IT TOOK A FEMALE REVEREND TO PRAISE METAL

Tuesday, August 31st, 2010 at 3:00pm by

I don’t think reverends that are also ladies are so rare today — my high school girlfriend’s mother was a reverend (actually, both of her parents were reverends, believe it or not). But I have to think there’s some connection between a woman who holds a position that some tight-asses would consider “unorthodox,” and the fact that that same woman has now publicly declared that “the Church, especially at this agonized time, has a serious gospel lesson to learn from this darkest and heaviest music.”

In article in British newspaper The Telegraph, Reverend Rachel Mann has this to say about metal:

“The music’s willingness to deal with nihilistic and, on occasion, extremely unpleasant subjects seems to offer its fans a space to accept others in a way that shames many Christians.

“Metal’s refusal to repress the bleak and violent truths of human nature liberates its fans to be more relaxed and fun people.”

She also says that metal fans are “graceful, welcoming and gentle.”

Of course, for readers of this site and headbangers across the world, Reverend Mann will just be preaching to the converted (pun intended); I’ve long felt that I’d be in prison for murder if I didn’t listen to aggressive music that is often about murder, so, yeah, “metal’s refusal to repress” the bleak/violent/etc. is, I think, certainly liberating for the listener. But it’s always great to see someone so closely associated with an organized religion that has often frowned on our music of choice give said music praise.

Read the rest of the article here, then weigh in with your thoughts in the comments section below.

-AR

[via Metal Underground]

  • http://www.gravatar.com/avatar/46e389eb8b79606050d3d447431ff6ac?s=80 Nate

    Totally agree. It’s about time someone realized metal doesn’t cause violence by talking about it. No one’s ever attempted to rip a chick’s guts out through her pussy because they listened to too much Cannibal Corpse.

    • inhumanrampager

      That would make for an interesting news story though…

    • Metalguy

      Nate…
      Do i have to link to a certain old post of yours? Watch your tongue boy.

  • Jack

    This one of many examples I’ve seen of some religious people actually being cool about Metal and shit.

    There’s that church in PA which lets a ton of Metal bands play, which is pretty cool.

    • CrapMcPoopin

      First Unitarian Church in Philly? I’ve been to a few shows there, it’s mostly core bands that play there now, but they have always been a super liberal church. Most Unitarians are very welcoming and accepting.

      • Jack

        A friend of mine saw Municipal Waste there I think.

      • http://www.facebook.com/people/Dorian-Legodick-Lafferre/1432620197 Dorian Legodick Lafferre

        You mean Rocketown? The place that had a date for the Skeletonwitch/BDM tour?

        • D. Bliss

          Living in Philly and going to the (First Unitarian) Church has definitely been something that stops and makes you think about the acceptance and cooperation that exists between different cultures.. I’ve lived in Philly my whole life, and been to pretty much all its venues, and the Church is by far the best place to go to for shows. The r5 people who run the shows are great people, who seem to be on great terms with the people who run the actual Church. I’d definitely suggest hitting that place up to anyone who lives near or in Philly.

  • Between the Cookie and Me

    Well I did notice that most people who listen to metal are chilled out dudes. Unless you’re into Black Metal, cause if you are, shit always gets real.

  • Doc

    There’s your difference between “religion” and Christianity.

    • paganheart

      1

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jake-Lentz/20725060 Jake Lentz

      Yep.

    • Crentist the Dentist

      Amen.

  • http://deathmetalbaboon.com/ byrd36

    “Miss Mann, priest-in-charge of St Nicholas’s, Burnage”

    hehe Burnage, I can’t believe you pot heads didn’t point that out! Maybe that’s why she’s so cool.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/David-Yu/2207107 David Yu

    Really thought provoking article!

  • ZackP

    ABOUT GOD DAMN TIME!

    • Major Zim

      ^

  • |Tch0rT|

    Weed, Metal, video games, and pussy keep me from killing people. \m/

    • Brownsound

      You just described 3/4ths of my life!

      • Metal Fuckin’ Dave

        You should try pussy. Good stuff.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Daniel-Winnett/504952291 Daniel Winnett

    We’ve finally found it: A preacher worth not setting fire to. Though if she’s hot she’ll get a good gang-raping.

    • Ben

      Well, 9 out of 10 people enjoy a gang rape ;)

      • kvlt of personality

        lol’d

  • kmfcm

    A christian who doesn’t hate fun?

  • shpostal

    It’s obvious this reverend isn’t from anywhere around the Bible Belt midwest like I am. They still can’t accept Lawrence Welk unless they turn him down really low. The most untrustworthy people you’ll ever meet are the ones with neat trimmed hair and suits who invite people like Anita Bryant to their megachurches. I’ve always said metal is an outlet for aggression, and healthy and therapeutic as a result. Yes, a mosher might get banged up occasionally, but metal heads don’t go to churches and yell how they hate liberals and start firing. Before someone brings up Dimebag Darrell, let us remember his killer was mentally ill to begin with, something that can happen to anybody.
    Question authority!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/David-Adam-Meredith/1463830541 David Adam Meredith

    I agree with what this woman says 100%. Being a female reverend is still, in itself, a fairly “liberal” concept. Her praise of metal and it’s culture is surprising but not as shocking as a Catholic Priest saying the same thing. I know every metal head, as well as I, says the same thing. “If it weren’t for metal, I’d fucking kill somebody.”

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/David-Adam-Meredith/1463830541 David Adam Meredith

    I agree with what this woman says 100%. Being a female reverend is still, in itself, a fairly “liberal” concept. Her praise of metal and it’s culture is surprising but not as shocking as a Catholic Priest saying the same thing. I know every metal head, as well as I, says the same thing. “If it weren’t for metal, I’d fucking kill somebody.”

    • Jack

      Uhh… no, I would not kill anyone regardless of whether or not I had Metal…

  • http://www.jaydinitto.com Jay

    Christians (and Christian leaders) have been okay with metal as music for decades.

    • Crentist the Dentist

      Agreed. People need to do their research…
      P.S. I figured this was the Jay I was thinking it was.

      • Brownsound

        lol @ delusional christians

  • http://www.jaydinitto.com Jay
  • Elston_gunn

    I don’t know… call me crazy, but I think if you’re a committed Christian you probably *should* have a problem with, say, Slayer. Now, I myself don’t have a problem with Slayer, but I’m not a committed Christian, or a Christian at all. I totally agree that many Christians should be a little more laid-back and fun-loving, but that certainly doesn’t require listening to metal. (In fact, to me “metal” and “fun” aren’t really synonymous. Metal is awesome, but if I wanted “fun” music, I’d look elsewhere.) It seems to me like the reverend is inventing post-hoc rationalizations to justify her affection for metal.

    • Rob S

      I’m a very devout catholic and Tbh, theres a quote that Tom Araya himself (Who is infact a christian) that says “People are not in good shape to where they have to question their own belief system because of a book or a story somebody wrote, or a Slayer song”. This pretty much explains my thoughts on the matter.

      • paganheart

        Agreed. Those who think their faith system can’t be challenged and must be protected and shielded from anything that criticizes, questions, or makes fun of it (music, movies, TV shows, books, politics, etc.) don’t have much of a faith system, IMHO.

      • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mark-Lee/1565314465 Mark Lee

        Isn’t that what the Bible does? Makes (or should I say “helps”) people change their belief system. And it’s a book and a story somebody wrote.

        • pokwok

          What’s your point? Just as a non-christian can choose to be unmoved and unaffected (brainwashed?) by the Bible, a christian can easily choose to not let metal, or anything else change their belief system.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Dorian-Legodick-Lafferre/1432620197 Dorian Legodick Lafferre

      I think holding a complete worldview of any kind requires that people judge all art not just on whether they agree with the subject matter, but also the form of the art itself. As a Christian myself, I would disagree with Slayer if they advocate the violence and atrocity they sing about (which, after looking over some of their lyrics, I don’t believe they advocate so much as they just talk about), but it is another matter entirely to judge their music as it stands without lyrical content. Maybe the lyrics are “bad,” but what about the riffs? The musicianship? The energy in the performance? In that sense, I love Slayer, as well as many other bands that have subject matter that I may disagree with.

      Personally, I had to reconcile my love of violent, devil-worshiping music with my love of God through much of my childhood. I’m thankful for that opportunity to rationally work that out, and I honestly think I became a smarter, more mature person as a result.

    • Sid

      She wasn’t specifically talking about anti-religous bands. She was focusing on the positive psychological effect metal has. Two entirely different discussions.

  • paganheart

    Probably wouldn’t convince the holy-rolling Southern Baptists in my family that metal is anything but “Satan’s music,” but then, most of them also don’t believe women belong in the pulpit (or belong anywhere except barefoot and pregnant in the kitchen, for that matter.) Not really surprising that a female pastor is saying it; most denominations that accept women as ministers are more progressive-leaning and willing to accept that we don’t live in the Victorian ages anymore. If more Christian leaders were like this woman, I might not have told the church to go fuck itself years ago.

    I think Paul Masvidal wrote in one of his blogs about accepting and embracing the darker parts of our psyche and life in general, and no genre of music does that better than metal. Metal can be amazingly cathartic; there have been days in my life when it was the only thing that kept me from taking a razor blade to my throat and I know it’s the same for others.

    Click through and read the full article from the Guardian if you haven’t already. Rev. Mann makes some great points.

  • bekilicious

    ditto to y’all, it’s about time metalheads are recognizing that not all christians are haters. metal has been among us since the early 80s- stryper, the crucified, guardian, i could go on forever… just like all metalheads, fanatics come in all shapes and sizes, church ones too… if u get the pont of the message, metal is not anti-gospel. it’s like mann says, recognizing the brutality of human nature, and we make community out of our love for it. same with metal, if you get the point of the message (ref slayer), it’s not about actually performing satanic rituals on people, it’s about laughing that shit like that really does happen because ppl are morons and we understand that about human nature- we’re honest cuz we know how f*cked up we are as a humanity. deniars can go hide under a rock or a pew and call metal evil then cuz they don’t even know themselves or why they even need their Gospel.

    i know i need it, and i need metal, both like i need air in my lungs.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jacquelin-Rostad/635209883 Jacquelin Rostad

    As a future female pastor and a metal fan, this article rocks so much! I’ve said similar things about metal’s honesty about matters of the soul/darkness/death/etc., but she’s put it all together beautifully. I’m saving this for every annoying future instance (and they happen frequently) when someone asks how I can be genuinely passionate about the field I’m going into and be a metal fan.

    • Doc

      Pharisees. You go, sister.

      That is all.

  • Charlie

    Religion & Republicans need to die.

  • Dalton Hinton

    I listen to lots of Metal and -core music and am a very devout Christian. I love br00tal shit too. Lol.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Conor-Davis/1381188316 Conor Davis

    heyy, religion is finally doing something right and opening up their caged minds. XD