NOW ANDOLS HERRICK IS OUT OF CHIMAIRA, TOO (AGAIN)

Wednesday, April 13th, 2011 at 6:09pm by

Alright, so I was out of the office this afternoon at a meeting, and I walk out and check my e-mail on my phone to find like a thousand e-mails from readers pointing us towards this post on The PRP, in which drummer Andols Herrick announces his departure from Chimaira.

Here are some excerpts from Herrick’s statement:

“Since Chris [Spicuzza, who announced his departure from the band last week] released his statement recently, I suppose its time that I do so as well since I have been dodging questions and comments for almost as long. I am no longer a member of Chimaira, and actually haven’t been since before Christmas. I did play at Chimaira Christmas 11, which was my last show. I certainly couldn’t have asked for a better and more memorable way to go out.

“I cannot stress enough how significantly different the circumstances are now than back in 2004. The short story is that the guys had taken issue with certain aspects of my role in the band. Nothing discussed was out of anger or anything personal, but I was definitely not expecting it and it was quite the spirit crusher for me. The decision was made that it would be in the band’s best interest to move forward without me.

“I was obviously devastated, but again there was no ill will between us. Later, I was asked to rejoin, but after some painful contemplation in my mind, I decided it was best not to. I started to see everything that happened as something that was ultimately positive. I share some of the same concerns that Chris mentioned in his statement, namely the current state of the music industry and concerns about my future.”

So as Herrick mentions, he’s already left the band once before; but he’s also the third member to part with Chimaira just since November — aside from the aforementioned split with keyboardist/programmer/hype man Spicuzza, bassist Jim LaMarca left the band late last year. Which basically means that the new Chimaira album will have a 50% different line-up than 2009′s The Infection did.

And yet I’m not especially worried about the ongoing quality of Chimaira’s music — in fact, as long as vocalist Mark Hunter and lead guitarist Rob Arnold are still in the band, I’d reckon everything is gonna be a-okay. (And I say that with all due respect to the other remaining member of the band, guitarist Matt DeVries.) Since Herrick says he doesn’t play on the new album, though, I am super curious as to who it was playing drums on those snippets of new music we heard earlier this month.

I’m also, of course, curious as to who the new drummer will be. Arnold and DeVries have been playing in Six Feet Under with Kevin Talley, who took Herrick’s place when he left the band the first time; is it possible that he’ll soon be making a return…?

Speculate recklessly in the comments section.

-AR

  • Tony

    Wow I’ve loved chimaira since the beginning, It’s kinda depressing seeing all this develop.

    • Brian

      Yeah…I am in the same boat, dude. This sucks. I agree with Axl that their sound will most likely remain unchanged, but this is still unnerving.

    • OLiNViLLE

      1

    • BTK666

      Yep

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/James-Butters-Mitchell/513886251 James Butters Mitchell

    FUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUCCCCCCCCCCCKKKKKKK.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/James-Butters-Mitchell/513886251 James Butters Mitchell

    I guess it could be cool to see new blood in the band, look at what the new drummer did for Trivium, I’m already more interested in their new album, their sound has evolved because of it. Maybe the same will happen here.

    • Brian

      True…but if you listen to all the Chimaira albums, no two are the same…each one is a change and evolution, which was happening with the whole band intact.

  • Matt S

    shit nu-metal band is shit

    • Broda

      Fail troll is fail.

      • Glorious Johnson

        your shit taste in music is shit.

        white trash dudes wearing beaters are not stoaked.

        • Matt S

          yeah, my taste sucks. from the guy who likes chimaira. hah. okay.

          • gloriousjohnson

            you’ve misunderstood who i was directing it too

            sorta like when your driving and honk at someone 3 cars ahead of you and everyone else around you gets pissed off

  • Andy Synn

    Fuck’s sake.

    I truly loved “The Infection” and felt it was such a good move for them, both professionally and artistically, to side-step the expectations drawn from their previous records. I was really looking forward to seeing them move on further with this shift in direction and now I’m concerned about their future, new album or no!

  • Michael Brodsky

    Wait, so if I got this right he got kicked out, then asked to rejoin and refused?

    • DecrystallizingReason

      Glad to see the band maintaining the utmost professionalism.

  • Ben

    This is just awful, awful news. Andols was one of the reasons I took up drumming, I sure hope he at least continues to do what he does best, and not take up video game programming….

  • Chainsword

    “And yet I’m not especially worried about the ongoing quality of Chimaira’s music — in fact, as long as vocalist Mark Hunter and lead guitarist Rob Arnold are still in the band, I’d reckon everything is gonna be a-okay. ”

    You just jinxed it. One of the two will leave before the new album comes out.

  • http://www.schenkeltown.com SchenkelTown

    mike portnoy already wears his hat backwards. he’s be a perfect fit.

    or maybe travis barker…yo.

  • http://Deconghost Tyler Lesniewski

    *Andols Herrick joins Six Feet Under* bahaha, oh the irony in that if it were to occurred

    • http://Deconghost Tyler Lesniewski

      *occur

  • Frank

    Goddamn. Chimaira is hands down one of my favorite bands of all time. It sucks so much to see all this shit going down. The Infection was the best album of 2009.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Shane-Tallent/100000411561578 Shane Tallent

      HUGE understatement, i think you are confusing that with Planetary Duality

  • d.o.g.o.b.g.y.n.

    PLEASE tell me this is some belated April Fool’s Joke.

  • MeesterDerp

    Kind of weird to see people so passionate about Chimaira. I never saw them as the highest caliber of metalcore, and personally I think they went completely downhill after their self titled. Though it is kind of a bummer that the band is falling apart. Going to listen to The Impossibility of Reason out of nostalgia now.

    • Brian

      “I never saw them as the highest caliber of metalcore” because they are not a metalcore band.

      • MeesterDerp

        They most definitely are.

        • http://myspace.com/theswampzombiecult Blake

          How so? They never struck me as metalcore in the least.

          • TheSkunkCatcher

            I second that, they are not metalcore

    • pixelate

      They don’t have enough sleeve tattoos in the band to be metalcore.

  • Plasmaterial

    Bring back Talley!

  • Skullkrusher

    Chimaira fucking sucks anyway…

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ian-Cimaglia/1097033911 Ian Cimaglia

      Hey. Fuck your shit.

  • samich

    wonder how much rob has to do with all these guys leaving? he seems like a asshole.

    • Butthurt

      I don’t think he’s necessarily an asshole, but in their documentary vids he seems like the one that takes the band the most seriously. Like he really wants them to become a legendary band (a la Slayer, Metallica). He’s a pusher.

  • theBear

    not too worried about chimaira. could care less about keyboards. Chimaira’s self titled album introduced a different drummer (Talley) and that is one of their strongest albums to date.

  • Adam

    Bummer, I really liked Andol’s drumming!

  • Hugh Al

    Emil Werstler is apparently the new bassist for Chimaira, I’m not making this up, check his personal facebook page, he added Chimaira to his employee as bassist couple of days ago.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ben-Goodkind/71106456 Ben Goodkind

      Holy fuck, you are right. I was concerned about Daath with Talley in SFU, and now Emil is playing in bass in Chimaira? wtf?

  • Marco

    What really concerns me about both their statements is that one of the reasons to leave would be “he current state of the music industry”.
    I mean, have we reached a point where musicians simply give up playing, because it´s not worth it in terms of making a living due to non-existing cd-sales?

    • cougar party

      Unfortunately, I think this will become more and more common of a reason to break up or leave a band. Since you have to be in the top 1% to make enough to live off your music, I think we are going to see a lot of bands/musicians play for 5-10 years and if they aren’t making a good living, they’ll give it up in order to pursue a more lucrative career. Sad, but I don’t see things changing for the better.

      • paganheart

        Agreed. In addition I think it’s pretty obvious if you watch Chimaira’s DVDs or follow them at all that Andols hates touring, and he especially hates going overseas. These days if you are going to make any sort of living as a musician, it seems like you have to be willing to literally tour the world. It’s not enough to just play North America and Europe and maybe Japan or Austrailia, you have to be willing to go to places like the Phillipines, Indonesia, China, India and even freaking Dubai to make a living. No disrespect at all to any of those countries–fuck it’s great to know that there are metal fans in all of those places!–but that kind of travel is absolutely brutal, and it’s not a life that everyone wants. Especially as you grow up and get older and start wanting to settle down and maybe have a family (and I believe Andols and Jim each got married recently.)

        So again, as with Chris, good for Andols for knowing it was time to move on, and doing so with class. He’s a hell of a drummer and hopefully he will be able to continue playing and teaching. I wish him the best, and as others have noted, as long as Mark and Rob–and Matt!–are at the core of Chimaira, the music is going to be great. (And if the rumors are true about Kevin Talley and Emil Werstler joining the band, so much the better!)

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Brandon-Clevenstine/100000864925742 Brandon Clevenstine

    I’m so fucking pissed right now!!!! Why does Chimaira have to fall apart!!?

  • AARONIUS

    HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!! Who didn’t see this coming? Didn’t Hunter release a statement just last week saying everything was peachy? I like Chimaira (though I’m kind of burnt out on them now) but I think there are serious relationship issues these guys need to deal with.

  • raiseyerfists

    Time to break up! Peace out, don’t let the door hit you in the ass.

  • Ray Peterson212

    I follow Hunter on Twitter and apparently he is going to announce something today about Chimaira. This is fucking depressing. This was my most anticipated album of the year BY FAR and now I’m getting my balls broke. If Talley rejoins Chimaira, what does that mean for Daath?

    • raiseyerfists

      Hopefully means the world has one mediocre band instead of two.

      • the rob

        there are many more medicore bands in metal than great ones.

  • Dissolution

    We had the honor of playing with Chimaira this last June in Portland.

    The show was not empty – but it was NOT packed either. They played with Shadows Fall too. Tickets were…$16? I think before hand. The promoter lost money on the show. They’re just not pulling it (most aren’t).

    So metal fans………..get off your ass and go buy CDs and support – don’t be elitist or we’ll kill the genre we know and love. Its sad.

    • cougar party

      What is the name of your band?

  • Slaughterhouse

    Wow, this is sad sad news. I hope the band continues to move forward. I guess they will since he stated that he has not been in the band since December. I love Chimaira but Mark and Rob do seem to be kind of control freaks and assholes at times

  • willd

    People need to stop cheating at life and buy music. Musicians make the music, and its their career. They deserve the money for their work.

    If i went to work everyday and people were stealing my pay, I’d be pissed. Fuck all you cheap ass bastards. Get a job, stop buying weed,

  • BigEvilMetalhead

    A little birdy told me that Austin D’Amond from Bleed The Sky/The Elite (featuring members of Chimaira) will more than likely be taking his place… Don’t quote me on it though.. ha..