THE HARD R: DALLAS ON WHY HE HAD TO LEAVE GOD FORBID

Monday, March 15th, 2010 at 4:30pm by

It’s hard to believe I wrote my first blog for Metalsucks on February 21st, 2008. I really don’t know what happened to that time. So much has happened to me since then that it’s hard for me to believe life has gone by this quickly.

And I left the only thing I ever knew behind me. I bowed out of the most rewarding and troubling journey I’ve ever experienced.

Believe it or not, my decision to leave God Forbid wasn’t a decision. My quitting the band stemmed from a stupid argument (the last straw) I had with my brother involving me getting a ride from New York City to the band’s van in Pennsylvania. This argument consisted of screaming about money, respect, being a “star,” big opportunities, etc. The argument ended with me screaming to my brother, “Fuck YOUR band.” I’ve never leveled an attack at my brother in that way. The band was never “his” or “mine.” It was always “ours.” That statement was really “I quit,” and we both knew it.

The band had to embark on a two day trip to Arkansas to play a one-off show before they joined the Lamb Of God tour. It was about 3 pm in the afternoon when I quit. The band was supposed to leave around 7 pm or 8 pm. In that time I waited for someone to call to tell me they were coming to pick me up. I didn’t get a call from anyone in the band. They were on their way without me. In this time, I was trying to go over everything I was feeling.

How did I get to this point of anger and frustration? How did I let this band slip from my fingers? Why don’t I have the passion for the band the way I once did?

In the years of playing metal, especially since I started singing and writing lyrics, I discovered that metal was only a part of my make-up. It was my coming of age story that will affect the way I think for the rest of my life. I’ll base all of my future work on the sentiments I’ve learned from being a person who appreciates metal and the elements that make the genre so defined. I listen to metal more than I listen to any other music. I LOVE metal. But it didn’t feel right to me anymore. I had been feeling this way since 2006, so it was only a matter of time.

This is what it means when the time has come to move on. Despite my own actions of staying longer than I should have, I knew fate and time move on with or without me… so either follow it and see where it leads me, or turn my back on it and drown myself in conflict and addiction and lie to myself, my band, and my family. I believe there always comes a time in a person’s life when he/she becomes aware of the person they will be for the rest of their existence… sounds like a line from a movie but its the truth – trust your heart first and foremost.

My internal instincts pointed to the conclusion that I didn’t want what God Forbid had to offer. I didn’t have the passion to be in a straight-up metal band anymore. The life I saw ahead of me with God Forbid wasn’t worth the sacrifice. I also felt there was something more for me. This was transition. Whatever this transition was and wherever it would lead was more important. It was essential to my life.

On my last tour these feelings were at their peak. At one point, I had a panic attack for two days. I never had a panic attack in my life until that point. Anyone who has endured this kind of stress knows how scary it can be. These panic attacks were the repercussions of forcing myself to walk a path I know had ended long ago. But I kept walking.

And it turned into a path of self-destruction. It wasn’t the rock n’ roll self-destruction that screams “live fast, die young” as the behavior for rebellion. No. This was the pathetic self-destruction. The ‘”How did I get here?”, party-’til-you-don’t-care self-destruction.

In my time pondering what I said to my brother, I was going over my last experience on the road. I thought about the situations I would be in for the Earthsblood record cycle. Lamb Of God Tour. Rock Star Mayhem. I easily came to the conclusion that me continuing this cycle of frustration, anger, drinking, drugs and depression was going to take me out of this world.

If I didn’t quit God Forbid I was going to die. That’s the God’s honest truth.

After the rumors about me leaving the band started to circulate, I called my brother and offered to do the Lamb Of God tour as my final tour with the band. I felt bad leaving them hanging out to dry. I figured the answer would be, “We’re booking the flight now.” The answer was, “We have to discuss it.” I spoke to my brother a day later and was told if I do the tour I can’t be the “black cloud” hovering over everything. As it turns out, the band was getting along better without me in the mix. Everyone considered me to be so damaging to the mentality of the band that they taught a new guitar player the songs on two days notice rather than have me do the tour. I don’t blame them. This is a business after all and each element must be there in its proper place… if one falls, the rest do what they must to keep the focus on business. Just because you have a bad day, week, month, or even year, doesn’t mean the rest of the world has to. I recognize my mistakes and have taken a better path since.

Many of you have hit on some truths regarding my career in God Forbid and my overall state of mind since my departure. I know I’ve been erratic. I’m going to clear the air and tell you guys the truth. My dissatisfaction with my career in God Forbid and imminent departure didn’t stem from “issues with individual members in the band or the record label.” It didn’t stem from “a massive drug addiction.. After some quality time to zoom out, step back and breathe, I realized that it stemmed from the realization that 99% of the goals I wanted to achieve with God Forbid were achieved by 2004. I was lucky to achieve the personal goals of my younger years.

Make a demo. Play a show. Make a full length record. Get signed to a record label. Get a manager. Get a booking agent. Go on tour. Get a guitar endorsement. Get an amp endorsement. Make a video. Get on MTV. Play Ozzfest. Tour with Machine Head. Tour with Slayer. Tour with Slipknot. Sell fifty thousand records. Make a great metal record.

Most of my personal goals were achieved by the time I was 21 years old. The others were reached when the band toured on our own bus and with our own crew on Ozzfest in 2004. The only goal left for me was making a GREAT metal record. I know everyone here has an opinion, but I write music for myself. I always have and I always will make music for myself. Earthsblood was the great record I thought God Forbid was going to make. We achieved that goal and I’m proud of it. I wasn’t able to move on unless we did that. What matters is how happy we as a band and we individually were with it.

But, achieving that goal took its toll on me mentally and spiritually.

I put my entire soul into the Constitution of Treason record. I came into my own vocally, lyrically and spiritually. I found my voice on that record. Most of you may not know this but I wrote 70% of the lyrics for that record. Every emotion within me when I sing my lyrics is pure and bare. Today, I can’t listen to some of those songs. To experience those feelings of hope breaks me apart, because things will never be as they once were.

The words in “Chains of Humanity” say it best: “Judgement day has come at last. The clouds bleed black as the tentacles of the divine replace my blood.” Change is inevitable. Change hurts. We must ask ourselves if we’re really happy. At some point you will have to be honest with yourself. I was not happy wondering if I was being held back from my destiny. That mentality hurt God Forbid’s potential to get better and it hurt my ability to be honest and write great music. The creation of Genetic keeps me motivated to keep seeking and exploring a more unknown side of myself. I believe the music I’m creating has limitless potential.

I have a strong personality and I usually get what I want when I work hard and focus. Everyone has this ability. But I had very high, maybe unrealistic, expectations when it came to performance, songwriting and any other band related issues regarding God Forbid. I put pressure on everyone constantly and I have a short fuse, so it was not pleasant to be around me while I was in such a state of mind. To Doc, Corey, John, Byron and all the close GF family, I’m sorry for making your lives so tough all these years. You guys are doing great. I appreciate who I am today and you are all a part of it.

God Forbid is extremely special to me as is the music we created together. I’m grateful I had the chance to affect countless amounts of people with just a guitar, a pen and the will to succeed. My time has come and I’m at the crossroads, I chose a different path to take. I followed my heart and trusted this decision was for the best in the longrun for all involved. To the God Forbid fans disappointed by me leaving, I’m sorry. Your support and outpouring of responses has been incredible. Thank you so much. I look forward to the future, personally and professionally.

-DC

Check out Dallas’ new project, Genetic, on MySpace.

  • Double D

    Usually I don’t like your blog. I like this one. Great job. I hope you find (or have found) what it is you are looking for.

  • DecrystallizingReason

    Good man.

  • SonOF

    As a longtime God Forbid fan (having seen you guys play tiny venues in like 2000 in NYC, Jersey and Long Island), I am appreciative of the honesty you exhibited in this blog.

    God Forbid was an influential band in my life. When Determination came out i was 19, and in my first year of college. That record was so incredibly raw and powerful (coincidentally, I actually listened to it today while walking my dog). I grew up in the hardcore scene, and GF’s music at the time was this perfect mix of the hardcore attitude mixed with a more technically proficient metal sound. God Forbid undoubtedly opened my eyes to tons of great bands that I still listen to today, and I will continue to support the band as long as they exist.

    Just had to share that, as there too many GF haters around here, many of which perhaps didn’t hear of the band until “Constitution,” and decided to write them off because they were “yet another metalcore band.”

    • SonOF

      I meant to delete the above. sorry for the semi repeated post. :/

  • Chainsaw Majini

    Well said, Dallas. You are a very respectable guy.

  • Me

    Nicely put. Wise choice waiting to put this out there so you could digest it, always good to reflect.

  • SonOF

    God Forbid was an influential band in my life. When “Reject the Sickness” came out, I was a junior in high school, and Determination came out i was 19 ( my first year of college) – these are obviously very impressionable times for a music lover. Those records were so incredibly raw and powerful (coincidentally, I actually listened to Determination today while walking my dog). I grew up in the hardcore scene, and GF’s music at the time was this perfect mix of the hardcore attitude mixed with a more technically proficient metal sound. I have seen the band play tiny venues in NYC, Jersey and Long Island in 1999-2000, as well as large fests and such from 2005-present. God Forbid undoubtedly opened my eyes to tons of great bands that I still listen to today, and I will continue to support the band as long as they exist.

    Dallas, as a longtime God Forbid fan and someone who has been influenced greatly by the band, I am appreciative of the honesty you exhibited in this blog. Although I don’t believe that as a fan I am owed anything from a band, it is nice to understand the inner-workings of the group, especially when in times of turmoil; to see the real life struggles in addition to the successes.

  • Moose_Knuckle

    Very well said, i always did wonder why. Hopefully we’ll hear some more music from you in the future.

  • http://myspace.com/northwestroyale Blake

    I figured you’d talk about it when you were ready, Dallas. To each in their own time. Much respect for putting it all out there like that. You didn’t need to, but I’m glad you did. Best wishes with Genetic.

  • Hammer_Smashed_Hurtt

    Well Dallas, you can always find ‘Sympathy’ in the dictionary between SHIT and Syphilis.

    • !?!

      haha.

  • http://schenkeltown.blogspot.com SchenkelTown

    judge judy could solve this shit in half an hour…plus commercials

  • Slaughterhouse

    I love God Forbid…I first heard you guys right before Gone Forever came out! I totally pictured white dudes w/ long hair playing the music at the time haha…no offense…I have loved everything you guys have put out! Shit is great! I hope you find what you are looking for, sometimes when you stop looking it hits you…but I’m sure you know that!

  • PatrickSTL

    Rad read. Thanks for sharing. Follow your heart is the only advice anyone should heed.

  • \m/Eluveitie\m/

    This has nothing to do with Dallas, but has Bruce Dickinson’s radio show really been cancelled?

    • Sven

      Yes.

  • narcopolypse

    right on dude. it’s not always easy to identify your own feelings, let alone face them and their effects.

  • Kunki

    That was brutally honest, and probably really hard to recant the whole decision to leave GF. I can appreciate your sincerity and in being in bands, A LOT of ego(s) are involved and can obscure your perception of things going on at the time. Its tough to make it work especially for the long run, and in no way should YOUR personal decision to leave the band (one which you started) bear a negative effect on how people look at you. I think too many people have internet balls. You did what you had to do, and anyone else in this world should do the same. You had a great career and have a lot to proud of and you know that. Can’t wait to hear more of what you are doing creatively soon.

  • Harold

    Your not gonna find Jesus and make “worship” music or join Scientology and become a Theta 7 are you?

    j/k

    Do what makes you happy! In the end, your life is all on you buddy.

  • http://www.myspace.com/brutusegypt Timur Reda

    Dallas,

    I frequently read your blog, yet rarely post much because it is more entertaining to read the posts of others; however I just want to tell you that what you’re going through is normal, I almost quit listening to metal between 1998 & 2001 [understand I am not blaming the music 'scene',,, only myself]…I was going through the motions as well, and also realised that it never stops…to this day, life is nothing but trials & tribulations for me…it’s quite smart of you to put your feelings out there, but more importantly, it is actually a genuine gesture on your part if the words that were written are all true. props.

    T

    p.s. come to egypt & get lifted !

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Phil-Hopkins/100000274440932 Phil Hopkins

    That was a very real and heartfelt post and I totally respect everything that you went through. You guys made some amazing music but if you weren’t feeling it anymore then you made the right decision. I look forward to all your future musical projects.

  • Axolotl

    Well, this sounded pretty sincere. It takes balls to admit that you were an asshole and your own band didn’t want you back. I usually get an arrogant vibe off your writing, but not as much this time, which was nice.

    • http://www.myspace.com/7stringslaughter CJLsky

      What he said. I really dug this blog, as I had been wondering what had led to you leaving GF. Thanks for clearning everything up!

  • Bicro

    Never listened to GF

    Never will.

    No care ever.

    More time for BRING ME THE HORIZON! YEAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mathew-James-Saunders/1153389571 Mathew James Saunders

      pleasseeee be joking…

      • Bicro

        Yeha, just about BMTH.

        I like Decrepit Birth and Cynic.

        • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mathew-James-Saunders/1153389571 Mathew James Saunders

          Good man…good man, just making sure haha

          • http://www.myspace.com/brutusegypt Timur Reda

            what’s wrong with Bring Me The Hairdresser? is it the same problem as with the Architects??

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mathew-James-Saunders/1153389571 Mathew James Saunders

    One of the best blogs in a while from you man; brutally honest and to the point. I hope Genetic works out for you. The production value is awesome for one man doing everything, I think a little mastering of the tracks would help them significantly, mainly the vox (especially by a pro-studio engineer). I’m especially noticing that bits and pieces sound really bad ass, but composition wise a few of them don’t need to be 5-6 min. Good luck on your future endeavors and never live in the past! It only prohibits the present.

    • deus x

      Dallas-Keep your head up and do your thing, sometimes it’s diffcult to put you shit on blash for others to put their opions-keep on keepin on!!!!!!!!!

  • http://www.omimetal.wordpress.com The Greys

    Better to go in a new direction than spend your life “going through the motions” with something you don’t love anymore. It sounds like you made the right decision for everyone involved.

    Good luck with the new path.

  • RayRay

    Better late than never…just do not understand why it took a year to come out and tell people why you left but more power to you. Glad the truth finally came out…good luck Dallas

  • pryvt pyl

    heinz 57

  • DustintheWind

    Very heartfelt and well written Dallas.. The music business is a business, and it’s a bitch. Kudos for doing what you want to do and being so open about it man.

  • joshkid

    Great blog dude. Much respect.

  • Dodgy

    That was a touching piece of commentary, and shows a great deal of character on your part being so open about the whole situation.

  • teaches_of_peaches

    Am I the only one who thought this post could have done without the dramatic bullshit and just stuck strictly with the facts?

    • soy el niño más bonito

      the blog was about his feelings… there’s always drama with feelings.

  • http://www.masterful-magazine.com/ Choronzon

    I never particularly cared for God Forbid, but good post, Dallas. Good that you took a year off to figure out what you wanted in life/music and which mistakes you made while with this band.

  • Robotscythe

    I really relate to your sentiments about “moving on” from playing metal. I’ve played guitar for over 20 years. The first 10-12 years were dedicated to metal. Since then I’ve moved in a more bluesy/experimental direction ala Tom Waits/Govt. Mule. I still LOVE metal and listen to it constantly..my metal music collection is ever growing and it will always be a part of my musical DNA. But when it comes to playing/creating music, that just isn’t where my head is at anymore and what I’m doing now is much more artistically satisfying for me.

  • djabthrash

    Interesting blog, honest as it can be.

  • Wolverine999

    Thanks for sharing, Dallas.

  • familyghost

    gayyboy quit!!quit like a lil girl!! I’d quit too if I was in a shit band like God Forbid!!God forbid these posers make another album!!REAL METAL OR GTFO!!this aint no BBQ!!get in the pit if ya wanna talk shit!!get some punk!!we_get_it_here!!WHo0o00o0o0 Wheeeeeeeeee Mmmmmmmmmmmm Hmmmmmmmmmmmmm

    • Hammer_Smashed_Hurtt

      YESS!!!! He’s back…get em ghost!

    • cougar party

      holy shit. Stop drinking so much Mt. Dew before you type.

  • pigchop

    Honest and heartfelt. Nice. We all got bridges to cross or burn – looks like you have crossed over one and, in fine form. Cheers.

  • chtimixeur

    Thanks for sharing your story with such honesty.
    When I read this blog of yours, it sometimes felt like a suicide note, but I’m glad to know you have some new projects to focus on.
    All the best Dallas !

    PS : Constitution is still my favourite metal record of the 2000′s. I hope you top that in the future !

  • Jogeta316

    your split from one band means there are now two.
    as a consumer of metal – i like this greatly.

    Coyle music forever (including your dads jawesome piano pieces)

  • xBEARFIGHTx

    Dallas, Constitution of Treason is my favorite record hands down. I remember walking like 40 minutes to target from my sister’s softball tournament to pick up the record. I got the dualdisk version of it and I swear i watched the dvd side like once a week trying to pick up on some the riffs you guys were laying down in the studio. Fuck it was awesome putting in the disk and hearing the intro to “The End of the World” still gives me goosebumps. All in all it really seemed like everyone was tighter and more flowing on this album more than the others.

    Hope everything works out for you bro!

  • Sammy

    Speaking as a selfish fan, I was disappointed in your GF departure because I loved the clean vocals as a contrast to Byron’s voice that you added to the mix on Earthsblood. That is a fucking great album.

  • Dallas

    Thanks for the feedback dudes. Didn’t know how it was going to go but here’s to some good music and blogs in the future!

    • aj lucas

      your animal dude im ready to hear more material from you

  • ITTOA666

    Kris Norris? He learned the songs in 2 days!? Man is a machine.

    But really, when can we expect the fusion album to come out Dallas? :)

  • Kevin Salinas

    really fucking good, i read one of your interviews a few weeks ago where you touched on some of these aspects. now that youve chewed on it and got it out there’s no where to go but to all those places youve been working hard to get. i noticed ur last few blogs you’ve sounded optimistic and positive, keep it up man, those feelings are the catalyst to get you to where you want to be.

  • PUREDISGUST

    check out white dude….sideways hat….so GANKSTA…hahaha

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kf0TH7bwPVM