AT MADISON SQUARE GARDEN, IRON MAIDEN PLAYED ALMOST ALL NEW MATERIAL… AND IT FUCKING RULED

Thursday, July 15th, 2010 at 2:00pm by

Iron Maiden - Madison Square Garden, July 12th, 2010

Photo credit: MS photographic wiz Jacqueline Cheng. More pics (including lots of opening act Dream Theater) coming soon!

The setlist of Iron Maiden’s current U.S. tour has been the topic of much debate lately. At first I was bummed to hear that it would consist of mostly material from Brave New World and newer, the album on which Bruce Dickinson and Adrian Smith rejoined the band. But the more I thought about it the more I realized that it was actually a pretty cool thing for the band to. I LOVED Brave New World so it would be a treat to hear those songs live again after 10 (!) years, and though I couldn’t possibly ever tire of hearing Maiden’s classic songs live, I’d seen them performed on the Somewhere Back in Time World Tour less than two years. Maybe it was time for something different, and maybe it was time for everyone to stop whining and to let the band do their thing. They’ve earned it after all these years.

By the time I was standing at my seat in Madison Square Garden on Monday night I was 100% behind the idea of a Maiden set focusing on new material. And Iron Maiden did a fucking fantastic job with it, putting on a stellar, captivating show as always and giving us, the fans, something just as fun, albeit a bit different, than what we’re used to.

The tour Maiden did a few years back on which they played A Matter of Life and Death in its entirety was too much; I’ll give you that. It was overindulgent, and despite that the fact that Maiden’s new material is strong it isn’t that strong, and a full album performance was just overkill. But the way they mixed material from that album and the slightly older Dance of Death and Brave New World — with a sprinkling of classics — on this new tour was a great way to mix it up. I don’t remember listening to Dance of Death or A Matter of Life and Death all that much upon release, but as the band tore through those songs live I found myself knowing more than I’d thought. And those that I didn’t know I found myself liking enough to want to go back and listen to those albums again. So for Maiden, mission accomplished; they’ve definitely drummed up interest in their newer material.

It’s funny to think, but Brave New World is almost considered a classic Maiden album at this point. It’s universally loved, and the adoration was evident in the crowd. Of course the BNW songs didn’t elicit the audience action that the true classics did, but you could tell tons of folks knew the songs by their cheers and their fist pumps timed to key moments of the songs.

And what about from the band’s perspective? Bruce Dickinson gave a short between-song rant about how the fact that Iron Maiden still release new music is what enables them to tour the world and pack arenas despite a generally weak global concert market, and he’s 100% right. When he asked the crowd how many folks were seeing Maiden for the first time, an unbelievable number of people raised their hands and cheered; Bruce — and us — did an incredulous double-take and asked the crowd once more. It’s all because of the machinery that drives a new album; getting the band’s name in the press and releasing new songs to radio and creating music videos all get the band’s name in the public consciousness again where they can attract new fans. The proof is in the pudding. I was one of those fans too, once upon a time, who got into the new Maiden album then went back and discovered the rest. Since then, I’ve seen Maiden live 4 or 5 times.

(Side note: There’s another band taking the same exact approach. Despite this act being around for 25 years, when you go to their shows you see as many young faces as old. That band is opening act Dream Theater.)

Of course Bruce and co. must tire of playing the same old songs over and over, so thankfully they’ve got decent new material with which they can mix things up. What we’re witnessing on this Iron Maiden tour is a very special moment in the band’s history; they’ve got three solid albums behind them and another on the way, and we’re watching a confident band not yet past their prime continuing to chug along. I doubt we’ll ever get to hear some of those songs from Brave New World live ever again! But you’ve seen the same old classics before, and DON’T WORRY, you’ll see them all again. Enjoy this tour for what it was; this was a special tour indeed.

Which is to say nothing of their always amazing stage performance; how the fuck do they do it? There are few bands as entertaining to watch. Maiden are the kings. Bruce is astonishing. The best. The absolute best.

If this tour has yet to hit your city, make sure you don’t miss it. It’s worth the ticket price.

-VN

  • the opposition machine

    seeing them tonight…so pumped…i never understood all the hate this setlist got…the millenial stuff is really good…maybe not classic stuff like the 80s but what were you expecting from a band that just did a tour consisting of nothing but stuff theyve already played quite literally at this point over 1000 times?

    • pat

      seeing them tonight too
      I’ve seen them play the classics I’m stoked for the new stuff

  • bubbles

    Very well said. I agree 100%. I saw two shows this tour. Outstanding.

  • Cokane

    I have to agree with every word.Can’t wait to see Maiden for the 5th time next year…

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Bobby-Tims/1313713879 Bobby Tims

    i was actually one of those virgins monday night, so going in i asn’t as pumped because it was my first time and i wanted to see a couple of the other classics. but holy fucking shit. you are absolutely right, and now i’m paying more attention to the newer albums that in all honesty i probably would have overlooked. long live iron fucking maiden.

  • Chris

    I heard that saw them at PNC and it fucking ruled

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Devon-Czekaj/550092101 Devon Czekaj

    I was at the NJ show. The band had so much energy you could tell they were thrilled to play songs they almost never played live before. Bruce was amazing, just as strong as on the studio albums.

  • MammothCommander

    I think Iron Maiden is one of those rare bands that sounds ten times better live than they do on albums.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mike-Long/100000144612811 Mike Long

    Just saw them for the first time in Pittsburgh last night and they kicked so much ass. One of the best nights of my life so far

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ben-Robson/1375985482 Ben Robson

      hell yes. such an awesome show.

      • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jordan-Oates/1476540021 Jordan Oates

        That show was awesome.

        And you’re the guy that one the Nevermore contest right? Are you gonna be performing with them in Pittsburgh on Oct 26?

        • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jordan-Oates/1476540021 Jordan Oates

          *won*

  • Ian

    I am sort of sad I missed this. I saw Maiden on the Somewhere in Time and Seventh Son tours. I don’t have much interest in arena shows anymore but this would have been the exception had I had some friends who really wanted to go.

    I don’t think it can be overstated how amazing it is that Maiden continue to put out above-average new material after all these years. It’s unheard of. Has there ever been a more unlikely story than Maiden doing arena tours on NEW MATERIAL in the year 2010? If you had suggested that in 1993 you would have been laughed out of the room by your flanel wearing friends.

  • cougar party

    Maiden’s the best live band in the world. They have more energy than bands half their age. I feel very lucky I’ve been able to see them twice. It’s great to see these old guys on top of their game so late in their career; which should be a blueprint for any band that hopes to be around as long as them without being relagated to playing state fairs.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ryan-Sean-Heron/9391234 Ryan Sean Heron

    I respectfully have to disagree with the thing about the new material being what draws new fans into Maiden. Younger generations go back and discover older classic music all the time. Great music is timeless. and in this day in age when radio and mtv means absolutely nothing, music is more timeless than ever. You can easily get into whatever you want from whatever time period. Most of the first time maiden fans at that show were probably much more familiar with number of the beast than they were with a matter of life and death.

    • stu1

      You are completely correct. No new kid is picking up their brand new album and saying “that was great, I need to go back!” Kids are starting with Killers, Number of the Beast etc

      • Joe

        Dance of Death came out when I just got into Maiden so it was one of the 1st Maiden albums I owned. It’s not that they’re picking up the new albums 1st, but when a new album comes out there’s intense promotion and that’s what gains a lot of new fans that are around 13 or 14 when a new album comes out. Between new albums, it’s definitely stuff like Guitar Hero and all that stuff. For new Maiden fans, when they’re a new fan and a new album is released they grow up with that album as much as some others. I’ve listened to DoD just as much as Powerslave and Number of the Beast. It’s all about timing.

        • Octillus

          For sure! I first picked up Edward the Great (The one that came out before Dance of Death) after seeing some cable tv ad for it, and everything just clicked in my head, that I needed to own music by this band.

          I played the hell out of it for a week, and I went out and bought an album of theirs.

          Which one? Brave New World. GREAT STUFF.

          I now own every core album they’ve released in some form (Hell yeah No Prayer cassette, so I don’t have to actually listen to it!)

          Once Maiden retires, man, there will be no more great Arena acts left. (assuming that the other greats who are actually older than they are)

  • http://www.metalinsider.net Bram

    Agreed on all counts. Sure, something – anything – off Seventh Son or Powerslave would’ve been amazing, but the band puts on such a great live show that it’s pretty much beside the point. I turned to a friend I was at the show with on Sunday and said ‘y’know, the only thing wrong with new Maiden is one thing – it’s not old Maiden.” If I were seeing them for the first time, like many in the audience were, the era would’ve been irrelevant.

  • Ørsaeth

    I saw them in Vancouver and it fucking kicked ass. Hearing songs like Reincarnation of Benjamin Breeg and Ghost of the Navigator was awesome. While it was a little bit disappointing that I didnt get to hear Run to the Hills or The Trooper, I can watch live version on DVD. One of the best moments (I thought) was Blood Brothers. The way Bruce introduced it talking about Dio. “Look up to the sky and give him the sign!”. And with everybody singing “we’re Blood Brothers” at the chorus… it was magical

  • Robotscythe

    Seeing them in Virginia, July 20th/ Last night of the US Tour. I’m amped!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Phil-Freeman/1315346890 Phil Freeman

    I was disappointed by one thing and one thing only about Monday night’s set – that they dropped “Brighter Than A Thousand Suns” (my favorite song from A Matter Of Life And Death) from the set early in the tour, replacing it with “Wrathchild.” I thought the idea to play almost entirely material from the last 10 years was brilliant. This was the fifth time I’ve seen them live since 2004 – the only tour I skipped was the one where they played AMOLAD front to back. I wonder what they’re gonna do next time, though – all material from between Fear Of The Dark and the two albums without Bruce or Adrian?

  • http://www.twistedcritic.wordpress.com Chris

    I was at the MSG show and had no problems with the setlist (although I wish “No More Lies” had been replaced by something better from Dance of Death – like “Paschendale” or even “Rainmaker”). It was entertaining sitting on the side of the stage and getting to see what Bruce does every time he runs back there (usually wiping his face with towels and drinking lots of water), but sometimes just waiting on the steps until he has to run back up. It was also great to see DT play MSG for the very first (and maybe last?) time.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Alejandro-Aldana/683878171 Alejandro Aldana

    i should’ve been there, but i didn’t have tickets =(

  • http://www.vertebrae33.com/ Rodney

    funny thing..at first I was bummed…but I enjoyed the show a lot….and since then I have been listening to them over and over again…

  • Vakarm

    Saw them in Montreal not too long ago with one of my friends. It was her first maiden show (I saw them two years ago during the somewhere back in time tour also). She was all bummed out because because they didnt play run to the hills. She said she was dissapointed. had to slap her

    BUT the show fucking ruled!!! i loved BNW and dance of death, even “A Matter…” the setlist was just awesome

  • Alex_P

    Fully and completely agreed. It was a fantastic night and the highlight of my summer.

  • mike
    • bubbles

      that’s the lamest “review” i’ve ever read. Fail.

      • http://Idiot GoMaiden

        you are so lame. SBIT was the tour to hear all the ‘classics’…. Now you slam a band for playing high quality music that other bands can’t even comprehend playing is beyond me…… Who is better? Who is more loved despite no radio airplay? Who is the band all other bands want to be?

        Maiden….enough said.

        Up the Irons forever!!!!!

        • http://Idiot GoMaiden

          People like you are the reason Bruce dislikes playing the USA on tour….You are all stuck in the 80′s when we should all just appreciate what the best heavy metal band of all time is doing….
          Selling tix and playing in front of thousands of people and bringing new fans into the fold…

          I’m was so happy to hear the newer stuff played live. It’s all Maiden and even better in person.

          Can any other band say that….? No.

          Hammers Rule……..deal w/ it.

          Maiden Fan from day one….bought it on 8-track :-)

  • Unicornaxe

    The new fan attendance is due in large part to flight 666 which consisted of only pre brave new world material. Go figure

  • zac

    I was at the show in Pittsburgh Wednesday night! First time to see Maiden and DT. I must honestly say this is one of the greatest shows I’ve been too!

  • Jack

    Absolutely fucking right. I was with a guy who’s just gotten into Maiden recently and knows the millennial stuff about as well as he knows the old stuff, and he didn’t give two shits they didn’t play the classics. Their energy and enthusiasm make the DOD/AMOLAD stuff a blast to see live, even if – from a strictly songwriting perspective – that material isn’t their best.

    BNW, on the other hand, is a bona fide classic at this point. Those songs have held up really well over the last 10 years, and everyone who was at MSG received “Blood Brothers” and “Wicker Man” about as well as they would have received, say, “Revelations” and “Wasted Years.”

    Couldn’t be happier for Maiden right now. They’re enjoying a second golden age and they deserve every second of it.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Paul-Pelkonen/1184592898 Paul Pelkonen

    Saw Maiden at MSG on Monday night. Fifth show. Thirteenth Dream Theater show. Great set and no complaints here.

    And the review:

    http://hairwhip.blogspot.com/2010/07/concert-review-iron-maiden-cross-final.html

  • Mark

    MSG gig was amazing. I made a transatlantic trip just to attend, and it was beyond worth it!

  • RandomGuitarist

    Go here for live videos of this tour. I saw them perform in Ottawa earlier this month with Dream Theater for Bluesfest.

    http://www.youtube.com/theonlybandever1000 ——- Go to the Iron Maiden Playlist