METTA MIND JOURNAL: CYNIC’S PAUL MASVIDAL ON LEARNING FROM FRIENDS, ENEMIES AND YOURSELF

Friday, May 28th, 2010 at 1:00pm by


*Compassionate Discrimination

*Compassionate Discrimination: Having astute judgment without being scornfully judgmental; seeing difficult truths about a situation or person without closing your heart or feeling superior. In the words of Alan Jones: having the ability “to smell a rat without allowing your ability to discern deception sour your vision of the glory and joy that is everyone’s birthright.” —from “The Outlaw Catalog of Cagey Optimism” in Rob Brezsny’s book, Pronoia Is the Antidote for Paranoia.

When I was younger, I would easily become attached to people when I first met them, especially if I felt we had a connection—and I would often cry when I had to say good-bye to someone I felt connected to. I still occasionally cry when I’m saying bye to a friend I may not be seeing again for an indefinite period of time. The good-byes are encapsulated mini-deaths that force me to let go. Perhaps the attachment stems from a childhood of constant renewal, instability, and change. It’s the kid in me wanting to hold on for just one more minute because back then, I never could. Eventually, I learned that friendships change and evolve in their own unique way.

I’ve been thinking about what it means to have friends, what it means to be one—and how we often think that we’ll know our friends for a lifetime, or that they’ll always be around. The truth is, like everything in life, our closest friendships are always changing and growing, and may eventually end. Some friendships will grow apart and other people I never felt close to may someday grow near.

Some friendships take more energy, others have a historical purpose or connection. Some friendships turn sour because of perceived slights, outright betrayal, while others fade away from natural decay. Often, friends become closer to us than our own family members, while other friends have hearts that harden themselves in silence, and as time goes on, it becomes more difficult to reach meaningful truth and intimacy.

Certain events can sometimes push a friendship out of bounds and into the realm of open enemy, as though the initial bonding was more like a meeting of near enemies who just needed the ignition of a single ill happening to affirm the destruction of the “friendship.” I wonder how many enemies I have out there…people who don’t like me because they believe I wronged them somehow?

I can’t think of anyone who I would consider to be my enemy, but have certainly encountered people who I’ve had no interest in getting to know better, while others I’ve found to be plain annoying. The people who fall into these categories are the ones who try really hard to suppress their anger by being extra nice. They come off as being fake—and difficult to trust.

Note: There are humans out there who are genetically predisposed to have naturally happy personalities. That’s a different quality from what I’m articulating here.

But it’s the annoying ones who actually become my teachers. They provide me with an opportunity to see where I’m stuck. It’s through them that I find out where I’m being judgmental, or justifying a sense of self-importance by believing that on some level, I’m more clever than they are.

So I get to meet the enemy, only to discover that the enemy is me. I meet the friend and find that he is me, too. When I learn how to befriend myself, I can better see my confusion: blaming someone else and thinking it would make me happy.

The flip side of a disingenuous “happy” person is a dark shadow that hasn’t been befriended—our own best enemy is right in the center of our hearts that we haven’t become intimate with. Inevitably, the monster surfaces. I’ve unleashed this monster in the past by pushing away or attacking everything I was afraid of. Back then I would let the Kraken sabotage everything good around me. And when everything was dead, I torched the earth for good measure. A Plutonian kind of purification.

I eventually grew tired of chasing drama and found that a little more kindness toward myself went a long way. It clicked that if I don’t reinforce thoughts that make me feel unworthy or useless as a human being, I’ll get into a lot less trouble.

So how do we cope with frenemies when our backs are up against the wall? Can we take the high road when our egos are being compressed? It’s OK if we’re still angry after all these years. We can even be jealous and timid and feel completely unworthy. The trick for me is finding a way to be OK with all these feelings and, most of all, befriending all parts of myself.

Even the ugliest monster who wants to hit back is allowed to feel that way.

I’m not here to edit a personality and try to mold myself into the shape of a perfect person. I’m here to accept who I am, flaws and all. My relationship to the outer world begins and ends with me. There’s nothing precious about this relationship. It’s very real and messy.

I can stop struggling with the “other” and see its true face without calling it “the enemy.” I can stop rejecting the parts of me that I find difficult to accept. I can surrender to the nature of reality as it is right now and see that it’s OK. There’s nowhere to hide and nothing to do other than allow life to be as it is right now. I can relax with the way things are. There’s nothing passive about this approach to reality. It’s actually quite intense because there’s nothing to hold onto.

I can’t deceive myself when I’m willing to step onto this narrow ridge…like tip-toeing up to the edge of a cliff with an open heart that’s no longer afraid.

  • evilfatguy

    The first step to mastering your ego is recognising that it’s there. You don’t have to be emotionless, but you also don’t have to be a slave to your emotions. Seeing them as they enter your mind and acknowledging what triggered them is a big step in making healthy, conscious decisions in your life.
    I’ve found, over the years and after much reflection, that anyone I have a particular aversion to is actually quite similar in many ways to myself.

    I really appreciate your columns, Paul, and they continue to be the main reason that I read this site midweek.

    • >_>

      “I’ve found, over the years and after much reflection, that anyone I have a particular aversion to is actually quite similar in many ways to myself.”

      Not sure if this is what Randy (LoG vocalist) was talking about, but this very reflection is the reasons why I like the lyrics “I will kill this part of myself that I hate and that I see in you” off of the Blacken the Cursed Sun song.

      • TonyT

        Yea I don’t remember where I heard it but there is a quote out there that basically says 99% of the time you hate a person for two reasons either 1. Because they are just the opposite of you….or 2. they are just like you. so take that for what you will.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Nick-Carosello/1360764011 Nick Carosello

    very good read Paul. I love the METTA MIND JOURNAL

  • Shnaz

    As usual, awesome blog.

  • Alex_P

    Compassionate discrimination sounds like a new Republican policy…

    Regardless, this is an excellent post, and I’m glad you took the time to write it. There are lots of people I dislike or have no interest in knowing, but I think the only person I’ve actively hated is this guy who cost me my job through his betrayal (and it was a sweet job too). Of course, this is a guy of very little intelligence and very little education (we all know these things are different but connected), a kid who grew up in Surrey, which is basically the worst city in British Columbia, overrun with gangs and violence. The result was that he was the sort of person with no ambition. I sometimes have to step back, and wonder if he wasn’t aware of what he was doing when he begged for his job at my expense. At 17, I’m sure I would have killed him if I saw him again. Now, at 19? I’m not sure I care anymore. The difference it made to me was about 2 grand. Time brings perspective.

    • evilfatguy

      Surrey is pretty far from the worst city in BC, but I hear where you’re coming from. He was perfectly aware of what he was doing, but in his mind, it wasn’t wrong or unjust, because it meant that HE got to have a job and HE got to make money. (I also have to question the circumstances surrounding your employment if one guy begging in some way meant that you lost your job?)
      Experience will teach you that hating anyone for any reason is a HUGE waste of mental and emotional resources. When you free up those resources, you become much more stable and efficient in your interactions with life.
      Who knows? You might meet that guy again some day and you two will become very good friends.

      P.S. I’ve known many more articulate, intelligent individuals from Surrey than any other type.

      • Alex_P

        There’s good people everywhere, of course, and I’ve known good people from Surrey. I don’t ever want to see him again, though. I don’t really give a shit about him any more.

        It was construction, which is why it was so dear to me. What happened was that he got fired in front of me (I was sweeping up the site, he comes and talks to me, foreman spots us and lays him off but not me, because I was doing my job). He went to the union boss and complained. The union we had is a pathetic weakling, and so he decided to lay me off as well to avoid any disputes and also avoid having to rehire a guy that incompetent.

        At least he didn’t get his job back.

        • evilfatguy

          Ahhhh yeah. That’s also construction for you. The funny part is, you could have gone to the union and claimed you were fired because someone was talking to you while you were doing your job, but it’s all just needless drama anyways. Construction jobs are a dime a dozen.

    • Meathead

      I guess the Surrey way would be to light up a doobie, drive your rust bucket piece of shit Dodge down to his baby momma’s house where he’s crashing on the couch and beat him up with your 12 angriest friends?

      Surrey is great. The public’s perception is so grossly misinformed. Walk down Hastings by Carnegie hall, middle of the day. The street market. There isn’t a worse place in BC for homelessness, drugs, prostitution, disease, and gangs.

      Random fact: The Quizno’s at Boundary and Hastings is the only one in Canada to install bullet proof glass.

      • Alex_P

        I fucking hate Vancouver as well, man: I grew up there. Hastings and Main will desensitize you to the world, right next to skyrocketing properties. I grew up in the Killarney area mostly, and it was interminable. Now that I live in Montreal, the quality of my life has improved.

        Like I’ve said: I’ve met tons of great people from Surrey. We have this perception because of all the violence, gangs and general bullshit. I’m sure there’s nicer parts to it, and I know many people come out of it okay.

        This guy really was the Surrey stereotype. Drug-addled, high-school drop-out, demeaning attitude towards women, crime, etc. I’m well aware that not everyone is like that, and I’m sorry if I promoted that image.

        • evilfatguy

          I fucking love Vancouver, but that’s cause I’m originally from the Nanaimo area. I would like to spend some time in Montreal, cause I’ve heard nothing but good things about it.

      • evilfatguy

        As for Surrey, I think people read “car theft capital of North America” and instantly think “scummy shithole”.
        I lived on the corner of Carrall and Cordova (a block from Pigeon Park) for two years, and I can safely say that you don’t know juxtaposition until you pay rent for a normal place in that neighbourhood. About three times a week, I stepped over a passed-out junkie to get into my apartment building. And yeah, the steps of Carnegie Centre are… impressive.

  • Drakodan

    Fantastic, and also very accurate.

  • http://myspace.com/jasonhoopes Jason

    The best. I needed to read this, particularly this morning. Thank you, Paul. Cheers to all.

    • brookh

      Agreed, this is so relevant to so many people. Thank you Paul.

      • http://www.facebook.com/alanbfoxy Alan

        It’s relevant to literally everyone. Unfortunately a lot of people I know (metalheads included) probably wouldn’t be able to read through something like this. Too touchy-feely :P

  • WarPlanRed

    Paul, You latest blog has spoken to me on a very personal level, I feel very much the same way about life and the people in it. Your blogs sum up alot of how I feel towards life, so I thank you. Ive been a fan of your music for a long time, and you more recent work with Cynic has help me through some dark times in my life and some bright (my baby girls birth) so thank you again for doing what you do. Its just nice to know that theres people out there that share the same views and ideas, especailly in the world we live in today….If you ever tour anywheres near northern Alberta canada, I will hike through the rockies and tundra to see Cynic in the flesh

  • EJ666

    This is the kind of piece which at different levels, we can all relate to.

    Great job Paul.

  • Sam

    When I was reading this it was hard not to think of my personal experience with a deteriorated friendship. I used to be good friends with this kid because we had a lot of classes together, but the next year we didn’t have any of the same courses. When I tried to maintain a friendship by hanging out with him and some of his other friends who I honestly wouldn’t have liked too much ordinarily, he began ignoring me because I didn’t quite mesh into this group. He and I had bonded over things that were completely different than what he and this group of kids bonded over, so it was hard to put both together. We got into some verbal fights, and stopped talking to one another eventually.

    This was a classic case of somebody acting like a total douchebag around other friends but in a one on one situation is actually pretty cool. It’s hard to know what to feel for such a person; half of me says he should go fuck himself, but the other half somewhat wishes we could still be friends. If this ex-friend ever approached me again, does he deserve a cold response on my part, or should I reengage in friendly conversation as if he never hurt me in the first place?

    Paul’s conclusion on such matters seems to be the best, but at the same time the most difficult, which is to acknowledge what happened and leave it as simply an experience in my past. Not denying its occurrence, but moving on and focusing what is good in my life instead of writhing in bitterness.

    Thanks for the post Paul, once again you have presented a very mature piece of introspection, prompted me and many other fans to reflect on how your thoughts apply to our own lives.

  • Carly

    Excellent insights Paul. Thank you for sharing your process and how it continues. So many priceless points and/or reminders. Reading, writing and/or communicating with friends about these internal monsters/enemies of our own and how we function with them rather than beating them back is damn good medicine.

    Respects to all.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jacquelin-Rostad/635209883 Jacquelin Rostad

    One of my best friendships lasted only a month. Years ago, a girl at work who I’d never talked to before asked what I was doing that weekend. We clicked instantly, and even though we just met, it felt like we’d known each other for years. We hung out almost every day for a month, even took a road trip together, and then it ended as abruptly as it started… as far as I know, with no real ill will between us. Some people are only meant to be in our lives for a season, I think. With other good friends, I can go years and years without talking to them, and when I see them again it’s like there’s no gap.

    The whole thing about “I can stop rejecting the parts of me I find difficult to accept”…. still working on that. Probably for a long time. It’s hard to look at those ugly parts of our souls and move from “I suck” to “I’m human,” but it’s so much easier to be in the world when we do.

    Great post, as always!

  • SourDeez

    Nice topic. I’ve been dealing with issues of this nature myself, and I’m sure anyone who’s ever had friends since early childhood has also experienced this. I have a whole crew of very close friends who I’ve known since elementary school, and we’ve had all kinds of crazy experiences together at different ages which cemented the bonds between us. But now, we’re all about to graduate from different colleges in different places, and so for the first time we’ve all had 4 years of drastically different experiences from each other. Our crew is still intact, but sometimes I can’t help but wonder if we’ll really be a crew forever. The sad truth is probably not. It’s just crazy looking back on how many important experiences we’ve been through while growing up together in the same city: Everything from playing basketball and having birthday parties together as kids up to experimenting with drugs, getting arrested together, losing our respective virginities, getting into college, and getting jobs. When you grow up with people, you see each other change and mature and grow in different directions. We’ve all seen each other’s highs and lows. It saddens me to think that there may come a time when all of that is history.

    • Doc Coyle

      Is this your life or the plot from American Pie? J/K haha

      • TonyT

        LOL +1

      • SourDeez

        Actually, my teenage years did kind of parallel the plot from American Pie, minus the awkward father, pie fucking, and the suburbs. Plus a lot more weed and Iron Maiden.

  • skychild

    I’ll say it again, Paul Masvidal should write a book. You have a great writing style that draws the reader in. It’s honest. With that said, I wouldn’t want you to take up writing books if it meant giving up writing songs. Btw, I just got a copy of your new ep Re-Traced. I totally dig it. Great to hear the beauty of TIA songs in a purer form.

    • Michiel

      I was just about to write this. A very honest and insightful piece yet again.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Michael-Brady/5027798 Michael Brady

    Paul, if you ever decide to call it quits with the music, you DEFINITELY need to start touring the country as a lecturer. Sort of the antithesis to Henry Rollins, if you will.

    Yet another amazing entry in this series. Every single time I sit down to read one of your articles, I walk away from it with a new perspective…and as a slightly better person for it, I dare say. Thank you so much for these.

  • large jockstrap

    thanks for writing this paul. I’ve just had a dear and fairly old friendship fall to pieces, and now i understand why… thankyou so much.

  • DustintheWind

    Very insightful Paul, been goin through alot lately and i can definitely relate. Really enjoyed the read, thanks

  • satansspit

    The brand Billabong has a slogan, “only a surfer knows the feeling” I’ve always thought good ( drug induced, phycotic, from the subconcious) metal lyrics, have tapped into a kind of mindspace where “only a metalhead knows the feeling”. This guy goes a long way into putting those feeling into words. In my opinion.

  • Chris

    Reading this brings a sense of Irony for me, as I am just about to lose a friend who pretty much hits all the criteria that Paul has mentioned. On meeting this person for the first time they actually annoyed me but through circumstance became someone who I considered one of my closest friends whom I ended up living with. This took a u-turn about a year ago because of a fall out with their Significant other. She then moved out for some reason and started a new group of friends and her personality seemed to change as when she hung out with us she never wanted to go out and could be seen as a reclusive person which I was fine with but with her new friends she started going out all the time, Drinking (something she had done with us four times in four years) yada yada yada. This brought on the aforementioned sense of unworthiness because after four years we (my housemate and I) appear to be worthless and of little to no significance or meaning to her, why would she hold us in so little regard in comparison to people she’d known for a couple months. This is something that came to loggerheads in January when she tried to have fun my expense by alienating me purposefully in front of my friends I cannot understand why she did it or what was she was trying to achieve. In fairness I reacted badly as I don’t appreciate BS like that we patched things up and have spoke possibly three times since.

    Anyway recently I find out she is leaving the country and I will probably never see her again and I can’t help but get a feeling we wont even say our goodbyes. This upset me at first but on reflection I realise the person that I saw as my closest friend left a long time ago and I was just trying to cling on to that ‘one more minute’. This got me thinking that instead of trying to figure her out I should try figure out myself and what will be is what will be.

    Again another though provoking and inspiring Metta Mind Journal from the great one.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ben-King/100000649235007 Ben King

    I wonder what Gene Simmons would think of this artcle?
    As always Paul, the best post of the week award goes to you.

  • paganheart

    “I can stop struggling with the “other” and see its true face without calling it “the enemy.” I can stop rejecting the parts of me that I find difficult to accept. I can surrender to the nature of reality as it is right now and see that it’s OK.”

    I need to write that down and put it somewhere that I’ll see it every day. :-) I had a counselor once ask me, “would you talk to a friend the way you talk to yourself?” I have been working through some serious issues the past few years that largely came from not being able to accept myself, or at least parts of myself. There is a tendency to ignore those dark and unpleasant aspects of ourselves, or hide from them, or distract ourselves from them in destructive ways, or beat ourselves brutally over them. But unless we face the reality of who we are, even those parts that are deepy flawed, and learn to accept them, we have trouble liking, accepting, or even loving others. But doing that can be really, really hard and it’s scary as hell.

    I totally agree with Paul, those people who annoy us or provoke an intense dislike almost immediately have something to teach us. I read once that when we feel an intense dislike for someone, it’s often because there is something in that person that reminds of something in ourselves, probably something we don’t like. I know that’s definitely true for me.

    More food for thought…excellent column as usual. Thank you, Paul.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Francisco-Boni-Neto/1502963451 Francisco Boni Neto

    “But the worst enemy you can encounter will always be you, yourself; you lie in wait for yourself in caves and woods.” F. Nietzsche from Thus Spoke Zarathustra

    The Buddha said the same: “More than those who hate you, more than all your enemies, an undisciplined mind does greater harm.”

    And you can learn more about yourself through an enemy. The observer is the observed. Often you learn more about yourself through your self-identification with enemies, possesions.

  • John

    Incredible writing…this is something I needed to read today. I’m almost choked up

  • WowWee!

    First time I read your blog and I like it. I guess the subject caught my eye and I felt like I needed to read it and it’s a good thing I did.

    One thing I was looking for is how to deal with a physical enemy who is insane (like shit balls looney) and threatening my life because thats a situation I’m unfortunately in.

    Anyways good read and thanks for the enlightenment.

  • Joey

    Thanks Paul. This was exactly what I was looking for. I found it very difficult to put into words, but you across methodically and with lots of clarity. Thank you!

  • Joey

    *but you put it across

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ricky-Brito/100000087180456 Ricky Brito

    Sometimes i find myself suppressing emotions that are stirred by people that are different from me, or that they are overly arrogant, or that they are cruel to others in a vampire like way. I myself will not be burdened by other’s opinions of myself or their intentions to drain my vitality to lift their own egos. But sometimes i see people drained from these vampires and i would like to share with them the knowledge of our equality and our equal value and worth as a life in and of it’self. But that such a personal revelation that i cannot console the person who had received the bite. But then i realize that there are two spectrum, there is consoling needed by the vampire, they are conflicted and hateful to themselves to the point they have to drain life-force from others, “temporary appeasing life-force”. Unless personally we conclude compassion and love is the only thing of value that we will carry with us through death, people are equally conflicted because they are blocking their universal Selfs from speaking to the universe. So where do i go from here? Who do i try to help? I do not know the answer, maybe it’s not my place to help either of them. Maybe nothing i say will console them, but maybe they will embrace the love within all of us and they will purge themselves of these human emotions of insecurity or arrogance on their own. Maybe not. I hate to sit back and watch my species hurt and kill each other, so i guess i will just go with my gut, and not contribute to the parasitic behaviors that are so plenty around all of us. These fellings stirred by others, it is one of my flaws. I am not at the level of awareness that you are Paul, but i hope one day i will find a way to accept this as one of my human flaws and dig deeper into my Self and find peace with my place and time in this life, moment, reality. I love the posts! And your music, nothing else like it. It speaks to me, you inspires me to challenge myself into peering into my mortal cup of mind *wink*. <3 Cynic <3

  • Brine B

    Fuck ‘em if they can’t take a joke. Dio’s death hit me harder simply because of my history with him as a fucking LEGEND. Gray’s demise is pretty bad too. Listened to a shitload of the Slip in my time.

    R.I.P. ….to both of ‘em.

  • Jonathan

    You guys think this is amazing writing? The subject material and presentation is nice, but there’s something called focus that this blog right here lacks. It jumps around from corporate discrimination, to friendships, to people you don’t like and then to teachers, and then to the ego. Now, yes, you can draw a line of logic from one to the other, but… it wasn’t done very well.

    First time in a while I’ve been disappointed with one of these, Paul.

    • SKYCHILD

      You’re in the minority here, ye Professor of Creative Writing.

  • http://www.conorschaefer.com/blog/ Conor

    I don’t have anything deep to say, but I wanted to comment in support of more Metta Mind Journal. Stuff like this will always keep me coming back.

  • http://www.conorschaefer.com/blog/ Conor

    Oh, I know: I’ve long said to myself that “I lack the ability to perceive in another person a fault which I myself do not possess.” This resonates in me when I read your post.

  • Emptyness and Stillness

    Paul,please don’t stop writing here,it’s very inspiring.

  • Andros

    Paul, keep writing when you have some free time brother. I actualize this blog each day but its been a long time since the last thread is done. Sorry for my english.

    Saludos

  • Virginia

    Paul – I found you in a strange way while using search engine to find more Metta work.  There you were – nice, I said – then I saw it was HEAVY Metal and my 66 year old lady brain when OH NO !  But, with open mind I began to read and I am blessed to say that our teachings come in so many ways.  Both Pema Chodron and Tara Brach keep saying this. If today’s journey is an example, then it is true.