SURVIVING MEMBERS OF NIRVANA ALL BUT ACCUSE COURTNEY LOVE OF SELLING KURT COBAIN’S CORPSE TO ACTIVISION

Friday, September 11th, 2009 at 2:30pm by

hey wait i got a new complaint

The Intarwebs have been buzzing and seething over the inclusion of Kurt Cobain as a playable character in Activision’s popular Guitar Hero video game, his digitized ghost forever doomed to perform Bon Jovi songs at the whim of teenage boys. Most rational people assumed that this perceived offense against the deceased grunge rocker was the fault of his widow Courtney Love, who would have had to sign off the creation of this virtual atrocity. When called out on this via Twitter, by British music journo and former Cobain family friend Everett True, the unflaggingly graceful Love took the usual high road and launched into an inscrutable six hour tweet seizure railing against, among other things, former Nirvana drummer Dave Grohl.

Anyone with a fucking brain in his skull (NO PUN INTENDED!) should immediately question the notion that Grohl has any control over Cobain’s likeness. Logically, that responsibility would rest with the executor of Cobain’s estate. But of course, we’re talkin’ about COURTNEY FUCKING LOVE here, so logic goes out the window from the start. Fortunately, Grohl and bassist Krist Novoselic have formulated a much more coherent response to the growing outrage expressed by Nirvana’s sanctimonious fans, most of whom have grown up to be the type of corporate sellouts that Cobain so obviously disdained.

From their joint statement (emphasis added by me):

We want people to know that we are dismayed and very disappointed in the way a facsimile of Kurt is used in the Guitar Hero game. The name and likeness of Kurt Cobain are the sole property of his estate – we have no control whatsoever in that area.

While we were aware of Kurt’s image being used with two Nirvana songs, we didn’t know players have the ability to unlock the character. This feature allows the character to be used with any kind of song the player wants. We urge Activision to do the right thing in “re-locking” Kurt’s character so that this won’t continue in the future.

It’s hard to watch an image of Kurt pantomiming other artists’ music alongside cartoon characters. Kurt Cobain wrote songs that hold a lot of meaning to people all over the world. We feel he deserves better.

Now it’s easy to read this quickly and reflexively assign all blame to Love, which is not entirely unfair. Yet assuredly, the statement suggests that the surviving members of Nirvana were at least aware of the Guitar Hero deal and in some capacity involved given the licensing of two of their songs for Cobain’s character to play. So now we need to ask ourselves the question: is it any less outrageous that Grohl and Novoselic participated in this evident cash-in if they only intended for the pixelated specter of their dead friend to play Nirvana songs?

Oh well, whatever. Nevermind. I’m still looking forward to that Bleach reissue.

-GS

[Gary Suarez killed your idols. He usually manages the consistently off-topic No Yoko No. Say, why don't you follow him on Twitter?]

  • Ryan

    the most ironic thing is that the dopes at activision actually would even think of the name Curt Cobain in a game called “guitar hero”. guitar hero of what? playing three power chords and pissing and moaning all day?

    • John

      He’s a guitar hero to millions of idiots that like shitty corporate rock posing as rebellious punk.

    • Trux

      The statement of the year !!… I could not agree with you more sir…

      • Trux

        and by that I mean the post of Ryan.

    • sYgnal

      +1

      BUT…Who really gives a shit. Nirvana sucked! And Guitar Hero is for pussies who don’t have the tenacity or intelligence to learn how to play a real instrument.

  • Failure

    I’m pretty sure…that if you’re willing to put a shotgun in your mouth, you don’t really give a fuck how people use your name after you’re dead. and who really gives a fuck anyway, i think we should still be talking about how courtney got away with murder…regardless if she shot him or not…any guy would kill themselves if they had to live with that piece of flesh attached to the black hole she calls a vagina

    • canea

      hahahhaha. nice.

    • Enjoy Guinness Extra Stout

      1

  • johnnywhoopass

    honestly….hes dead hes not gunna be bitching about anything and its not like their putting dildos on his face and making him touch dudes asses hes singing other peoples songs whoopee fuck most people who play that game dont even know who he is or haven’t even heard a nirvana song

    • Nate

      How would you feel if they put Dimebag in there playing some shitty alterna-rock songs… Dime playing Papa Roach, does that sit well with you? The point is, if they can do this with Kurt Cobain, they’ll eventually get to others.

      • http://infinitybasement.wordpress.com Jon

        Just you wait, Dime will be there eventually. I wonder if ppl realize that playing actual guitar is way more fun?

        • http://uponwingsofblack.blogspot.com/ \m/Eluveitie\m/

          At least on real guitar I don’t hafta worry about my orange button fucking up in the middle of a song

    • John

      I would be kind of interested in playing a game where you put dildos on kurt cobains face and making him touch dudes asses. Maybe if it was like a flash game or something..

      • orbital

        1

      • Enjoy Guinness Extra Stout

        I would be into that way more than Guitar Zero

  • http://uponwingsofblack.blogspot.com/ \m/Eluveitie\m/

    Courtney Love is suing Activision over Cobain’s likeness, she claims to be appalled by it

    • Kevin M

      I don’t think she really has a leg to stand on. Activision has responded stating that Ms. Love signed the contract allowing them to use him in the game herself. I guess she should have read the terms and conditions of the contract a little more carefully, and orchestrated a deal more to her liking much like the Hendrix estate did with the last Guitar Hero game. Although, I guess when you have as much heroin in your bloodstream as she does, you’re physically incapable of reading the terms and conditions outlined within a contract.

      • http://uponwingsofblack.blogspot.com/ \m/Eluveitie\m/

        From Activision’s response it did seem like they were on pretty solid legal footing, but it was interesting how MetalSucks never brought up this part of the story

  • Driven9

    damn Love is a whore

  • http://www.kingdomofnoise.blogspot.com MetalMatt

    I have Bleach on cassette.

    • http://www.metalsucks.net/category/scraping-genius-off-the-wheel/ Gary Suarez

      1

  • Sammy

    If Cobain did indeed have disdain for corporate sellouts, then he was a huge fucking hypocrite. Cobain was the king of “HEY LOOK AT ME……..WHAT ARE YOU LOOKING IT hypocrisy.

    Sign big record deal. Check!
    Make music videos. Check!
    Sign bigger record deal. Check!
    Do Rolling Stone cover interview. Check!
    Procure radio exposure. Check!
    Book world tours. Check!
    Complain about being famous. Check!

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Richard-He/749730660 Richard He

      Selling out = compromising the artistic value of one’s music in order to find greater mainstream appeal.

      Literally everything you listed is purely an example of how Nirvana gained mass exposure to the world. When Nevermind was written before all that, and an album as abrasive as In Utero came afterwards, how the hell did any of that lead to their music “selling out”? Could it be any more obvious that Cobain’s disillusionment with fame only made him MORE angry, as expressed through his music?

      Popularity is not selling out. Playing big venues is not selling out. Publicity is not selling out. Dumbing it down is – and if anything, Nirvana did the complete opposite.

      Or is it, in your opinion, better to remain kvlt in your garage than adored?

      • RyanK

        +1 to Richard He’s comment

      • http://infinitybasement.wordpress.com Jon

        + 2

      • Sammy

        My only opinion regarding anyone who replaces a “u” with a “v” (i.e., kvlt) or an “00″ for a long “u” is to be a sanctimonious prick who has no time for idiotic drivel. I realize you’re not using the term; rather you’re asking if I follow that line of thinking. So, no I don’t give a shit about trve, kvlt, br00tal or any other mentally challenged foolishness.

        As for your “selling out” argument, I agree with your points and grant that you make a very sound argument. I didn’t do a very good job of differentiating between creative selling out and corporate selling out.

        My disillusionment with Cobain is not regarding his band’s music, but rather for his constant whining for four years that he didn’t ask for the fame and popularity. That it was never his intention for that to become his life. To that I say “bullshit” and at the time often found myself saying, “Shut the fuck up, you whining twit.”

        Every retrospective I’ve read regarding his teenage years was full of friends commenting on his desire to be a rock star. Not that childhood friends are necessarily a good source of fact, but looking at his actions re: his life decisions, I’d say he did set out to be a rock star.

        As to your point regarding the music and that aspect not being a “sellout”, yes I do wholeheartedly agree with you. And to be fair, I do hold out the small benefit of the doubt that he was a victim of the “careful what you wish for” crowd. But he always came off to me as a petulant whiner. He did not have to record a third album, save for a lawsuit (but he could’ve pulled a Tom Sholz).

      • Sammy

        And by the way, I really no longer worry about the sellout factor with bands. It’s the only industry I can think of where its fans openly vilify artists for actually trying to make a living doing what they like to do. I don’t think U2 sold out by doing iPod adverts; quite the opposite. Their job is to make and then market their music.

        • http://www.last.fm/user/Richaod/ Richaod

          Ah, that sounds a LOT more reasonable now. I understand not wanting to take what Cobain said at face value, but there’s no doubt fame affected him – enough to drive him to suicide?

          and yeah, I’m generally fine with advertising as long as it doesn’t detract from the art itself. Vertigo not being too serious, it worked fine with the iPod ads – but naturally I’m glad they turned down Toyota ads wanting to use Where the Streets Have No Name.

      • timmah

        doesn’t anybody know what the song ‘rape me’ is about?

  • metalguy

    that line from teen spirit you typed is my favorite line ever. i dont know why. just throughing it out there

  • Lord Bling

    Let’s not forget that in Kurt’s suicide note, he basically said that he had no art left to give the world. Clearly, he was mistaken, cuz THIS is art!

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-UuAoEW5MbI&feature=fvw

    muwhahahahahahahaha

    YEAH BOYEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!

    • jason

      Mother of all that is holy. I was staying out of this as it seemed like a bit of a non-issue, but after watching :10 of that, I understand why people are so pissed off. That was a fucking abomination.

    • orbital

      stab my eyes out plz.

    • DustintheWind

      hahhahhaha, yeah Cobain is definitely rolling in his grave…

  • cookie

    Why are artists the only people not allowed to get paid for their work?

    Everyone else whores out their wares for money, but if an artist of any sort does it, they get massive piles of shit thrown at them.

  • bearbomb

    I HATE NIRVANA AND TYPE IN ALL CAPS! NOW CAN I BE COOL???!!

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Richard-He/749730660 Richard He

      +1. :D Jumping on the Nirvana hate bandwagon does not make you more “metal”.

      • bearbomb

        IS IT POSSIBLE TO BE COOL AND METAL??? IF SO, WHO DO I HAVE TO HATE?!

        • http://uponwingsofblack.blogspot.com/ \m/Eluveitie\m/

          If metal was cool, we wouldn’t listen to it

          • http://www.last.fm/user/Richaod/ Richaod

            If we were cool, we wouldn’t listen to metal? :P

            perhaps there is a difference – more like polar opposites – between an intelligent “cool” and the trendy “cool”?

          • http://uponwingsofblack.blogspot.com/ \m/Eluveitie\m/

            Don’t forget temperature “cool”

            But yes, I meant the trendy definition

          • bearbomb

            IT’S SO HARD TO FIND ACCEPTANCE IN THIS COOL/METAL/TROO/KVLT WORLD! WHAT ELSE MUST I DO? BTW FUCK JIMI HENDRIX, THAT NO TALENT HACK!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Richard-He/749730660 Richard He

    Great post, Gary, and good on your for not prematurely jumping to any conclusions. But if there’s one thing I gained from Courtney Love’s Twitterfest (apart from the realisation that no, the Foo Fighters are not anyone’s favourite band), it’s the sheer complexity and fucked-upness of the legal issues surrounding Cobain’s estate.

    I don’t remember details, really, except that according to Love, she said “design a better-looking avatar” to Activision (which they never did) to try and delay the process – she never had the intention of signing off on it. That and she called the whole thing “necrophilia”, and understandably seemed pretty fucking angry. Being famous doesn’t automatically create irrational people who always have ulterior motives, you know…

    • http://www.last.fm/user/Richaod/ Richaod

      okay, so I didn’t read the Gawker article. But no doubt Courtney’s side of the story is waaaaay more complex than it seems.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mark-Gavin/1396340262 Mark Gavin

    I don’t think I’ve given a shit about a Guitar Hero game since Rock Band 2 came out, and now I can play Painkiller or My Last Words whenever I want.

  • Pahkmycah

    Maybe if I learn how to make easy chords sound good I’ll get put into a Guitar Hero game!

  • http://www.welovemetal.com We Love Metal

    who cares, Kurt didn’t know if he was coming or going so I don’t think anyone is in a position to say what he would like or not like. All of them made a lot of money off Kurt’s death, this really isn’t that much different

  • Peter

    I do laugh at how theres three Kurts doing Sweating Bullets. That was a nice touch.

    However this is pretty much spitting on his career. Like someone said earlier they’re putting his corpse on puppet strings.

  • The Goat

    “… and was forced to live off her own feces.”

  • Bill

    Dave Grohl needs a quick payday? Huh, well I’ll be.

    • Brendan Seigel

      No, Grohl does not need a payday. He gets a pretty big fucking payday every time Foo Fighters plays a concert and every time they release a record. Not to mention his other band Them Crooked Vultures. Nor does Krist Noveselic, seeing as how he doesn’t give two shits about money (the man lives in a business-less rural town in Washington in his three bedroom house with wife and kids). They simply allow the music of Nirvana to be used because, believe it or not, they actually want more generations to hear and be inspired by their dead friend.

      Courtney, however, just wants more money to wipe her filthy cunt with in her three houses in New York City, Hollywood, and London.

      • Bill

        Couldn’t have said it better myself. I loved Nirvana when they were around and I still have a great respect for their music, even if I feel like I’ve grown out of it.

        • Enjoy Guinness Extra Stout

          Nirvana were\are souless corporate shills who sold their music so Butt-Hurt-Kurt and Courtney Hole could shoot more drugs into their veins.

  • Guy that knows way too many dead baby jokes

    Courtney killed Kurt

  • metalvinny

    A company like Activision wouldn’t make Cobain a playable character without SOME sort of approval.

  • dEV
  • Annie

    Whatever. Am I alone in thinking Kurt would love this shit? He probably would have thought it was hilarious. Because… it is …pretty hilarious.

  • http://reaper-x.deviantart.com/ Reaper-X

    I wonder what Steve Albini thinks…