REVIEW: MACHINE HEAD’S UNTO THE LOCUST

Monday, September 26th, 2011 at 2:00pm by

Not that art is a competition or anything, but just you so know where I stand as a Machine Head fan and how your own tastes may or may not match up with my own, here are my three favorite pre-Unto the Locust MH releases, in descending order of preference:

  • The Blackening
  • Burn My Eyes
  • Through the Ashes of Empires

So.

Machine Head’s The Blackening was some kind of goddamn masterpiece, an album that rightfully met with near-universal acclaim. And that acclaim wasn’t just hype, or critics and fans being swept up in the moment; the four-and-a-half years since its release haven’t diminished The Blackening‘s power any. There are few, if any, bands on earth that could make something that friggin’ good, and then follow it up with a record of equal, or even greater, quality.

And the bad news is, that Machine Head have not achieved this near-impossible task. Unto the Locust is not as good as The Blackening. But it is as good as Through the Ashes of Empires, and totally worth the nearly half-decade fans have had to wait for it — and that ain’t nuthin’ to sneeze at.

Aside from one kinda alt rockish semi-ballad, “Darkness Within,” the band hasn’t made many adjustments to their sound, and the chorus to one track, “Be Still and Know,” even sounds kinda like it could be the cousin of The Blackening‘s “Halo.” But it’s all good , ’cause said sound is awesome, and Machine Head continue to excel at classic-Metallica-style epic deathrash. Album opener (and my personal favorite track on the record) “I Am Hell (Sonata in C#)” moves from a choir of Robb Flynns to an absolutely massive elephants marching riff that will stay stuck in your head for days on end to the scorchingly fast ripper that composes the bulk of the tune, and each movement absolutely slays; the transitions between the sections of “Pearls of the Swine” are a little less obvious, but those sections pack no less of a punch, and the guitar tone that Flynn and co-guitarist Phil Demmel have opted for is damn near perfect — chunky but never muddy. These songs may technically have running times that are double that of the choice cuts from most neo-thrash and deathcore releases, but they actually feel half as long because they never fail to, y’know, ROCK. They rock so hard, in fact, that the high-pitched clean vocals on “This is the End,” which should irritate the crap outta me, absolutely do not bother me one bit. Even my least favorite song on the release, the finale “This is Who We Are,” is better than 90% of the stuff you’ll hear from other bands this year.

So what did The Blackening have that Locust does not? I’ve been struggling with that question for awhile now, and I can’t seem to articulate a definitive answer, so shame on me, I guess. Call it a gut feeling; for whatever reason, Locust just doesn’t seem as furious as its predecessor, and as good as the songs are, they don’t quite achieve that same level of “Honey I’ll be right back I’m off to slaughter the neighbor and his family with an axe” rage that the best material on Blackening did. It’s entirely possible that The Blackening simply arrived with fewer expectations; Through the Ashes of Empires was a great album to be sure, but it came on the heels of three records that a lot of MH fans, myself included, were not very keen on, and I don’t think we knew quite what to expect from the band moving forward. But Locust, as I said, has the unfortunate task of following what may be the album that defines Machine Head’s legacy. Maybe with age, those expectations will dissolve away, and Locust will seem even cooler than it does now.

But even if it ends up being the South of Heaven to Machine Head’s Reign in Blood, that’s really not something about which to complain. Your standards would have to be inhumanly high not to enjoy the album at all at all. This Locust can plague me anytime.

(4 outta 5 horns)

-AR

  • http://www.facebook.com/mike.reagan Mike Reagan

    Only like the first 3 songs

    • Blaxpheme

      About to pop it in, still finishing up my first listen of the new Gary Numa record.

  • LoGs the Shit

    This album kicks so much ass, but it simply wasnt possible to follow the blackening

  • corrupt_toolbox

    “it came on the heels of three records that a lot of MH fans, myself included, were not very keen on”
    What was wrong with The More Things Change?

    • http://heavymetalist.com TheHeavyMetalist

      My favourite

  • woah

    This album blew me away. 5 horns up.

  • Names

    This Is the End is pretty much the greatest thing they’ve ever done.

    • Names

      On another note… I REALLY want to read a MS review of Mastodon’s latest.

      • crank

         If it is more that 3 horns, I am gonna shit myself. That album is fucking garbage.

        • Metalwolf

          No it’s actually pretty cool.

          • crank

            No, it’s actually garbage.
             

          • Ben

            No, actually you’re garbage.

            (ooo burn)

          • crank

            No, actually you’re burned.

  • Spanky

    South of Heaven > Reign in Blood

    • The_I

      Yep.

      • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jay-Johnson/100001321441701 Jay Johnson

        Angel of Death>south of heaven

  • Brian m/(-_-)m/

    i got the deluxe edition and i havent had an opportunity to listen yet, but im actually REALLY excited for their cover of the sentinel by judas priest m/

  • Anonymous

    When you make an album as good as The Blackening, the next album will almost never be as good, so I agree that Locust doesn’t quite meet up to par with its predecessor. That being said, I wasn’t disappointed at all when I listened to this. It’s great to hear new fresh material from them and is just a shiver-giver in general. Amazing record.

  • http://www.facebook.com/FlannelBastard Dylan Jones

    While I like The Blackening, its not as good as everyone says it is.  His vocals have never really done it for me, as they just don’t fit the intensity of the rest of the group.
    That and it always seemed a little empty. :L  I’m sure I’m going to get called IMN or a retard, but thats just how I feel.  DEAL WITH IT BUTTFUCKS

    • Names

      I think his lyrics have always been the weakest link. “Slanderous” is the first example that comes to mind. Awesome song, shit lyrics.

    • ACoffinShip

      I generally like Flynn’s vocals and the lyrics on The Blackening but I felt they really dragged down Through the Ashes of Empires.  Even when they were saying things I could more or less get behind something about them always came across as amazingly clunky.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=9391234 Ryan Sean Heron

    south of heaven vs. reign in blood analogy is perfect. or even justice vs. master of puppets. those albums are still really really really fucking good. gotta take it as its own entity.

  • Rsh923

    everybody knows that the burning red is the best machine head album

    • Pastor of Muppets

      TIME 2 SEE BELIEVE THISSIN ME!

  • Ghr

    Great album.

    Seeing them live in november, Shit wil be intense

  • bilegrinder

    The overwhelmingly good reviews for this album continue; Metal Hammer gave it 10/10 (or maybe it was 9.5/10), Decibel gave it 8/10, another publication from the U.K. gave it 7/7 (can’t recall which at the moment), and now Axl gives it 4/5 horns. It’s not just “professional” reviewers, either; I’ve seen almost nothing but universal praise for “Unto The Locust” by fans as well.

    Honestly, I’m stumped as to what exactly other people are hearing that I’m not. Coming into it, I kept my expectations very low because I do agree with the universal acceptance of “The Blackening” as one of the most significant metal releases in the last decade (if not longer). I was and am continually blown away by the musicianship and pure aggression exhibited on the last album. And during their seemingly endless touring cycle, I managed to catch the band at least 10 times, perhaps more….I lost count after a while. 

    With that in mind, I assumed the new album would fall short of high expectations and certainly wouldn’t be another “masterpiece” like its predecessor. I expected even less upon hearing about the band going into the studio around February or March of this year and then being completely finished with the writing AND recording process a mere three months later. Sure, there’s no doubt the band wrote some of the base material during their insanely long touring cycle, but considering how long it took them to write “The Blackening”, I simply didn’t foresee “Unto The Locust” being anything more than a good album.

    When I finally heard the album a week or two ago, everything I assumed about it became a reality. Like Axl, my favorite track is the opener; it’s yet another epic, amazing way to start an album (a trend Machine Head has followed since their debut, as every single album has an amazing first track). But other than that, almost the entirety of “Unto The Locust” sounds like B-Sides from the last sessions, songs that simply didn’t make the cut for “The Blackening” – this is especially true of “Locust”, a song I wasn’t particularly fond of when the “advance” version was released a few months back, and while the finished version does have more “oomph”, it’s still a mediocre track at best.

    Also, the closing track, with the choir of children, really bugs me. The kids feel out of place and cheesy, and the high pitched vocals annoy me…a lot. It’s a shit song and a horrible way to close out what is otherwise a somewhat questionable effort by one of my favorite bands of all time.

    In essence, it’s not a BAD album. But I would definitely rank it below “The Blackening”, “Through The Ashes of Empires”, “Burn My Eyes”, and “The More Things Change”. Hell, I don’t care what anybody says, I still do love “The Burning Red”, too, and going back to it again this week, I think I even enjoy that album more than the new one. Oh well, to each his own. Glad the band is getting good reviews, perhaps they’ll actually be able to headline their own tours instead of being support for another 4-5 years. But I just hope their next album is better than this one.

    • mikey

      Completely agree. Not buying into all the hype. It’s not that great.

    • random

      Couldn’t agree more.
      Especially the previously released track “locust” lowered my expectations, so i kind of saw it coming. Considering this, i was astonished by all the critics hailing even that really lame song. The new album lacks all aggressivity you’d expect from a MH (especially the 2 first) record.
      The author should once again listen to TheMoreThingsChange, how could that one be disappointing?

  • Kieblerelf10101

    It sucks. Fuck this shit.

    • Basshole

      fuck you virgin.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Tom-Saunders/660453371 Tom Saunders

    I really want to dig this album, but I really don’t.

    For starters, I really hate the I am Hell intro. Once the riff kicks in, it’s OK, but nothing more, and the breakdown-y bit is pretty sweet, but other than that, meh.

    The song after it is just OK, standard Machine Head fare, can’t remember what it’s called.

    Locust is the best song on the album, I really like the main riff, but I don’t really like the chorus, so that kind of drags it down for me. I do like the song overall, I just don’t think it’s up there with anything on The Blackening.

    Darkness Within and This is the End are also forgettable. I know one of them has a horrible acoustic intro with some not too great singing, which kind of defeats the point of a MH album for me, I just want a full blooded, all out riff fest. This is not that.

    Pearls Before the Swine is another OK song.

    Who We Are has the abysmal children’s choir. Nuff said.

  • Chupacabrax

    Does anyone else find the production shitty on this album? Its sounds nowhere near as clean and crisp as the blackening, hell, the new chimaira cd recorded in a garage 30 mins from my house was recorded better.

    It kinda sounds like its a rough mix for the whole album, besides the fact that some of the songs are meh, and the kids singing like everyone else said.

    And i love machine head, even stuck through the burning red and supercharger years seeing them live a bunch of times. Its not internet “insta-hate”, this cd just should have and could have been better.

    • Ray

      Colin Richardson did not mix the album which def hurt the band because he is a master.  But overall the record sounds good but not AS good as The Blackening

    • Plasmaterial

      Rob Flynn and the guy who mixed the “advanced version” of Locust several months ago mixed this, unfortunately, due to Colin Richardson being unavailable. Surely the band could have enlisted a name producer to mix this properly, because you are right, it sounds like absolute crap. There is a variation of the mixing “standard” throughout the album. I hope there will be a remixed and remastered version a few years down the line.

      • http://www.facebook.com/people/Brandon-Ware/1017199668 Brandon Ware

        I’m glad i’m not the only one!  i’m the one that posted this earlier, but it wouldn’t let me sign in right on my phone.  

        i listened to it more on the way home from work to make sure i wasn’t just jumping to a conclusion, but it sounds so flat.  i think you’re completely right that it’s just “standard”.  

        i’m not comparing it to the blackening and saying its bad cause i dont like the cd, it really does sound sub par.

        • KRANG

           Agreed, I like the songs on this CD a lot, but The Blackening just SOUNDED so good. Remastered would be way sick.

      • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100001506729462 Lars Kuperus

        yes i agree a remastered version would be better!

  • crank

    This album slays. I would say 4.5…This is who we are needed less pedophilia.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ian-Cimaglia/1097033911 Ian Cimaglia

    Haters gonna hate, the album is killer. Definitely a strong followup to The Blackening.

  • metalhead616

    what hype are you perceiving?  ^^.. I like the album. Be still and know rulz. Best songs ever. Since Blackening they became relevant for me as a guitarist.
    There are changes that I dont prefer but they are always truly  themselves. Fuck you if u dont like the kids and the intro… Thats all 1000000 better than the experiment ‘Loutellica ‘ did.

    They are a mature band.

  • Anonymous

    I really like this album, and I actually think that “Darkness Within” is a great track, and one of the best songs about losing your faith ever written. That being said, I agree with Axl here on the high expectations and how it will probably forever be in the shadows of The Blackening.

    Ok, time to go back to jizzing all over the new Atlas Moth…

  • Billandtedd

    I find this album like saying what is better peace sells or rust in peace? Kinda hard to decide right? Its up to the listener personally i think this is a little better than the blackening. Also the song pearls before the swine some people are complaining it sounds metalcore but they honored at the gates more than any other metalcore band will. These veterans showed the kids how its done.

    • Names

      Rust in Peace shits all over Peace Sells. Big, nasty, stinky shits.

  • http://www.facebook.com/vforvicarious Matthew Kurtz

    Having your new album compared to South of Heaven in a positive way is something I’m sure Machine Head would be ecstatic about

    Great album. A true work of art and(sorry Mastodon) the album you should buy this week if you only got ten bucks in spending money

  • http://heavymetalist.com TheHeavyMetalist

    They lost the hardcore influence… That’s what is lacking…

  • Anthony

    Before I heard this album, the only MH albums I thought were really good to begin with were The Blackening and Through the Ashes of Empires, and even THAOE has a couple of tracks that I automatically skip over most of the time when they come up on my playlist. I’d say this album is on par with THAOE, maybe even a lower. So i’m not really all that dissapointed, as I didn’t expect this album to be as good as The Blackening. Everyone’s using the Slayer example (A band i’m not a fan of to begin with) and one commenter used Metallica, but the drop off in quality between these two MH albums is far greater than that between Master of Puppets and Justice. I think a good example is Devildriver going from Last Kind Words (an album i’ll take over Blackening any day of the week) to Pray for Villains.

    Oh, and while it’s fashionable to rip on Burning Red and Supercharger (something I don’t disagree with), Burn My Eyes is not much better, and is incredibly overrated. Other than “Old”, the album gets a big meh from me.

    • Pastor of Muppets

      THAOE?

      • Anthony

        TTAOE. My bad.

  • ReaperMan

     I like it more than The Blackening. Infact…

    Burn My Eyes (which is may favourite album ever that’s not called Master Of Puppets) > Through the Ashes Of Empires > The Locust > The Blackening > The More Things Change > The Burning Red > Supercharger

    The Guitar Tone is perfect and This Is Who We Are is fucking epic. I don’t know, The Blackening is a monster of an album and I do love it, it just never quite sat well with me, Locust is much tighter and I think there’s more emphasis on songs. I always thought Scandalous and Farewell to Arms were weak points on the Blackening, but I can’t pick one on the Locust. Album Of The Year.

    • Sasasa

      Agree 100% including the MH album order.

  • Ray

    I am in the same boat as everyone else.  It was basically impossible for this album to be as good as The Blackening.  With that being said, I think this album is great and is the best album I have heard this year.  I have been let down by so much metal this year its not even funny.  I Am Hell is one of my favorite songs on any Machine Head album so they did not miss by much.  Looking forward to 2012…..

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100001105796085 Brian Bearden

    Guess I DO need to listen to this one.  Need to get past the first tune anyway.  Just knowing that it’s not gonna be as good as The Blackening has sort of killed my need to make a B-line for it.  But I will eventually.

  • Plasmaterial

    Really dig the first four songs, track 5 is quite meh, track 6 redeems itself somewhat and the final track is quite good minus the choir bit and the fact the song is rather short (by MH standards) and ends quite abruptly. A lot of these songs should have been stretched out a couple more minutes each…the ideas behind them sound rather incomplete and that’s where this album fails in many respects. And the god-awful mixing job..

  • Hellwing

    Locust is a sick fucking record, its not as straightforwardly crushing as The Blackening, its more of a complex version, with less hook but more meat in its song writing. I can’t say for sure which is better. I worshipped the blackening and learned every song off it, looks like im gonna have to do it all over again.

  • lycanthrope

    Big Machine Head fan here and I had to force myself to listen this album for a third time.  What a disappointment! 7 songs really!?!? First off it would be nice if the first minute of I am Hell was track one -just so I could skip it. Most of the album sounds like outtakes from The Blackening, tons of recycled riffs and predictable song structures. Three good tracks.. damn that’s only half of the album that’s worth a shit.

    In this order metal nerds…
    1. BME
    2. The Blackening
    3. TTAOE
    4. TMTC
    5. TBR
    6. Locust
    7. Supercharger

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Tommy-Brown/663689567 Tommy Brown

      You put The Burning Red above Unto the Locust? -_-

      • lycanthrope

        The Burning Red has more than 3 good songs on it.

        • B-RAD IS RAD

          thats exactly how i felt the frst 3  listens. now after about 10 spins, id say all songs kick much ass. except for the last song. those kids are annoying.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=506384712 Shannon Lang

    I bought the Standard Edition of Unto the Locust (7 track version) on Friday because my Special Edition version (10 track & DVD) that I was meant to get on Preorder didn’t come in the fuckin mail.

    The album has been fantastic to say the least. My front speakers in the car are now shot and need to be replaced, lol… completely destroyed the cone on the left and sounds like arse, so it’s all faded to the back LOL!

    Like each Machine Head album, I’ve had to listen to it a few times to get the vibe of it and let it grow on me… I did that with all their albums (Supercharger not so much but yeah).

    FYI fellas, the “choir” isn’t a fuckin choir. It’s Robb’s kids and one of the other dude’s kids that was helping with the producing. The kids are like, all under 10 years old. I’d suggest that people watch the Special Edition DVD before you hang shit on that bit. I’m guessing that they wanted to involve their family in this album.

    I LOVE the album version of Locust… it just pounds you right out! There’s no use trying to compare this to The Blackening because as far as I’m concerned, they’re not trying to create The Blackening again. Ever since Robb’s been involved in the majority of producing the albums (TAOE and onwards) they’ve been VERY solid albums.

    I’ve only listened to each song 5-6 times each and I’ll give it a week or two longer before I’d make my final opinion on it, but if it’s like any other MH album I’ve bought, they usually get better and better as I listen to them :)

    Cheers to Machine Head for another fuckin awesome album!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Stephen-Poff/1225238069 Stephen Poff

    This is exactly how I feel. I think its the best follow up album to “The Blackening”. Its not as good but Its still a kick ass album. I’m so happy that they didn’t try and write another blackening. They did what they do best. Machine Head wrote Machine Head songs. These songs needed to be written and the only band to write them is MACHINE HEAD!!

  • Anonymous

    I like it, but I think it sounds too clean. The Blackening sounded..dirtier, I guess. I mean, it certainly isn’t raw or anything either, but it seems to have a much darker atmosphere to it. Everything sounds more violent.

    That said, I think this is far and away the best vocal performance Flynn has ever given and if anything will make me come back to this album more than the last, it’s the ridiculous step up in both vocal performance and melody composition.

  • Bobjob

    Can’t top 10 Ton Hammer. Dave McClain is the man! 

  • Helyeah

    Davidian is their best song and the last album was not that good. 
    Now go listen to some Coal Chamber or Snot

  • Tone

    If it ends up being the ‘South of Heaven’ to Machine Head’s ‘Reign in Blood’ then holy shit – we’ve got Machine Head’s ‘Seasons in the Abyss’ to look forward to! Review is spot on. Love the cover of ‘the Sentinel’ on the special edition.

  • Rick Javic

    It’s basically not possible for MH to top the Blackening so it was inevitable that everyone was going to have a big whinge about whatever they released next. Whatever. The truth is that ‘Unto The Locust’ is another excellent album from a band who rarely dissappoints and only suffers by comparison to what has come before it. Props to them for trying some different shit rather than standing still, I find it bothersome that everyone complains about the choir vocals and other assorted scallywag experimentation, if they were featuring in a SYL album you’d all be proclaiming it a stroke of genius. Oh wait, you already did.

    8/10.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100001506729462 Lars Kuperus

    i absolutely agree with you! great review!

    as for the songs:

    this is the end – im still not quite used to the anoying chorus
    pearls before the swine – great song.
    darkness within – i like it more than i expected because its not as whiney as this is the end.
    who we are – i don’t like the children singing but the rest of the song is awesome
    one of my favorites but its not really a worthy ending song.
    i am hell – is currently in my top 3 davidian, aestetics of hate, i am hell.

    locust and be still and know are just good songs don’t have many words for them.

  • Phoenix Blade

    Best fuckin’ part of this album is how no one can agree upon whether it’s better/worse than TB/TTAOE/BME, and everyone has their own particular favorite song (although it’s trending towards I Am Hell, which is a fucking beast and my new favorite).  Even the people who don’t think this album is the best MH album generally agree that it’s awesome.  For my own part, album sounds like it combines the best of TTAOE and TB, minus the egregiously awesome beast that was Halo (come on, that riff is just fucking disgustingly badass).  

    The review on this site was actually the most objective one I’ve read.  I disagree with the final score, but at the same time I’m such a damn fanboy that I sat in paroxysms of goosebumps on my first listen that I’m in no position to dispute whether it’s better or worse than The Blackening–although, for what it’s worth, this album hit me harder than TB did, about as hard as TTAOE did when I was in high school and realized with vicious glee that, “Machine Head is back!”  

    I don’t even try and compare Machine Head’s (last three and first two…) albums to each other anymore.  Machine Head is Machine Head, and it’s fuckin’ metal bliss.

  • http://intothevoidofwhiplash.blogspot.com/ Fred_Durst

    Even if this is the Chocolate Starfish to Machine Head’s Significant Other, it will still be a good album.

    • Reverend_MF

      Wan’t that Supercharger?

  • Bob

    “But even if it ends up being the South of Heaven to Machine Head’s Reign in Blood, that’s really not something about which to complain.”

    I would that’s a fair comment.  Still a monster album though!

  • brjoro

    listening to it now, through headphones, and it sounds amazing. if they hadn’t made ‘The Blackening’ this would be hailed as brilliant. For better or worse though, they did, and this doesn’t quite measure up so far. But it’s still got a great vibe, it’s heavy as fuck, great riffs, Flynn sounds great, Dave McClain is playing his ass off, it’s a great metal record. I think problem is that it’s impossible to listen objectively with ‘The Blackening’ in the back of your mind. But if we can listen to it somehow without that shadow looming over it, I think it’s going to be seen for what it is, one of the best metal records of 2011!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Brian-Earl/539260098 Brian Earl

    i certainly don’t share most of the opinions here as far as the “sub-par” idea goes… i’m not bashing any of you either, to each is own. but i find that this cycle had more depth and emotion than usual and in itself still is as brutal as ever. as far as my favorites go, this one is on top at the moment. i have a hard time playing anything else. i do wish they’d included 2-3 more songs (i’m not counting the covers or alt. versions), but even as is, its amazing in my ears.