METTA MIND JOURNAL: CYNIC’S PAUL MASVIDAL ON THE SHAPE OF SILENCE

Wednesday, May 5th, 2010 at 6:30pm by

…the paramecium senses no more of the flute’s sweet warble than we do of the radio waves that pass through our bodies. It spends its life in silence, or more correctly, in soundlessness, for silence is the delicious muffle of an auditory system in repose, and an animal lacking an auditory system can no more know silence than one born blind can know darkness.

—from Music, the Brain, and Ecstasy by Robert Jourdain

I’m back at it with a particular tune, noticing how the space of silence is critical to the ebb and flow of a song’s evolution and ultimately, the shape of its birth.

Silence is not just about absence, subtraction, or less than. In any arrangement, silence can be performed in the service of contraction or expansion, very much like inhales and exhales. Silence also has a resonant quality because only in the vibrational space of silence can we better feel the parts composed of sound.

I was thinking about this spatial-songwriting concept on the way to rehearsal today and realized that, at present, I’m inside this particular tune as its shape evolves subtly and I’m hurling myself into a modus operandi that I have little control over. My only job here is to maintain a slow, nurturing cultivation….way more detached than smothering. A disciplined patience that sits, waiting for nothing to happen. Calmly active and nowhere to go. Just radiating simple “IS-ness” through the creative process.

Allowing a song to unravel is a delicate undertaking. You have to make room and give it the space it needs, and I mean delicate, kind of like the velvet fuzz that sprouts on a baby deer’s antlers. This fuzzy peach skin nourishes the antlers and helps them to grow. The “space fuzz” plays a big role in the antlers’ strength and shape, while being practically transparent in its makeup. It’s a balancing act of trust and letting go into an organic, velvety handmade shape of silence.

In silence, I can build and release tension, or generate room for something new to happen. Silence is actually quite powerful and intense if I am patient enough to allow it take on a tangible shape. Once in a while, I’ll put the guitar down and see if I can’t draw the shape on paper to see what a song looks like. Sometimes the shape of silence is circular and soft. Other times it’s a square, dead center in the middle of a maze of lines. I’m fascinated with silence and its deceptive complexity.

Each time I give myself the opportunity to be quiet, I get to listen, and that can be a really tough job. Just listening to the inner dialogue and getting that to slow down can be even more difficult. It’s in the silence that I get to take in life as it is, without evaluating it. Or, at least I don’t give the evaluating voice a microphone by forming sounds with my mouth. How many of us are comfortable in the space of long pauses, or do we feel the need to cover up that silence with more noise and distractions (computer, cell phone, video games, burying ourselves in work, and so on)? Some of us only visit the land of quiet when we retire each night for rest.

If you were to draw your personality in the form of a shape, what it would it look like? Are there any pockets of silence in that shape?

I invite readers to experiment by sitting in silence for 3 minutes, paying attention to that moment in the space of silence.

-PM

NOTE:

If you have suggestions for future Metta Mind Journal topics, or questions and comments about life in general, send them here: paul.cyniconline [at] gmail [dot] com

  • Loves2spooge

    yes +10000000000.

    truthfull it’s hard to sit in silence but can be rewarding when we are open to it

  • EarthIsGay

    Thank you for these posts.

  • Discipleofthewatch

    This is interesting as usual, but three minutes of silence? I could be listening to a song in that three minutes! …but really, there are a few minutes each day that pass without me listening to metal… a few, where I usuallly feel deprived, seeing as how I don’t have the auditory system (or the lack thereof) of a paramecium.

  • Alex_P

    Excellent post, Paul, but I have just one question.
    Do you have synesthesia? I find your descriptions of your senses fascinating. I could certainly not draw the shape of my own personality.

    • Coop

      I have synesthesia. It’s fucking awesome. The first sign I had it was when I was younger I associated every letter with a color; A was obviously a red color, B was yellow, C was blue, etc. I thought everyone did that and only recently I discorvered it’s an anomaly. When I listed to music I can see drums being hit in my head, guitar strings that get fuzzier with more distortion and a person’s voice as an image. And everything is in different shades of one color, like everything in Raining Blood is reddish (duh.) It actually pisses me off when a graphic designer makes album art that’s totally the opposite color of the music haha. It’s a pretty cool disorder to have.

      • Alex_P

        I really wish I had that, yeah. What colour is Cynic?

      • http://www.facebook.com/people/Daniel-Winnett/504952291 Daniel Winnett

        This is what annoys me about scientists and doctors calling anomalies “disorders”. Fuck that, what you described is absolutely wonderful and I envy you for having it. I’d love to have that, especially as an artist and musician. To me you basically have a superpower.

        • Alex_P

          Fuckin’ magnets!
          I don’t think it’s considered a “disorder” so much as a “condition”. Anyways, it’s just a point of semantics. Only Jenny McCarthy explicitly believes that the autistic have no soul, and that’s a disorder.
          I have my own disorder (not telling what it is, I tell it to girls after the 3rd date only); it hasn’t really stopped me from being a functioning adult, even though it fucked up my childhood.

      • Dwarfskeet

        I’ve always done something like this. With sounds (mostly music) I can see colors of swirling gases? I don’t know how to describe it. It’s kind of like that windows media player thing, where the colors just go everywhere.

        It’s like a haze, and each sound/instrument has it’s own color gas that swirls around, and moves with whatever is going on in the music. It changes colors as the music does.

        But I always thought everyone did this as well. And don’t most people associate music with colors? Didn’t they do a study where they’d play something and have everyone say what color they thought of, and usually it was the same for everyone. I don’t know.

      • Ruben

        Hello i’m portuguese and some of things that coop describes happens to me a lot of times, but i thought i’d happen to everybody! But to me it only happens when i listen to music, the letter with colors never happen, and also i associate every single name i now with an object that has nothing to do with that name!

  • this

    Silence makes me feel weightless.

  • SKYCHILD

    Silent moments are powerful. That’s why we “observe a moment of silence” to pay our respects to the fallen. Great column Paul.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Sanskar-Wagley/1376400331 Sanskar Wagley

    Silence is golden, but duct tape is silver…great article Paul!

  • http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ob9J3kCELXE Pete Mannion

    Masvidal should spend less time talking shit and more time playing guitar. Seriously.

    • svc181

      You could also spend less time talking shit. Seriously.

    • http://deleted SKYCHILD

      I second that, Pete’s the one talking shit here. Silence thyself, seriously.

    • Watty

      Thank you Pete. Seconded.

      • http://www.facebook.com/people/Kyle-Petrilli/100000460085509 Kyle Petrilli

        Watty for someone who hates Paul’s articles so much, why do you comment (after you’ve obviously read them) after every one?? Seems silly to me. It’s like my younger brother Dominic when we were little would eat a whole mango while saying “god these taste weird, I don’t like them”. It appears you just need something to critique.

    • Mario

      How do you see his discussions as shit? If you’re gonna make that claim, be courteous enough to give a reason or a point of support for yourself, no matter how absurd.

    • http://www.gravatar.com/avatar/62449cbe5ea8d22bcc2e76890fceaa37.png Lord Bling

      Would you like more dating advice columns instead?

      Jackass.

  • Honeynutzz

    At first I tried reading this with music and the TV on and just couldn’t do it, which is weird cause pretty much any time I’m on this site I have music on. But I just didn’t feel like I could properly take in what you where saying until I read it in silence.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Roy-Getpaid-Fry/530649722 Roy Getpaid Fry

    Paul Masvidal is my hero!!!! No one understands what beauty just that “pause” in a song can bring. IT can speak more volumes than any note you could fill that space with.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Taylor-James-Hamilton/1178820034 Taylor James Hamilton

    I love your column, Paul. Very interesting to read and definitely gives me something to think about in the days leading up to your next column. Continue to write.

  • Hugo

    Your column is so inspiring. Just by reading it I feel «purify», better.

  • KilledByDeath

    Well, for me silence is highly intolerable. I mean i have a tv in the next room, and i never watch it, but when i go to sleep i turn it on, set to pretty low volume, and that really helps me fall asleep… Otherwise i just struggle not to think about things.

    • >_>

      I used to approach sleep thinking it would be a good idea to not think about things that way I would fall asleep. Now I just let my thoughts meander down whatever avenues they like when I lay down each night, and after a time I fall asleep. Also I do not consider anytime I spent “trying to fall asleep” as wasted because often enough I gain some valuable insights/consolidation while laying there.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Daniel-Winnett/504952291 Daniel Winnett

    I find silence to be agonisingly painful. Suddenly when the music stops I hear all these voices telling me all sorts of horrible things about myself, my life, my world, what I see, what I hear, what I feel and what I am. The music drowns out the voices without becoming just senseless noise. I sleep with music on too.

    • Alex_P

      You might want to look into that…

    • msv81

      Uhhh, yeah. I’m not placing judgment on you but if you’re serious about what you said, you should immediately seek help in the form of a psychologist or psychiatrist. Sounds like you have some deep seeded emotional and psychological issues that need to be worked out.

      Try meditation as well.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jacquelin-Rostad/635209883 Jacquelin Rostad

    I used to go to a Taize church service that included a lot of meditative, simple/repetitive music and a 3-5 minute period of silence. After a few weeks I started to long for that silent time each week. There are so few spaces anymore, especially public/communal spaces, where we can even experience genuine silence. For me it’s calming and helps me slow my mind down and feel at peace…and when I’ve been able to share that silence with other people in a communal setting like that, it’s even richer.

  • Awful Offal Carnage

    My old jazz band instructor back in high school, when teaching the class about improvising, and how to do so, he gave the class some of the best compositional advice I’ve heard: In music, silence is as important as the sound that surrounds. It gives room for the music to breathe; for the previous phrase to soak in to the listeners mind, among other things.

    I believe this is relevant: 4’33” by John Cage
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HypmW4Yd7SY&feature=related

    • Lil fofo

      Thanks a lot for that.

  • GoingDeaf?

    My ability to enjoy silence completely has been somewhat hindered by a history of loud guitars and crashing cymbals (Tinnitus), but I still sit in silence often during the day.

    Since I work in a studio and listen to music all day, I almost NEVER have music on in the background at home. Sitting, reading, browsing the web, cleaning, etc… all done in just the natural ambience of my environment and it always feels good to be in the moment.

    • Alex_P

      Your username is appropriate.

      I know what you mean. I can’t do any “deep” reading with music. I can read a textbook, but not a novel or a critical essay.

      • PD

        That’s funny you mention that. When I read stuff like Chuck Palahniuk, I ALWAYS have music on in the background. I think my brain is too active, so it needs something to drown out while focusing on the reading. Once I start getting into the book, the music disappears into ambient noise…and I’m talking stuff like Spazz and Leng T’che here, not exactly “reading friendly” or “ambient” music. Everyone’s different and that makes the world go round. <- a bit cliche.

        • Alex_P

          Honestly, I find that grindcore makes for great backround music, simply because as a genre it blends together if you aren’t paying attention.

  • http://reaper-x.deviantart.com/ Reaper-X

    That sounds like an interesting concept and I think as a musician it makes just as much sense to understand the power of silence. Sometimes the space of silence allows our mind to lower its tolerance of whats heavy, just enough for the next hit to feel like the biggest.

    Nice writing, dude.

  • Tanner

    When everything is truly silent, I feel as if I’m the only person on the planet. That deep breath that initiates the silence makes everything else more effortless. Whether its focusing on work, reading, taking a walk, or that car ride on that isolated road with the window down, silence provides that feeling of bliss.

    Once again, great post and thank you Paul.

  • soy el niño más bonito

    i’ve been noticing certain things about silence recently. for YEARS, i have done EVERYTHING with music on (except sleep). only over the past few months, when i’m too lazy to connect my hard drive to my laptop have i stopped constantly listening (but even then, there’s the hum of the computer so i guess there’s still white noise). walking to class, going to the store, doing pretty much anything: music. the only silence i have in my day is when i go to sleep. i went on a small euro-trip a month ago with some friends, and i noticed that every single one of them put on headphones when they were going to sleep.

    some cliché questions to ask about this are: is this generation the culmination of the US culture that prizes efficiency and speed, that never stops moving? is this emblematic of the constant movement in our developing “instant,” Internet society?

  • Blabbermouth

    I have silent farts.

    • The-D

      That is chemical warfare.

  • JohnTurrigenous

    Good post. I read that book too, its great.

  • no-ghost

    not bad, I sit in silence all the time, probably because I smoke a lot of pot. generally though I do need a fan on or something specially when trying to sleep. My ears over the years of playing music to loud have that sweet sweet hissssssssssssss. So I guess maybe Im not really ever in silence.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mike-Long/100000144612811 Mike Long

    Cannabis + blogging = awesome!!!

  • Metalguy

    My brain automatically plays through entire songs. It’s never, EVER silent in my life.

    • Sacajawea

      That’s the way I am. Except I have multiple songs playing at once and voices that remind me of a crowded cafeteria, people all talking at once. I guess that sounds weird, but I’m not joking, and it can be annoying at night.

  • Lil fofo

    Thanks for your post Paul, it has reminded me of a wish taht i had while i was younger, it was the search of absolute silence, i searched for that moment in a lot places, and there was always something, the nosie from the outside, the thoughts, the sound of my own breathing. Anyone else had this wish?.

  • Shinaain

    To echo what discipleofthewatch said, time spent in silence is time I could have spent doing what I love, which is listening to music. (Praise be, sister.)

    Only when I’m feeling (very) brave do I explore the texture and feel of silence, and the results are too personal to type here.

    Too simply put: I appreciate your candor, Paul.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Zech-Lakatos/1685681479 Zech Lakatos

    Not digging it. Just like silence, this is a glorified way of not really saying anything. I love you Paul, you can do better than this :(

  • o_O

    Silence is a space where I can come back to the center. Sitting in silence while focusing on the breath, without craving or aversion to what sensations or thoughts flow through, is an ultimate way to cultivate love, awareness and healing. I find it to be good, hard work.

  • JanJan

    I like this post paul..
    Silence is something where I can lean on to escape reality. To all the worries, problems and everything that gives negative and stressfulness into my life. It’s where I can have peace of mind, To move freely and reflect on everything and meditate on it day and night.

    Silence is a way to have a deeper understanding into yourself.