened to every song on myspace, and if it is indeed your new project, it sounds very good (not too sure about the King Deathlog intro though). God Forbid is a great band, but IMHO, it would have achieved more success with cleaner vocals. This whole metalcore screaming bullshit must have “scared” a lot of traditional metal listeners (I wish more bands had “clean” like in the 80′s). Don’t mistake me, Byron is very good at what he does, and I love Constitution and Earthsblood, but this whole screaming nonsense in metal isn’t exactly the best way to be successful these days.

    I think your voice is strong enough for you to front a band of your own (the Muse cover was excellent). You know how to write good songs, you can sing… I hope you get suceesful in your new life/career ! Cheers.

  • bob

    HEY DALLAS? no mention of steel panther? where’s the luv brotha?

  • AddRokk

    lame post. lame list. this ruined my xmas eve

  • john

    10.Mudvayne-Mudvayne
    9.Chimaira- The Infection
    8.Lazarus A.D.-The Onslaught
    7.The Red Chord-Fed Through the Teeth Machine
    6.Between the Buried and Me- The Great Misdirect
    5.God Forbid-Earthsblood
    4.Daath-The Concealers
    3.Shadows fall-Retribution
    2.Devildriver-Pray For Villians
    1.Lamb of God-Wrath