NEW PANTERA GREATEST HITS COLLECTION INFERIOR TO OLD PANTERA GREATEST HITS COLLECTION

Thursday, February 25th, 2010 at 10:50am by

Yesterday we discussed all the upcoming Pantera reissues, as well as the fact that the band’s second greatest hits collection, 1990-2000: A Decade Of Domination, is coming out on March 30. I said that it’s hard not to see this compilation as a cash-in, and now that track list has been revealed and details of how the album will be sold, it’s even harder.

For one thing, the band’s original greatest hits album, Far Beyond the Great Southern Cowboys’ Vulgar Hits, not only had six more songs than this new one will, but came with a bonus DVD showcasing twelve (!) music videos.

Here’s the track list for the new collection, A Decade of Domination

  1. “Cowboys From Hell”
  2. “Psycho Holiday”
  3. “Cemetery Gates”
  4. “Mouth For War”
  5. “Walk”
  6. “This Love”
  7. “5 Minutes Alone”
  8. “I’m Broken”
  9. “Drag The Waters”
  10. “Revolution Is My Name”

…and here’s the track list for the old one:

  1. “Cowboys from Hell”
  2. “Cemetery Gates”
  3. “Mouth for War”
  4. “Walk”
  5. “This Love”
  6. “I’m Broken”
  7. “Becoming”
  8. “5 Minutes Alone”
  9. “Planet Caravan”
  10. “Drag the Waters”
  11. “Where You Come From”
  12. “Cat Scratch Fever”
  13. “Revolution Is My Name”
  14. “I’ll Cast a Shadow”
  15. “Goddamn Electric”
  16. “Hole in the Sky”

Now, three of the above songs are covers, so I guess you could argue that they’re highly unnecessary (although I have a soft spot for Pantera’s version of “Planet Caravan”). But poor “Becoming!” And I know Reinventing the Steel is probably Pantera’s weakest record (if you don’t count the pre-Anselmo glam stuff), but, y’know. Two more songs is two more songs. And I actually really like “Goddamn Electric.”

(Of course, as I said yesterday, I’d prefer new fans just seek out whole Pantera albums. But maybe that’s too much is to ask in 2010.)

Now here comes the punchline: Decade will be sold exclusively at Wal-Mart stores – and Wal-Mart has apparently refused to carry Pantera albums in the past, because Phil Anselmo likes to use naughty language in his lyrics, and that’s a big no-no for a wholesome, all-American retailer like Wal-Mart. Which explains why “Goddamn Electric” didn’t make the cut.

In other words: this really is just a cash-in. Oh well. Hopefully that Cowboys from Hell reissue will be awesome enough to wash the taste of disappointment out of my mouth.

-AR

  • Double D

    1st off: Wal-Mart? Fuck…
    2nd: Pantera’s Planet Caravan is a FANTASTIC cover.

  • Cisco

    I don’t know, I really love ‘RtS’ and feel that any of the songs on that record should have some inclusion within a greatest hits compilation.

    • Slaughterhouse

      I agree! That album kicks major ass!!!!!!!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Rob-Kurkjian/1238131077 Rob Kurkjian

    The only good part of the old greatests hits was the covers. If Vinnie is behind this greatest hits than shame on him for trying to cash in on the Pantera legacy. And why why in Wal Mart. I am totally tired of this wal mart exclusive trend.

    • Genial Gentile

      Who else could be behind it other than Big Vin? I’m pretty sure he owns all the publishing rights.

      • http://www.facebook.com/people/Rob-Kurkjian/1238131077 Rob Kurkjian

        Its me clinging on to a false hope that maybe MAYBE someone else was behind it but you had to kill it for me *tear*

        • Genial Gentile

          Sorry bro, I know what you mean and sometimes the truth can be hurtful:) I don’t think anyone should be particularly surprised though after that bald-faced cash grab of his deceased brothers legacy: the Dimevision DVD’s. That was patently wrong…he and Rita should really be ashamed.

          • Lordassenfroth

            vinnie paul is a sleaze bag. i cant believe he has tarnished pantera’s legacy like this.

          • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jason-John-Crispen/100000169530540 Jason John Crispen

            you nailed it. him and rita SHOULD be ashamed. rita uses dime’s name anytime she can to get a little bit more of the spotlight. i’ve liked pantera for almost 20 years. and until he died, i’d NEVER heard of her.

    • AATHD

      I was wondering why Fucking Hostile wasn’t on here.

  • http://thenumberoftheblog.wordpress.com/ groverXIII

    Wal Mart? HAHAHAHAHAHA

  • Who

    Stop complaining, you fucking losers !
    You don’t have to buy it.

  • yetzer hara

    don’t forget that all of these tracks are newly remastered… haha. oh, and why “psycho holiday” over “domination”? please tell me that there will never again be another pantera’s greatest hits record. i’d take a new pantera dvd (you know they have the footage to do it) over this, the 20th anniversary reissues, and new vinyls put together. this whole thing is fucking stupid.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jason-John-Crispen/100000169530540 Jason John Crispen

      i wish they’d put out a DVD. and not just a “look at us being drunk and crazy” one. an actual LIVE dvd of entire sets. (not that i don’t enjoy the ones they have out already.)

      • yetzer hara

        some of the pro-quality live shows from their late era were among their best. “the great southern trendkill” is the most scathing indictment of heavy music in the 90′s.

  • http://hookinmouth.net Hookinmouth.net

    Revolution and God Damn Electric are the only memorable songs from RTS. Even though I already had all the songs from the first Greatest Hits, I still bought it when it came out because I thought it was a good mix and I wanted the DVD.

    • Slaughterhouse

      All of their songs are memorable…that might be due to me being a huge fan though lol

      • cougar party

        I think RTS is solid too, but hardly anyone agrees with me.

        • Slaughterhouse

          I fucking love that album!

          • Cisco

            I don’t understand why folks don’t love RtS as much as they should. That album is smokin’ and is still in constant rotation in my playlist.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Brandon-Cunningham/100000167213200 Brandon Cunningham

    you know if Walmart wasn’t fucking gay about editing albums i wouldn’t be bothered too much about this. you gotta admit they have pretty good prices for their shit. it just bothers the hell out of me because they will carry a shitload of R-rated movies and M-rated video games but when it comes to vulgar language in music they censor it?? wtf is that?

    • Gecko

      dude, good call. wal-mart isn’t far from me and when i need essentials and i can get them cheap, i tend to head over there. i always wander through looking for cheap dvds and xbox games and they have tons of guts and gore, but when i ask for the white zombie boxed set, it’s like i’m a leper in there or something. weird…

    • cougar party

      Because gratitudinous sex and violence is okay as long as no one says any naughty words.

  • http://schenkeltown.blogspot.com SchenkelTown

    the only response i can think of $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

  • bob

    No Pantera greatest hits collection is complete without Projects In The Jungle!

    • Althazaire

      srsly, why can’t i find ANY of those albums? metal magic, i am the night, power metal, projects in the jungle….wtf, it’s like they never existed, and some of those were pretty sick

      • bob

        Oh they exist! A little hard to find, but not impossible. I picked up a copy of Projects In The Jungle from Deceased’s distro in November!

        It’s sad that the band doesn’t acknowledge that era, while it may be silly and totally 180 from their later stuff, some of it rules! Projects In The Jungle is an awesome record and hugely overrated for example.

  • cargo

    Most overrated band EVER!!!!

    • yetzer hara

      the importance and relevance of pantera cannot be overstated. pantera was to metal in the 90′s what slayer or metallica were in the 80′s. you know who saved heavy metal when metallica put out “load”? pantera. you know who took slayer on tour with them once they were past their prime, just to say “fuck you, we love this music” to an industry who was pushing nothing but nu-metal garbage? pantera. no machine head. no lamb of god. no mastodon. nothing that’s relevant now would be here without pantera.

      in the 90′s, pantera was universally loved by people across the entire metal scene. anyone who thinks differently obviously wasn’t around at the time. punk ass kids. get the fuck off my lawn.

      • Genial Gentile

        You sir, were apparently there because you speak truth.

      • mahkiavelli

        Well said…

        • yetzer hara

          not to mention the fact that dime wrote the most original and iconic riffs in metal, second to only tony iommi. all four members of pantera influenced an entire generation of kids to pick up instruments and play.

          again, anyone who argues against this is like donny from the big lebowski… “So you have no frame of reference here, Donny. You’re like a child who wanders into the middle of a movie and wants to know…”

      • cougar party

        Hear, Hear!

      • Biff_Tannen

        Pantera was to metal what the Pinto was to Ford. Pantera SUCKED. Stupid macho tough guy garbage with dumbed down, lowest common denominator ‘groove’ riffs. The entire REAL metal scene fucking HATED Pantera. NASCAR fans and Busch Light drinkers are their fans….and the O’Doyles from Billy Madison. Neanderthal mouth breathing shit.

        It is ONLY kids that like them. Kids and adults with SERIOUSLY stunted brain development, and a disparaging lack of knowledge about REAL metal.

        • hotsauce

          Dude, get off your high horse and elitist snobbery. You’re just pissed because you were beat up in high school by bigger kids who listened to Pantera while you sulked in the corner afterwards listening to your lame black metal. Douche.

        • yetzer hara

          i don’t know where you’re from or what “real” metal scene you’re referring to, but i distinctly remember the same dudes who went with me to the milwaulkee metal fests would go to pantera too. as a matter of fact, there were always long haired “true” metal dudes in death/black metal shirts at pantera shows. you must be fourteen years old if you believe what you just said. you’re an idiot with no frame of reference.

        • UpwindGravy

          I guess a guy with the screen name: Biff Tannen would know all about “stupid macho tough guy garbage”. Why didn’t you add in a MCFLY in there anywhere. You obviously don’t know shit about metal if you are badmouthing one of the best bands in the genre. Get a clue. Also, I owned a Pinto back in the day, ran great,fuckface.

        • cargo

          redneck shit!!!! Pantera has nothing to do with metal!!!!!! Do you remember them back in “cowboys from hell” wearing spandex? Please!

        • Althazaire

          what world are you living in, dip shit? people on the “Real” metal scene would probably beat you 7/8ths of the way to death if you said that shit within reach of their fist.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Rik-Powell/286400508 Rik Powell

    Reinventing the Steel is my favourite Pantera album. Then again, I just don’t “get” this band, so what do I know.

  • http://www.myspace.com/whiskeyrambleproject x101whiskey_ramble101x

    as a huge Pantera fan, I am sorely disappointed. This isn’t a fuckin’ greatest hits, this is like gettn poked with a pin as apposed to gettn your fuckin arm chopped off…. super weak, I call bullshit

  • Dave B

    There’s a ton of torrents out there for the full Pantera discography. Just sayin!

  • WowWee!

    I can see a lot of people buying this at Wal Mart, you know those people who have babies and were minimally into metal.

    Who the fuck buys CD’s at Wal Mart? oh ya i just said it.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Brandon-Cunningham/100000167213200 Brandon Cunningham

      people who dont wanna pay a shitload of money…like i said above they have good priced cds. fucking Sam Goody/FYE…etc on the otherhand (with a better selection i might add) has cds for fucking 20 bucks.

  • Jeremy

    There was also an international version of the first greatest hits called “Reinventing Hell” which had a slightly different track list.

    On a side note it looks like they ripped off your logo…

    • yetzer hara

      are you fucking kidding me? i hope the logo comment was your lame attempt at sarcasm.

      • Jeremy

        What’s sarcasm?

        • yetzer hara

          thanks for clearing that up for me.

  • http://www.last.fm/user/wrath_of_vishnu Dillon

    Wal-Mart’s obviously always had a shoddy selection of CDs. Seriously, it’s stupid that they’re releasing ANOTHER greatest hits compilation. And for what? 10 tracks previously released on other albums and nothing else.

    If you want to capture the true spirit of the band, buy the real albums. Sure, it may cost more, but it’s better than wasting money on an expensive drink coaster.

  • Hated

    I fucking love Wal Mart and Pantera. Make money.

    They still make cd’s?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jay-See/726690352 Jay See

    Fuck this cash-in. Go out and buy Cowboys From Hell, Vulgar Display of Power, Far Beyond Driven, and The Great Southern Trendkill. NOW…DO IT (if you don’t already own them: where the hell have you been the past 20 years?). I’d also highly suggest grabbing their live album, 101 Proof.

    • Genial Gentile

      You’d still be putting money in the same pockets, friend.

  • Ziltoid

    Shit = shit

    Therefore, both GH collections are identical.

    • http://hookinmouth.net Hookinmouth.net

      Go back to your Pokemon cards.

      • Ziltoid

        I am playing Fire Red right now. I just defeated Misty, and I already have a Charizard. I am that cool.

        • AATHD

          I have Roostor and Shoe!

          • http://hookinmouth.net Hookinmouth.net

            lmao. Ziltoid, you never seem to amaze me. Thanks for taking that exactly how it was meant, in a completely nerd teasing manner. Look forward to more of your posts on TheNumber…

  • bob

    Seriously though, the Glam era Pantera should be included!

  • Gabe

    Oddly enough, Fucking Hostile is not on either compilation. What the hell, brosef? That’s one of my favorites off of Vulgar and one of my favorites of all time, and an undeniable crowd favorite. Quoteth Phil from Live 101 (and all the more poignant in light of this Wal-Mart bullshit): “You can curse. You paid good money to curse.”

  • bob
  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mark-Irwin/612231572 Mark Irwin

    My reaction:

    http://wackyiraqi.com/wtf/well_fuck_your_shit.jpg

    I was hoping this would have “Floods”, “Hollow” or one of the “Suicide Note” songs. But I guess not since Wal-Mart frowns upon that kind of stuff. Even though the Wal-Mart in my town sold Cannibal Corpse’s new album and Heaven & Hell without the alternate cover.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Alex-Johnston/1444803323 Alex Johnston

    In Canada Walmart sells all music. I bought Great Southern Trendkill there, and I’ve seen albums by Cannibal Corpse.

  • http://www.myspace.com/provenmetal KarlProven

    Is Planet Cavaran really a cover? I thought Iommi said it was their song now? :) They took a song…….I never saw much promise in (I love Black Sabbath, didnt care for that song) and made it their own, and really fully realized it. I still remember watching that video for that song in the Pantera home videos!!!

    Aaahhh good times. I’m gonna go find it out YouTube.

    My whole band is huge Pantera fans. Our singer has Pantera tattoo’d on his back. He and I are super fans.

    RIP to the greatest band ever.

  • Dezzrek

    The first compilation also had a DVD with all their music videos on it.

  • Sloshjoshbgosh

    the whole business is about money. I’m not surprised at all. Good move.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Trip-Cahouet/706361037 Trip Cahouet

    Psycho Holiday over Floods?!?!?

    *face-palm*